Garden centres Best garden centres

Which? Archive

This article, Garden centres, was last updated on 24 March 2011 and is now out of date and held in our online archive for reference. Explore our latest Home & garden articles.

Find the best garden centre near you - our ratings table ranks over 60 garden centres from around the country, based on the views of more than 7,000 Which? Connect members.

Best and worst garden centres

Garden centres reviewed - April 2011
BrandLocation (County)PriceProduct QualityProduct RangeServiceCustomer Score
CoolingsKentsatisfactoryexcellentexcellentexcellent90%
Gordon RiggLancs & W. Yorksgoodexcellentexcellentgood87%
Aylett NurseriesHertssatisfactoryexcellentexcellentexcellent86%
Dean’s Garden CentreYorksn/agoodgoodgood82%
Sunshine Garden CentreLondonsatisfactoryexcellentexcellentexcellent82%
Longacres NurserySurreygoodgoodexcellentsatisfactory80%
RHS WisleySurreypoorexcellentexcellentexcellent80%
Burston (formerly Burston Tyler)Hertssatisfactorygoodsatisfactorygood79%
Woodcote Green Garden Centre & NurseriesSurreysatisfactorygoodexcellentgood79%
ScotsdalesCambssatisfactorygoodexcellentgood78%
Chessington Garden CentreSurreysatisfactorygoodgoodgood76%
StewartsDorsetsatisfactorygoodgoodgood76%
BentsCheshirepoorexcellentexcellentgood75%
Gordale Nurseries & Garden CentreCheshirepoorgoodexcellentgood75%
Burford Garden CompanyOxon & Worcspoorgoodexcellentgood74%
Grosvenor Garden CentreCheshiren/aexcellentexcellentgood74%
Hayes Garden WorldCumbriasatisfactorygoodgoodgood74%
KnightsSurreyn/agoodn/an/a72%
Bridgemere Nursery &
Garden World
Cheshirepoorgoodexcellentgood71%
Forest Lodge Garden CentreSurreyn/agoodsatisfactoryn/a71%
Barton GrangeLancspoorgoodexcellentgood70%
Millbrook Garden CompanyE. Sussex & Kentpoorgoodsatisfactorygood70%
Thompsons
Kent, Middx &
Isle of Wight
n/asatisfactoryn/an/a70%
Webbs
Warks & Worcspoorgoodexcellentgood70%
Whitehall Garden CentreBristol & Wiltspoorgoodgoodgood68%
Garsons Garden CentreSurreyn/agoodgoodgood67%
Hillier14 centres in Berks, Hants, Herts, Oxon, Somerset, Surrey, Sussex & Warkspoorgoodsatisfactorygood67%
AldiNationwideexcellentsatisfactoryvery poorvery poor66%
Burleydam Garden CentreCheshiren/agoodgoodn/a66%
FrostsBeds, Bucks, Cambs
& Oxon
poorgoodgoodsatisfactory66%
Otter NurseriesDevon, Somerset
& Hants
satisfactorygoodgoodsatisfactory66%
Squires11 centres in Berks, London, Surrey
& Sussex
satisfactorygoodsatisfactorysatisfactory66%
Adrian HallLondonn/agoodsatisfactoryn/a64%
Robert Dyas100 centres in southern Englandgoodsatisfactorypoorsatisfactory64%
Secretts Garden CentreSurreyn/agoodsatisfactorysatisfactory64%
ShootsW. Sussex, Middx
& Surrey
poorgoodsatisfactorygood64%
Marks & SpencerNationwidesatisfactorygoodpoorpoor63%
Blue Diamond Group13 centres in mid- & southern Englandpoorgoodgoodsatisfactory62%
LidlNationwideexcellentsatisfactoryvery poorvery poor62%
Heighley Gate Garden CentreNorthdpoorgoodgoodsatisfactory61%
Stephen H SmithW. Yorks, Lancs
& Lincs
n/agoodgoodn/a61%
Van HageCambs & Hertspoorgoodgoodsatisfactory61%
Garden & Leisure7 centres in mid- & southern Englandpoorgoodgoodpoor60%
HaskinsW. Sussex, Dorset
& Hants
poorgoodgoodsatisfactory60%
MorrisonsNationwideexcellentsatisfactoryvery poorpoor60%
PolhillKentpoorsatisfactorysatisfactorypoor60%
WilkinsonNationwideexcellentpoorpoorpoor59%
Dobbies25 centres in Scotland & Englandpoorsatisfactorysatisfactorypoor58%
NotcuttsNationwide (England)poorsatisfactorysatisfactorysatisfactory58%
AsdaNationwidegoodpoorvery poorpoor56%
Ruxley Manor Garden CentreKentpoorgoodsatisfactorysatisfactory56%
BloomsGlos, Norfolk,
S. Glamorgan, Warks, Wilts & Worcs.
poorsatisfactorysatisfactorysatisfactory55%
Klondyke6 centres in Scotlandpoorsatisfactorysatisfactorypoor53%
Strikes18 centres in north Wales & northern Englandpoorsatisfactorysatisfactorypoor52%
WickesNationwidegoodsatisfactorypoorpoor52%
Country Gardens12 centres in Englandsatisfactorysatisfactorysatisfactorypoor51%
Peter Barratt’s Garden CentresE. Yorks, Northd
& Cleveland
poorsatisfactorysatisfactorypoor51%
Wyevale (The Garden Centre Group)Nationwide (England
& Wales)
poorsatisfactorysatisfactorypoor51%
ArgosNationwidegoodsatisfactorypoorn/a50%
Capital GardensLondon & Hertsn/asatisfactorypoorpoor50%
Sainsbury’sNationwidegoodpoorvery poorpoor48%
B&QNationwidegoodpoorpoorpoor46%
TescoNationwidegoodpoorvery poorpoor46%
HomebaseNationwidesatisfactorypoorpoorpoor44%
FocusNationwidesatisfactorypoorpoorpoor41%

