Misleadingly named savings accounts uncoveredAttractive-sounding accounts pay little interest

24 December 2012

Which? has uncovered the savings accounts that sound like they pay you a fortune in interest but actually only give you a pittance, with some accounts paying a miserly 0.05% a year.

In the current low-interest environment, you might find it hard to swallow that banks and building societies are still giving their savings accounts names such as Extra High Interest, Midas Gold, Extra Special and Triple Gold. And yet, there are accounts with these names that pay miserly interest rates. 

Take NatWest’s Diamond Reserve paying 0.1% – for every £100 you save, you'll get just 10p in annual interest. We've listed the worst offenders in the table below.

Savings hall of shame
The table below shows what we consider to be the instant-access and notice savings accounts with the biggest mismatch between a low interest rate and a high-value name.
AccountProviderInterest rate on £1,000
Extra SpecialDudley BS0.05%
Instant SapphireCambridge BS0.05%
Savings BuilderBarclays0.05%
Liquid GoldHalifax0.05%
CashbuildSaffron BS0.05%
Cash StashFirst Trust Bank (NI)0.05%
Gold AccessLeeds BS0.05%
Bonus GoldHalifax0.1%
Gold AccountDunfermline BS0.1%
Platinum SaverLloyds TSB0.1%
Midas GoldDanske Bank0.1%
High RiseNorwich & Peterborough BS0.1%
Extra High InterestNewcastle BS0.1%
Diamond ReserveNatWest0.1%
Triple GoldDerbyshire BS0.1%

Table notes

  1. Accurate to 21/12/12

Some grandiosely titled accounts are less stingy if you're able to save more. The Extra High Interest account from Julian Hodge Bank, for example, pays a pathetic 0.1% interest on £1,000, but a more respectable 2.7% on a balance of £10,000. 

Halifax/Bank of Scotland’s Extra Income Saver, on the other hand, boosts its rate from 0.1% to just 0.13% for balances of £5,000-£25,000, while Derbyshire BS's Triple Gold account increases its rate from 0.1% to just 0.11% if you save at least £10,000 and 0.12% on balances of £50,000. 

Visit our guide to finding the best savings account to get a better deal on your money.

Superseded accounts 

Many of the savings accounts now paying insulting returns once paid higher rates. For example, in September 1997, the NatWest Diamond Reserve account was paying 4.59% AER, while the Halifax Liquid Gold account paid 3.7% on balances of £3,000. Neither matched the best deals available but they were far better than the current advertised rates of 0.1% and 0.05% respectively.

Typical of the hundreds of 'superseded' accounts that are no longer available to new customers, the rate paid on these accounts has fallen over time. So while banks and building societies advertise attractive rates on other accounts to new customers, existing customers lose out with rates as low as 0.01%. 

More on this...

Cookies at Which? We use cookies to help improve our sites. If you continue, we'll assume that you're happy to accept our cookies. Find out more about cookies