Three Best Buy carpet cleaners for 2014 revealedBuy or rent? We put the Rug Doctor to the test

09 July 2014

Rug Doctor carpet cleaner

We've reviewed and rated the Rug Doctor, which you can buy for £430, or rent for £33

Our latest carpet cleaner group test has uncovered three Best Buy models that are so good, they'll make your grubby carpets look like new again. 

We put 16 carpet cleaners from big names such as Bissell, Vax, Rug Doctor and Hoover head to head on grubby and stained carpets in the Which? lab. We also tested out the Rug Doctor - a carpet cleaner that is available to rent widely on the high street.

But while we found three models that do an excellent job cheering up tired carpets, a further four proved so ineffective on dirty carpets that we’ve labelled them Don’t Buys and recommend you avoid them.

You can find out which models were the winners and losers in our carpet cleaner reviews section. 

Rug Doctor: buy or rent?

The average price of the carpet cleaners we've tested is £200. However, among those carpet cleaners is the Rug Doctor, which you can buy for £430, or rent for approximately £33.

That price secures you a Rug Doctor for 24 hours and gets you a litre of carpet cleaning detergent, which is advised as being enough for two rooms. The Rug Doctor is available to rent from a number of stores across the UK such as Asda, Homebase, B&Q, Morrisons, Johnson Cleaners, Tesco, the Co-operative and the Range.

Which? floor care expert Adrian Porter said: ‘Our research shows that carpet cleaners are not the most frequently used of machines. Some that own them only use it once or twice a year, if that.

‘The Rug Doctor has gone through exactly the same tests as the carpet cleaners you can buy in the shops. We’ve given our expert view on whether it’s worth buying or renting, but you’ll also be able to compare our test results for yourself.’

Read our full Rug Doctor review to find out how good it is at cleaning carpets and whether it’s worth renting, or even buying.

£200The average cost of the carpet cleaners we've tested - so is it worth saving money by renting a Rug Doctor?

Carpet cleaners on test

The full list of carpet cleaners we've just reviewed is below - click the links to read our full reviews.

Bissell 34T2E Cleanview Pro Heat £300
Bissell 37Y8E CleanView Reach £200
Bissell CleanView Deep Clean 18Z7E £256
Bissell Deep Clean Deluxe £200
Bissell Deep Clean Lift-Off £300
Bissell Deep Clean Premier £280
Bissell ReadyClean £100
Hoover Cleanjet Volume CJ625 £200
Hoover Cleanjet Volume CJ930T £300
Rug Doctor Mighty Pro £430 or £33 to rent
Swan SCW3013 £49
Vax Rapide Ultimate Clean W87-RH-P £120
Vax Rapide Ultra 2 W90-RU-B £170
Vax W86-DP-B Dual Power £120
Vax W87-DV-B Dual V Advance £190

Multi-function carpet cleaner on test

This Vax is both a vacuum and carpet cleaner rolled into one – is it worth buying and throwing your old vacuum away? Read our review to find out.

Vax 6151F review £170

Prices correct as of July 2014 and are subject to change.

More on this...