How to buy the best large car
By Martin Pratt
Article 3 of 11
How to buy the best large car
Lost in a sea of saloons of sedans? Our expert guide shows you what to consider in your search for the right large car.
From good-value motorway mile munchers like the Ford Mondeo to premium models like the BMW 3 Series, there's a large car to fit most needs and budgets.
Our expert guide for buying a large car will show you what to look for and consider.
To see the large cars that excelled in the Which? test lab check out our best large cars page.
1. Saloon or hatchback?
Whether you buy a saloon or hatchback depends on many factors, but boot space and versatility is the big difference. Hatchbacks usually trump saloons, not just in terms of sheer carrying capacity but also with through-loading into the cabin area, although saloons tend to offer greater security for luggage with their separated-off cargo compartment.
The so-called 'premium' brands tend to stick with saloons, while the mainstream brands prefer hatchbacks, although there are exceptions. Most large cars are only available in one body style or the other these days.
There are a couple of cuckoos, too. The Skoda Superb is a hatchback whose boot lid can also be opened like a saloon's, for example, and the VW Passat CC is a saloon trying to look like a coupé.
2. Running costs are king
Minimising running costs is an issue that all owners should be aware of. As well as fuel consumption, insurance, servicing and parts, you need to consider depreciation (loss in value).
This tends to be very steep for big saloons. Even sought-after cars like the VW Passat will only be worth around a third of their list price after a typical three years and 36,000 miles, while the worst depreciators could be worth as little as 20%. You need to do your sums carefully before you buy.
3. Space stars
The whole point of large cars is the amount of space that they offer for passengers and luggage. However, not every car that's large on the outside is quite so big on the inside. For example, you might be surprised at how cramped the rear seats are in the Audi A4, Lexus IS and Mercedes C-class. Our practicality kings include the BMW 3 Series, Ford Mondeo, Toyota Avensis and Skoda Superb.
4. Diesel or petrol?
The majority of large cars sold in the UK are diesel powered at the moment. Modern diesels have plenty of pulling power, so they're rarely a compromise next to petrol versions, but their appeal is economy-related - fuel efficiency but, in particular, the tax benefits that come from lower CO2 emissions.
The best large diesels are now rated below 100g/km of CO2 in the lower tax bandings. However, do be aware that this may change in coming years, as the air quality implications of diesel (notably emissions of nitrous oxides and particulates) are addressed, and incentives may be withdrawn or even reversed. Some local authorities are now charging more for residential parking permits for diesel-engined vehicles, for example.
The latest petrol powerplants are very efficient, too, and the price premium of buying a diesel - and diesel fuel - can sometimes take years to claw back through lower running costs unless you do a very high mileage.
Our petrol vs diesel buying guide will help you work out which type of engine suits you best.
5. Mainstream or premium?
Should you buy a mainstream or premium brand? Your decision should not be based solely on the list price. Yes, mainstream models are priced more cheaply than premium ones, but premium cars often depreciate more slowly, so the overall cost could even be lower.
On the other hand, premium cars typically need a lot of expensive options to reach a realistic specification. And discounts are typically less generous from brands like Mercedes-Benz than they are from Ford or Peugeot. Our car reviews include a target discount that you should aim for.
6. Get the spec right
It's vital to specify your car correctly if you want to maximise its value and appeal when it comes to selling it on. Large car buyers expect metallic paint, climate control and sat nav, while leather upholstery is a very worthwhile option if it's not overpriced.
Certain brands really suit automatic transmissions as well - Mercedes is a prime example. Other options worth considering include parking sensors, an upgraded audio system and cruise control. However, don't bother with a sunroof, mobile phone connectivity or body styling packages.
7. Handling and performance
Large cars can be among the very best cars to drive on the road. Models such as the Audi A4, BMW 3 Series, Mercedes C-class and Volkswagen Passat CC are almost like sports cars in the way they drive, with superb performance and agile handling.
8. Hybrids and new tech
New 'green' technology is rapidly entering the large car sector, and it's something that should definitely be on your radar. Hybrids - cars with both conventional and electric engines - have been around for some time in the form of the Honda Insight and Toyota Prius, as well as models from Lexus.
There's also a new breed of 'plug-in' hybrid (PHEV), which has batteries that can be externally charged rapidly from the mains, extending the range that they can cover before their engine has to kick in. The benefits are very low (overall) CO2 and high fuel-economy figures, as well as the likelihood that they will be exempt or charged at a lower rate to enter forthcoming city centre low-emissions zones, for example.
Newcomers in this field include the Toyota Prius Plug-In Hybrid and the diesel-electric Volvo V60 Plug-In Hybrid; there are also plug-in hybrid 4x4s and SUVs on offer, such as the Mitsubishi Outlander PHEV, as well as PHEV versions of the Porsche Panamera and Cayenne.
9. Consider comfort
Ride comfort and noise insulation are important factors for many large car buyers, who often cover big mileages. Here, the cars that are sportiest to drive are often all at sea, particularly if you specify large alloy wheels with low-profile tyres and sports suspension. Indeed, surprisingly few large cars score top marks for ride comfort; one of the best cars in this regard is the Audi A4.
10. How about an estate car?
Large saloons will always occupy a special place in car buyers' minds, but in many ways an estate body style might make more sense. For some, this will have the wrong image, and estate cars do cost more than the equivalent saloon, but they offer a lot more practicality.
For the lowdown on hundreds of new and used cars read our expert reviews.