Virgin Trains tops first ever Which? train surveySurvey finds mixed picture for rail services across the country

22 March 2012

fast train UK

Virgin Trains has topped the table with a score of 64% in the first ever Which? survey of train companies. 

For the first time, Which? has surveyed train passengers to find out what they think of the train companies they use. 

The Which? survey paints a mixed picture of the service provided by train companies, with some passengers experiencing overcrowding, erratic punctuality and poor value for money. 

Mixed results for train companies

Survey satisfaction scores ranged from 64% for top-rated company Virgin Trains to 40% for bottom-ranked Southeastern. 

Commuter companies generally received lower scores than train companies carrying a higher proportion of leisure passengers.

But commuter carrier c2c bucked this trend and achieved the second highest-score overall, at 61%. 

Which? asked passengers about key issues of train travel, including punctuality, cleanliness, room for passengers, catering and value for money. 

1,844 train journeys

Separately, Which? asked members of its Which? Connect panel what they thought of their train journeys between November 2011 and January 2012. 

Which? received responses relating to 1,844 journeys.  

Punctuality and cleanliness were vital for passengers to be content with their travel experience. 

Beyond that, factors such as good staff or poor food could sway people to feeling more or less positive about their journey.

But the majority were left unmoved after their journey - 56% felt the same about their train company afterwards. 

Positive response to East Coast

20% felt less positive than before they'd taken their journey. But almost as many - 18% - felt more positive. 

One passenger commented that their first train journey for many years was 'very easy and stress free.'

East Coast was most likely to leave passengers feeling more positive about it as a result of their experience with the company whereas London Midland was most likely to leave them feeling less positive.

Train station

Tell Which? your views

Most train company contracts are up for renewal in the next two years. 

Which? will be challenging the government and train companies to improve services and want the voice of the passenger to be taken into account. 

Now is your chance to tell us - and the government - how you think train companies are doing and what changes you want to see. 

Email us to share your experiences. 

More on this

  • Delayed on a train? Use our free train delay tool to check what compensation you are entitled to
  • Take a look at what else we're doing to make things better for consumers from financial services to energy tariffs
  • Have a read of our free guide to train travel to get the best value train fares