Buying a car Petrol or diesel?

Petrol or diesel?
  • We consider cars from six popular sectors
  • We calculate the true payback period for the diesel premium in fuel savings
  • Calculations based on the unique Which? lab test results
  • Follow the links to do your own calculations and make the best choice

What's in this guide

  1. Finding out the real costs

    We help you decide whether to pay extra for a diesel, comparing popular models.

  2. Superminis

    Choosing a supermini? Is the diesel Fiesta worth the extra cash?

  3. Medium cars

    Is it best to go for diesel in a medium family hatchback? We compare two Vauxhall Astras.

  4. Luxury cars

    Carrying VIPs round town or looking for a motorway cruiser? Which 5 Series is best?

  5. MPVs and Estates

    Is petrol or diesel the best choice for powering your family to its destination?

  6. 4x4s

    Tiguan's good on the school run or country driving, but which fuel choice is cheapest?

Trial Which? today

Latest Which? Car magazine cover

Try Which? magazine for just £1 and gain instant access to

About Which? magazine

Which? Car podcast

Listen to our latest FREE 10-minute digest of all the most important car news and reviews.

Listen to a podcast now

Which? car news

Sign up for the latest car news and reviews, and money-saving hot car deals, in your newsletter every Friday.

Sign up to Which? Car news