Which? Car lab tests have revealed that the new Honda Jazz Hybrid is hardly more fuel-efficient than the petrol-engined model.
The Jazz Hybrid is the first petrol-electric supermini to go on sale in the UK, and it’s just been put through our unique tests.
We found that despite the car’s marginally cheaper running costs compared with the 1.4-litre automatic petrol model, the £1,500 extra it costs to buy means that it makes little financial sense.
Take a look at the cars the Honda Jazz has to beat in our supermini car reviews
Fuel savings too small
Our tests showed that the Jazz Hybrid averages fuel economy of 57.6mpg (lower than Honda’s claim of 62.8mpg), meaning that it will cost around £1,071 in petrol each year. That’s based on today’s average unleaded price of 136p per litre and an annual mileage of 10,000 miles.
The 1.4-litre i-VTEC petrol-engined Jazz averages 49.6mpg (again, lower than the claimed average of 52.3mpg), and so should cost about £1,247 to fill up over the same distance.
That equates to an annual fuel saving of approximately £176. So, based on fuel costs alone, it would take more than eight and a half years to recoup the extra cost of the Hybrid.
Even if you factor in the lower tax cost of the Hybrid – £10 a year, rather than the £80 a year it costs to tax the 1.4 petrol – it would still take nearly six years to repay that initial price premium.
Which? members can see our Honda Jazz Hybrid review here
Still a good car
It’s a shame those numbers don’t add up for the Jazz Hybrid, as it’s a success in other areas. Despite losing 100 litres of boot space to the electric batteries, it’s still practical and there are few compromises in the way the car drives when compared with the normal Jazz.
The standard car is a favourite with Which? members thanks to incredibly high reliability (it was the third most reliable new supermini in the 2010 Which? Car survey), and the new 1.3-litre IMA hybrid engine comes from the Honda Insight, which earned an even higher reliability score – so it should be very fuss-free to own.
Our free guide to buying a new car has all the insider tips you need to choose the right car for you
If you’re not already a Which? member, you can take a £1 trial here
Follow Which? Car on Twitter
The Which? Car team is on Twitter, to offer you help and advice as and when you need it.
We’re monitoring our Twitter account every day, so if you have an account, please send us you thoughts and questions to @whichcar.
Don’t worry if you haven’t got a Twitter account – you can still stay in the loop by regularly checking www.twitter.com/whichcar.