Table notes

Rating categories:
Price – price of gardening products
Product quality – quality of gardening products
Product range – extent of gardening products available and stock levels
Service – staff availability, helpfulness and product knowledge

Customer score: Between 21st January and 3rd February 2011 we asked the Which? Connect panel to complete a survey on the garden centres/retailers they had bought plants or gardening products from in the last 12 months. Members were asked to rate a maximum of three stores that they had visited on a wide range of criteria, such as product quality, price and staff helpfulness, and were also asked about their overall satisfaction with that store and whether they would recommend it to a friend. Our statistics team used this information to create customer score values for all the stores/chains that had at least 30 responses.

Sample sizes: Coolings (83), Gordon Rigg (38), Aylett Nurseries (137), Dean’s Garden Centre (38), Sunshine Garden Centre (38), Longacres Nursery (121), RHS Wisley (233), Burston (formerly Burston Tyler) (37), Woodcote Green Garden Centre & Nurseries (67), Scotsdales (77), Chessington Garden Centre (82), Stewarts (47), Bents (75), Gordale Nurseries & Garden Centre (64), Burford Garden Company (61), Grosvenor Garden Centre (34), Hayes Garden World (65), Knights (33), Bridgemere Nursery & Garden World (85), Forest Lodge Garden Centre (35), Barton Grange (91), Millbrook Garden Company (39), Thompsons (30), Webbs (107), Whitehall Garden Centre (44), Garsons Garden Centre (43), Hillier (282), Aldi (74), Burleydam Garden Centre (30), Frosts (147), Otter Nurseries (142), Squires (227),  Adrian Hall (31), Robert Dyas (77), Secretts Garden Centre (38), Shoots (40), Marks & Spencer (137), Blue Diamond Group (53), Lidl (95), Heighley Gate Garden Centre (47), Stephen H Smith (32), Van Hage (143), Garden & Leisure (73), Haskins (174), Morrisons (209), Polhill (71), Wilkinson (405), Dobbies (541), Notcutts (274), Asda (60), Ruxley Manor Garden Centre (55), Blooms (180), Klondyke (109), Strikes (101), Wickes (103), Country Gardens (102), Peter Barratt’s Garden Centres (75), Wyevale (1,119), Argos (44), Capital Gardens (46), Sainsbury’s (142), B&Q (1,913), Tesco (269), Homebase (1,230), Focus (293). Total sample size was 7,268.

at the garden centre

Our survey found independents are better than big garden chains

Best garden centres and shops

Independent garden centres came out top in the Which? survey. They outperformed large garden centre chains and DIY stores.

Coolings in Kent came first, closely followed by Gordon Rigg in Yorkshire/Lancashire and Ayletts in Hertfordshire. 

Least favourite garden centres and shops

Bottom of the pile were DIY giants Focus and Homebase, with Tesco, B&Q and Sainsbury's not far behind. Although these did well on price, their product range, quality and staff were consistently below average.

Some familiar garden-centre chains were also less than impressive when it came to customer service. 

While supermarket or DIY-store staff are not necessarily green-fingered, it's a surprise that some large garden-centre chains such as The Garden Centre Group and Country Gardens received such low customer scores. 

Both of these chains were rated as average for their product quality and range but were disappointing on staff knowledge, helpfulness and availability and price.

What to buy where

If you’re looking for a specific plant, a specialist tool or gardening advice, your local independent garden centre is your best bet. Staff are more likely to be helpful and knowledgeable and there will be a wider choice of quality products. Our guide to how to buy different types of plant explains how to buy roses, bedding plants, spring bulbs and more.

If you already know what you want or don’t need a large selection to choose from, a supermarket or DIY store is the place to pick up a bargain. They're especially good for garden furniture, garden tools or compost. 

If good value is your priority, high-street stores such as Aldi, Lidl, Morrisons and Wilkinson all scored top marks for value gardening products.

More on this

Which? works for you