Which? finds fake goats' cheese in shopsWe join forces with food crime scientist

22 October 2014

A sheep and a goat

We tested 76 samples of goats' cheese: nine contained sheep's cheese

Which? uncovers fake goats' cheese being sold in the shops - we became suspicious about the large amount of goats' cheese on sale, despite a goats' milk shortage.

We were concerned that goats' cheese manufacturers could be substituting goats' milk for other milks. So we joined forces with the author of the government's independent review into food crime, Professor Elliott, to investigate.

We bought 76 samples of goats' cheese from supermarkets, delis and markets from eight locations around the UK and tested them to see what they really were. 

In total, nine samples were adulterated: three contained more than 80% sheep's cheese, another three contained more than 50% sheep's cheese, and the final three around 5% sheep's cheese.

Sadly these results are not an isolated incident and reinforce the need for better checks so that people get what they pay for and can trust the food they buy. Pledge your support for our food fraud campaign and sign our petition to stop food fraud.

Food fraud

This isn't the first time we've uncovered food fraud this year - click the links to read the Which? magazine articles about each investigation:

  • In May we tested lamb takeaways and found that 24 out of 60 contained other meats, either chicken or beef or a mixture of both. And six of these contained no lamb at all. Both chicken and beef are cheaper than lamb, so a substitution cuts costs for manufacturers and caterers.
  • In September we tested fish sold in fish and chips shops to find seven out of 45 samples were mislabelled. We bought fish labelled as either cod or haddock - two 'cod' samples were actually haddock, and five 'haddock' where in fact whiting.

And, of course, no one can forget the discovery of horsemeat in our food in early 2013 - where tests showed that horsemeat was substituted for beef in many processed beef products, including supermarket ready meals. 

A recent Which? survey revealed that only 36% of people in the UK* are confident that the food they buy contains exactly what is stated on the ingredients. More needs to be done to increase consumer confidence and trust in the food industry.

Which? supports the recommendations of Professor Elliott's review into food crime, which included introducing a Food Crime Unit to investigate food fraud. Now we want to see the government implement changes to protect consumers. 

*Survey: 2,106 UK adults

More on this...