We use cookies to allow us and selected partners to improve your experience and our advertising. By continuing to browse you consent to our use of cookies as per our policy which also explains how to change your preferences.

Revealed: how to play the tax-free Isa rules to your advantage

Find out our five top tips for making the most of your Isa

While cash Isas have fallen out of favour, average rates have hit a three-year high. We explain how to maximise your Isa allowance before the tax year ends on 5 April, including how to juggle flexible Isas with high-interest current accounts to get the best of both worlds.

Before the introduction of the personal savings allowance in April 2016, cash Isas were a no-brainer. But when we surveyed 8,794 Which? members about their finances in February 2019, only half of those with a cash Isa said they’ve paid into their account this tax year.

With interest from ordinary savings tax-free up to £1,000 per year, or £500 for higher-rate taxpayers, most savers no longer need an Isa to lower their tax bill.

Simply plumping for the best rates should be your priority – but here we explain our top tips for using the Isa rules to get the most benefit out of your savings.


Use up your Isa allowance before the deadline

If you don’t use your Isa allowance by 5 April 2019, you lose it.

That may not be much of a concern unless you have significant savings, as the annual allowance is currently £20,000.

However, interest rates have started to rise and the personal savings allowance may seem less generous over time, particularly if you’re a higher rate taxpayer, with half the allowance and double the income tax to pay.

For example, £22,750 saved in the BLME one-year fix paying 2.20%, would earn £500 in annual interest, meaning an Isa would be the only way for a higher-rate taxpayer to avoid paying 40% income tax on any excess savings.

Future-proof your savings

Cash Isas remain free of tax no matter how much they grow. This means you can use the Isa wrapper to future-proof your money in case regulations or economic circumstances change, including scenarios like:

  • interest rates go back to pre-financial crisis levels.
  • you move up a tax bracket.
  • the personal savings allowance is cut.
  • you want to move into stocks and shares.
  • you want to pass on your Isa after your death.

If you’re married, your spouse or civil partner will be entitled to an additional Isa allowance so they can inherit your Isas without losing the tax-free wrapper, should you die first – less than half of Which? members (42%) were aware of this, in our survey.

To grow your nest egg, cash Isas can also be moved into a stocks and shares Isa whenever you choose. You could potentially lose some or even all of your money, so never invest any money you might rely on in an emergency. However, keeping savings in cash also carries risk, as inflation can erode the spending power of your money over the years.

Find out more: What is a stocks and shares Isa? 

Take advantage of flexible Isas

Flexible Isas let you withdraw some of your savings and then replace it in the same tax year without it counting towards your allowance.

This means you could take money out of an Isa and put it in a high-interest current account (paying up to 5%) or the best non-Isa on the market, before replacing it before the end of the tax year (5 April) to make sure it remains within a tax-free Isa wrapper going forward.

Only a third of variable cash Isas offer this feature – providers don’t have to offer flexibility at all, or may only offer it on certain products – but there are some attractive deals (see our table of the best flexible rates, below).

Isa flexibility rules do not apply to the lifetime Isa or Help to Buy Isa.

Mix ‘n’ match with a portfolio cash Isa

Usually, you can only open one cash Isa in each tax year but a handful of banks which allow you to spread your annual allowance across multiple products – known as ‘portfolio cash Isas.’

For example, both Aldermore and Ford Money Isas accept transfers in from previous tax years, allow flexible withdrawals, and let you mix and match your savings across their entire cash Isa range.

Say you had £10,000 to put away and didn’t want to lock all of it into a fixed-term account. You could spread your money between the Aldermore 30-day notice cash Isa paying 1.30% on deposits of £1,000 upwards and its one year fixed-rate Isa paying 1.55% – and this would be classed as one cash Isa for the purposes of HMRC reporting.

Transfer old Isas to a market leader

Even if you don’t wish to add new money to your Isa, make sure any existing accounts are earning a decent rate.

If your savings are with any of the big high street banks, you can easily get a better deal, particularly if you opened it more than a year ago.

You can see our list of the worst Isa rates offered by high street banks in the past 12 months in the table below.

Bank Isa Rate (AER) on £10,000
Halifax Variable Isa Saver (closed) 0.10%
Halifax Instant Isa Saver (closed) 0.20%
Post Office Money Cash ISA – Online Isa Easy Access Issue 10/11 (closed) 0.25%
Bank of Scotland Access Cash Isa – Isa Saver 0.35%
Lloyds Bank Cash Isa saver 0.35%
Santander e-Isa 0.35%
NatWest Cash Isa 0.35% (0.60% at £25K, 0.85% at £50K)
HSBC Bonus Isa – Variable Rate Cash Isa (closed) 0.50%
Nationwide Loyalty Single Access Isa – Single Access Isa (closed) 0.50%
The Co-operative Bank Cash Isa 0.56%


For example, if you had £10,000 in the lowest rate Halifax Isa, currently paying a miserly 0.10%, you could improve annual returns by £135 by switching to market leader 
Virgin Money Double Take e-Isa (issue 5) which pays 1.45% and has no limit on transfers. 

This Virgin Money account only allows two withdrawals per calendar year, although you can close the account and transfer the entire sum at any time.

  • Use our savings booster tool to see how much you could gain by switching to one of the best cash Isas on the market.

Never transfer the money yourself

If you want to switch Isa providers, don’t simply move your balance via bank transfer.

First, check that your chosen new provider accepts transfers, as not all do. From there, fill in an Isa transfer form. Your new provider should then manage everything for you, including contacting your current provider.

Under Isa transfer rules, if you want to move money that you’ve paid into an Isa during the current tax year, you must transfer the whole balance. For Isas deposited into in previous tax years, you can choose how much you want to move.

Please note that the information in this article is for information purposes only and does not constitute advice. Please refer to the particular terms & conditions of a provider before committing to any financial products.

Which? Limited is an Introducer Appointed Representative of Which? Financial Services Limited, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN 527029). Which? Mortgage Advisers and Which? Money Compare are trading names of Which? Financial Services Limited.

Back to top
Back to top