Ropey returns on cash Isas12 cash Isa providers offering low interest rates

24 May 2009

We highlight the ‘dirty dozen’ banks and building societies that are hitting savers hard.

Increases in in the Budget may be set to boost your tax-free savings – but, at press time, we found 12 of the biggest cash Isa providers were offering astonishingly low interest rates.

Three of the ‘dirty dozen’ didn’t even match the Bank of England’s base rate of 0.5%, so their customers’ savings were making a pittance in interest.

Rates dropped

Barclays offered the lowest rate in April 2009, of just 0.10% (down from 4.26% in April 2008). And Nationwide, Halifax and HSBC all dropped their rates by more than the 4.50% base rate fall.

None of the 12 came close to providing the rates of Which? Best Buy cash Isas.

Martyn Hocking, editor of Which?, said: ‘Too many of the big financial providers are blaming the economic crisis right now. Savers are entitled to more and should move their cash to better Isa providers.’

The 'dirty dozen' Isa deals

The 'dirty dozen' Isa deals
Bank/Building Society Interest rate April 2009 Interest rate fall since April 2008
Abbey/A&LDirect Isa 2.00% 4.25%
Yorkshire BS e-Isa 1.90% 3.65%
NS&I Direct Isa 1.30% 4.00%
Halifax Isa Saver Direct 0.50% 4.75%
Nationwide BS Instant Access Isa 0.25% 4.80%
Natest Cash Isa 0.60% 4.25%
Lloyds Cash Isa 1.00% 3.85%
Britannia BS Instant Access Isa 0.80% 4.00%
HSBC Cash Isa 0.20% 4.55%
Royal Bank of Scotland Cash Isa 0.80% 3.90%
Northern Rock Cash Isa 0.87% 3.67%
Barclays Cash Isa 0.10% 4.16%


Latest money news

For daily consumer news, subscribe to the here.

If you have an older web browser you may need to copy and paste this link into your newsreader: . Find out more about RSS in the Which? guide to news feeds.

Or listen to our weekly .