Illegal and potentially dangerous scam ‘eco plugs’ still widely available to buy on online marketplaces, Which? investigation warns
So-called ‘energy saving’ devices can seem appealing to consumers who may be struggling with increased energy bills or those who would like to make more eco-friendly purchases. These plugs claim to save customers money on their electricity bills by ‘stabilising’ voltage and ‘balancing’ electric current to ‘optimise’ the performance of household appliances.
However, Which? researchers tested eight devices from AliExpress, Amazon, eBay, Shein, Temu and TikTok Shop and found no evidence that they worked. More concerningly, they failed basic electrical safety standards, meaning they are illegal and potentially dangerous. The platforms removed the listings reported after being contacted by Which?, but despite repeatedly claiming customer safety is a top priority, many identical looking devices were still available weeks later.
This is not the first time Which? has raised the alarm about the safety of these products. In 2022, researchers tested near-identical devices from Amazon and eBay twice and reported them to their platforms, which then delisted them.The Office for Product Safety and Standards officially recalled four similar devices on AliExpress, eBay and Wish in 2022, citing a ‘serious risk of fire and electric shock’.
Many of the devices made dubious energy-saving claims, which led to a raft of poor customer reviews. One buyer pointed out that a device bought on Amazon was “nothing but a scam” and that the company “should be ashamed of themselves for marketing this item and be more responsible for what they sell.”
Another one-star review warned that the “only thing these boxes will achieve is a house fire”.
Despite nearly half of the 33 ratings for one device on Amazon receiving one-star reviews, the device continued to be available to buy. It was even shipped from an Amazon warehouse.
One device available on AliExpress promised to ‘reduce’ line loss and ‘improve’ power factor. Some 260 shoppers had bought this AliExpress ‘choice’ product, which was handled and shipped directly by the marketplace.
An eBay seller who had sold 50 three-packs of ‘smart electricity-saving’ boxes claimed that they use ‘a capacitor system to store electrical energy, allowing it to be released more smoothly’.
SHEIN, a marketplace that harbours hopes of floating on the London Stock Exchange, sold and shipped a ‘Magic Electricity-Saving Box’. SHEIN is a marketplace, based in China with a similar business model to Temu, that used to predominantly sell clothing but has since branched out. Based on this evidence, it could be just as likely to put customers at risk of buying unsafe products as the other marketplaces Which? has exposed.
Most of the items Which? researchers looked at had poor quality soldering, contained too much lead which is tightly regulated due to potential health side effects, and had unmarked non-standard capacitors indicating they were not manufactured in the UK and therefore potentially unsafe.
Consumers are also being exposed to numerous adverts and promotional videos for scam ‘energy-saving’ boxes on social media platforms that operate as online marketplaces. For example, adverts for these devices were found on Instagram and Facebook, some of which featured the face of tech entrepreneur Elon Musk to add a veneer of authenticity. One disgruntled member said the seller was a “scammer”, adding: “It doesn’t work.”
Which? investigations have also shown that removing specific listings for recalled products is not sufficient to keep consumers safe. The consumer champion’s product safety tests have found similar or identical-looking products can also be unsafe, leading to warnings for customers to avoid unbranded electronics sold on online marketplaces.
This investigation underlines the need for tough new laws to make online marketplaces responsible for ensuring the safety of the products offered on their platforms. The government’s Product Regulation and Metrology Bill must be strengthened to ensure that these new laws give online marketplaces clear legal responsibilities for keeping dangerous products off their sites, backed up by tough enforcement, including heavy fines, when businesses fall short.
Sue Davies, Which? Head of Consumer Protection Policy, said:
“It’s incredibly concerning to see that these scam eco-plugs are still widely available on many online marketplaces, despite the fact that they are illegal and potentially a danger to their users.
“Sadly, it’s not surprising that these dangerous items have reappeared on major online marketplaces. It fits the pattern we’ve seen following countless Which? investigations and is yet more evidence of why change is needed.
“The government’s Product Regulation and Metrology Bill must be strengthened to give online marketplaces a clear legal responsibility for ensuring dangerous products don’t make their way onto their sites - with tough enforcement action against those that fall short.”
ENDS
Notes to Editors
Which? - Why you should avoid unbranded electronics on online marketplaces
Product listings
Amazon
eBay
AliExpress
https://www.aliexpress.com/w/wholesale-energy-saving-plugs.html?spm=a2g0o.home.search.0
Right of replies
An Amazon spokesperson said: “Safety is a top priority at Amazon and we want customers to shop with confidence on our stores.
"We require all products to comply with applicable laws and regulations and we take action to maintain a safe selection for our customers.
“These products have been removed.”
An eBay spokesperson said: “Consumer safety is a top priority for eBay. We take a proactive approach to keeping our site safe that – among other measures – includes auditing compliance documentation from sellers. Both listings from which Which? did the test purchases were subject to our audits. Because the sellers did not provide sufficient documentation, we had already removed the two listings before Which? informed us that the products are unsafe.
"In addition to these audits, eBay uses block filter algorithms aimed at preventing unsafe and prohibited listings, and regular monitoring by our in-house specialists, supported by AI. If we find an unsafe product, we remove it immediately. Our Regulatory Portal also enables authorities from around the world to report listings, and unsafe items are automatically removed within two hours.”
A spokesperson for SHEIN said: "SHEIN takes product safety very seriously and is committed to offering safe and reliable products to its customers. Upon learning of any claims, SHEIN immediately removes the item(s) from its site as a precaution while the company investigates.
“On SHEIN Marketplace, both SHEIN branded products as well as products from a global network of third-party sellers are available. All vendors are required to comply with SHEIN’s code of conduct and must abide by the relevant laws and regulations of the countries the company operates in. SHEIN works closely with international third-party testing agencies such as Intertek, SGS, BV and TUV, to carry out daily risk-based sampling tests to ensure suppliers' compliance to product safety standards. In 2024, SHEIN performed more than two million tests including chemical tests, with these third-party agencies, as well as a CNAS-accredited laboratory, and removed over 260 marketplace sellers from our site due to non-compliance."
A spokesperson for AliExpress said: “AliExpress takes product safety very seriously, and we have strict rules and policies in place to ensure a safe online shopping environment. Third-party sellers who list items for sale on our marketplace must comply with the law and with our platform rules and policies. The listings of the product that failed Which?'s test have been removed. Also, we have conducted the verification and removed the similar products that have been identified to be problematic.”
A spokesperson for Temu said: “Temu takes a multi-pronged approach to product monitoring and requires traders to meet the safety standards of the markets they are selling to. In this specific case, our proactive monitoring had flagged the product and removed it from our platform before your email.”
TikTok did not provide a comment for publication.
About Which?
Which? is the UK’s consumer champion, here to make life simpler, fairer and safer for everyone. Our research gets to the heart of consumer issues, our advice is impartial, and our rigorous product tests lead to expert recommendations. We’re the independent consumer voice that influences politicians and lawmakers, investigates, holds businesses to account and makes change happen. As an organisation we’re not for profit and all for making consumers more powerful.
The information in this press release is for editorial use by journalists and media outlets only. Any business seeking to reproduce information in this release should contact the Which? Endorsement Scheme team at endorsementscheme@which.co.uk.