Car hire fuel costs and insurance excesses 'too high'Which? reveals consumers' car hire experiences

02 October 2011


A clear majority of consumers who have hired cars think charges for insurance excess and refuelling are too high, according to Which? research.

Most also think car hire terms and conditions are unnecessarily complicated, and believe car hire companies should provide maps of local garages when collecting a car.

Half have felt pressurised into taking out insurance offered by hire companies.

Car hire experiences

In July, Which? surveyed 2,618 members of the public about their car hire experiences. Of the 618 who had hired a car in the past two years, 70% thought terms and conditions were too complicated and 69% felt insurance excess was disproportionately high.

Another 60% wanted a map showing fuel stations with the car, 56% thought refuelling charges were too high, and 50% said they felt pressurised into buying insurance.

Damage and insurance

Some 44% of customers who hired a car experienced a problem, the most common of which was that the vehicle was not adequately checked for damage before hire.

Other common problems were having to pay unexpected charges on collection, being given a car that need to meet the customer's needs and not understanding what was covered by the insurance provided.

Which? believes the experience of car hire can be improved for consumers and will be investigating the issue further.

More on this

Tips for hiring cars abroad.

For travel advice, expert tips and destination ideas, subscribe to Which? Travel.