Which? uses cookies to improve our sites and by continuing you agree to our cookies policy

Save money on this year’s bubbly

Can you tell champagne and sparkling wine apart?

Is there really a difference in taste between champagne and sparkling wine? Our snapshot test reveals a surprising result.

Champagne glasses

We pitted the winner of last year’s Which? champagne taste test – Veuve Clicquot Yellow Label – against a sparkling wine recommended by one of our wine experts to see whether people could spot the difference. 

Surprisingly 40% of our 23 testers preferred the £12.99 sparkling wine to the £33.49 champagne, and the same number actually thought the sparkling wine was champagne.

So maybe you could get away with buying a cheaper bottle of sparkling wine for your Christmas party after all. 

Quality sparkling

Sparkling wines are getting better and better, as our test shows, but be sure to pick a good one. To fool our testers, we chose a Jansz Premium NV sparkling wine, available at Oddbins for £12.99.

This excellent alternative to champagne is great for parties thanks to the gentler acidity that makes it a bit easier on the stomach. Our wine expert also recommended Hunter’s Miru Miru, £13.45 from Jeroboam’s.

Go here to see the results of this year’s champagne taste test, which also includes a behind-the-scenes video of what our tasters look for and a nice dessert recipe from the Good Food Guide: Recipes book to serve alongside your fizz. 

More from Which? Home and Garden…


Back to top