Which? Reviews No advertising, no bias, no hidden agenda

Photo-editing program reviews: How we test

In our photo-editing software test, we take a selection of photos that need adjustment to improve their looks. Each one suffers from a different condition. We try fixing the images with each of the programs using the most appropriate tools provided. Our experts rate how successful each photo-editing package is at sorting the problem out. We also assess the ease of use for a novice and an experienced user.

Underexposure

A picture of a cat that has been photo edited

Muffin the cat before (inset) and after

Using a photo taken in poor light, we try to adjust of contrast and brightness using each program’s tools to try and create an image that’s well contrasted and brings out all the features of the picture.

Colour adjustments

A picture that has had photo editing

Julia before (inset) and after

Artificial light can give your photos a yellow cast. We take a photograph, shot indoors with fluorescent and tungsten lighting, and use each photo-editing program’s colour adjustment tools to try to create a more natural image.

Removing an object

Sometimes a perfect photograph gets ruined by an unwanted person or object upsetting the balance. We try to remove an object from a photo using whatever tools are provided within each photo-editing program. Where available, we use the program’s clone tool to do this.

Red-eye

A girl with red eye

Redeye affects many indoor shots of faces

Red-eye is an all too familiar side-effect of flash photography. We use each program’s red-eye removal tool to try and rectify the problem.

Repairing old photographs

An old picture before photo editing

Often most treasured, old photos need the most care

We use the tools available within each program (such as anti-blemish tools) to try to remove the creases and scratches from an old photograph.