Apple TV, BT YouView and EE TV boxes - Which? reveals test verdictFive new Best Buys and three you should avoid
29 April 2015
We put 11 models in our latest test: Apple TV, Microsoft and Netgear streaming devices, plus 8 Freeview/Freesat boxes such as EE TV, a Panasonic PVR and Blu-ray player, and new sub-£100 BT YouView box.
Do you want a set-top box to watch Freeview or Freesat TV, a PVR to watch/record, or a way to stream films and catch-up TV such as BBC iPlayer? In our latest batch we've tested a variety of models and found the best of the crop. Five did so well in our tests we've named them Best Buys, but three should be avoided.
Cheap and smart - watch catch-up TV and video from a tablet on your TV
If you fancy watching catch-up and film services on the big screen but don't want a new smart TV, then we've tested 'smart' set-top boxes, PVRs and streaming devices which give similar services and features for less than £50.
At £49, the Apple TV streaming device is a cheap way to add 'smart' features. It lets you access a range of video, music and photo apps over wi-fi, and AirPlay mirroring lets you share the screen of Apple iOS devices on your TV. We've also tested two other similar streaming devices; the £45 Microsoft Wireless Display Adapter, which mirrors the screen of Windows PCs, laptops, tablets and phones, and the Netgear Push2TV PTV3000 for Amazon devices.
One of these models did so well it earned a score of 85% in our tests, making it the second highest-scoring streamer we've tested.
PVRs and boxes to watch, record and catch-up with free TV
To watch digital TV channels you'll need a set-top box or PVR (Personal Video Recorder), and we've tested models that range from £20 to £350. The affordable Bush Freesat HD Digital set-top box costs £45 and also offers BBC iPlayer, while the new BT YouView box features all catch-up TV services, Netflix and Now TV.
If you want to record your favourite TV programmes, a PVR is ideal. As well as recording free-to-air channels, many also add 'smart' services and can be bought for a one-off cost, such as the Bush 500GB Freesat+ box (£130). We've also tested the new EE TV box which is available to EE customers taking a broadband and TV contract.
And if you want it all, the Panasonic DMR-BWT740EB offers Freeview HD, recording, BBC iPlayer and Netflix among its 'smart' services, screen mirroring, plays Blu-rays in 3D and 4K quality – and records to discs, too.
Which PVRs, set-top boxes and TV streaming devices have we reviewed?
Our latest test batch contains the following 11 models:
Internet TV streaming devices:
- Apple TV
- Microsoft Wireless Display Adapter
- Netgear Push2TV PTV3000
- Bush 500GB Freesat+ HD Digital TV Recorder
- EE TV
- Panasonic DMR-BWT740EB
- Technika TKSTB14
- BT YouView box
- Bush Freesat HD Digital Set Top box (2462323)
- Bush Freeview Twin Scart Set Top Box (1526019)
- Goodmans GDB02TFV2