Buying a car Where should you buy a new car?

With a dizzying range of options it can be difficult to know where to buy...

With a dizzying range of options it can be difficult to know where to buy...

Buying a car from a local dealer may be the easiest option, but is it the best? We’ve weighed up the pros and cons of the other options open to you when buying a new car to find out.

Buying a car from franchised dealers

Customer service counts for a lot, and many people return to the main dealers they know if they've had good previous experiences.

Pros

  • Face-to-face service; someone to answer questions
  • Order the exact specification you want
  • Wide choice of cars to look at and test-drive
  • Easy to part exchange your old car
  • Best comeback if things go wrong

Cons

  • Expensive – but haggle hard and you can usually get a fair discount
  • Selling your old car privately usually beats part-exchange values

Buying a car from brokers

Telephone- and can deliver a bargain to your door – if you can make do without the personal service you’ll get from a dealer.

Pros

  • You can save thousands of pounds on main dealer prices
  • Most now source cars from other UK dealers, so it’s easy to compare prices and specs
  • You can usually order the specification you want
  • One-stop shop for many different makes and models

Cons

  • No test drives available and limited personal contact
  • Delivery times and fees can vary – check up front
  • Not many offer a part-exchange service

Buying a car from car supermarkets

Supermarkets are a growing threat to established car dealers. Their stock is mainly used, though many also sell factory-fresh and pre-registered cars (those already registered but with only delivery mileage).

Pros

  • Very competitive prices – especially compared with main dealers
  • Lots of makes and models on one site
  • Test drives are available – though rarely offered
  • Most offer finance packages
  • Drive the car away the same day

Cons

  • Choice depends on what’s in stock
  • ‘No-frills’ approach to customer service in most cases
  • New cars may be imports, so check for full UK specification
  • Clock will already be running on pre-registered cars’ warranties

Buying a car from import agents

You can still save thousands on some cars by buying from dealers in other EU countries. An import agent should make the process easier.

Pros

  • Can source big discounts from other EU countries
  • Saves you hassle on paperwork, negotiation and collection
  • Will usually deliver to your door

Cons

  • Importing can be time-consuming and delivery times long
  • Comparing prices is tricky due to currency fluctuations and equipment differences across countries
  • Agent may want a large deposit before confirming delivery date

Other sections in this guide

  1. Overview
  2. Buying a car
  3. Buying a car with dealer finance
  4. Independent car finance
  5. Where should you buy a new car?
  6. Should I buy a pre-registered car?
Latest Which? Car magazine cover

Which? Car magazine

In the latest issue we investigate car recalls and reveal how to cut the cost of motoring.

About Which? Car magazine

Which? Car podcast

Listen to our FREE 10-minute digest of all the latest car news and reviews every month.

Listen to a podcast now

Which? car news and Twitter feed

Sign up for the latest car news, reviews and hot deals in your newsletter every Friday. Also, follow Which? Car Insider on Twitter

Which? works for you