Buying a car Where should you buy a new car?

With a dizzying range of options it can be difficult to know where to buy...

With a dizzying range of options it can be difficult to know where to buy...

Buying a car from a local dealer may be the easiest option, but is it the best? We’ve weighed up the pros and cons of the other options open to you when buying a new car to find out.

Buying a car from franchised dealers

Customer service counts for a lot, and many people return to the main dealers they know if they've had good previous experiences.

Pros

  • Face-to-face service; someone to answer questions
  • Order the exact specification you want
  • Wide choice of cars to look at and test-drive
  • Easy to part exchange your old car
  • Best comeback if things go wrong

Cons

  • Expensive – but haggle hard and you can usually get a fair discount
  • Selling your old car privately usually beats part-exchange values

Buying a car from brokers

Telephone- and can deliver a bargain to your door – if you can make do without the personal service you’ll get from a dealer.

Pros

  • You can save thousands of pounds on main dealer prices
  • Most now source cars from other UK dealers, so it’s easy to compare prices and specs
  • You can usually order the specification you want
  • One-stop shop for many different makes and models

Cons

  • No test drives available and limited personal contact
  • Delivery times and fees can vary – check up front
  • Not many offer a part-exchange service

Buying a car from car supermarkets

Supermarkets are a growing threat to established car dealers. Their stock is mainly used, though many also sell factory-fresh and pre-registered cars (those already registered but with only delivery mileage).

Pros

  • Very competitive prices – especially compared with main dealers
  • Lots of makes and models on one site
  • Test drives are available – though rarely offered
  • Most offer finance packages
  • Drive the car away the same day

Cons

  • Choice depends on what’s in stock
  • ‘No-frills’ approach to customer service in most cases
  • New cars may be imports, so check for full UK specification
  • Clock will already be running on pre-registered cars’ warranties

Buying a car from import agents

You can still save thousands on some cars by buying from dealers in other EU countries. An import agent should make the process easier.

Pros

  • Can source big discounts from other EU countries
  • Saves you hassle on paperwork, negotiation and collection
  • Will usually deliver to your door

Cons

  • Importing can be time-consuming and delivery times long
  • Comparing prices is tricky due to currency fluctuations and equipment differences across countries
  • Agent may want a large deposit before confirming delivery date

More on this...

Other sections in this guide

  1. Overview
  2. Buying a car
  3. Buying a car with dealer finance
  4. Independent car finance
  5. Where should you buy a new car?
  6. Should I buy a pre-registered car?

Trial Which? today

Latest Which? Car magazine cover

Try Which? magazine for just £1 and gain instant access to which.co.uk

About Which? magazine

Which? Car podcast

Listen to our latest FREE 10-minute digest of all the most important car news and reviews.

Listen to a podcast now

Which? car news

Sign up for the latest car news and reviews, and money-saving hot car deals, in your newsletter every Friday.

Sign up to Which? Car news
Which? works for you