Driver tools Petrol and diesel fuel costs

Petrol or diesel?

 

Please install/enable Adobe Flash Player to view an interactive version of this content

Example running costs comparing a petrol with a diesel car
Example numberCar price differenceAnnual fuel cost petrolAnnual fuel cost dieselAnnual CO2 emissions petrolAnnual CO2 emissions dieselNo. of years to recoup diesel price premium
1£1,500£1,068£8522.442.216.9
2£2,000£1,330£9913.042.575.8
3£1,500£1,575£1,1713.63.043.7
4£1,850£1,991£1,3534.553.522.8
5£1,099£1,805£1,4724.123.833.3

Choosing between a petrol and a diesel car can be difficult. While you can be fairly confident the petrol model will be cheaper to buy, knowing which is going to cost you more in the long run is a bit more difficult.

This is because the overall running costs of petrol and diesel cars are affected by so many factors, including fuel prices, servicing bills and emissions-based charges. 

Sign up to Which? for just £1 to get full access to all our car reviews, including real-world fuel consumption figures

The calculator on the right only takes initial purchase price, fuel costs and mileage into account, but should give you an idea of how many years’ driving it will take to make buying a diesel the most cost-effective choice - if indeed the diesel will ever be cheaper.

The 'diesel payback' period could take much longer than you would think - especially for lower mileage drivers. However, if the diesel car saves you money on car tax and depreciation, it may pay for itself sooner.

More on this...

Other sections in this guide

  1. Overview
  2. Petrol and diesel fuel costs
  3. Choosing between petrol and diesel

Trial Which? today

Latest Which? Car magazine cover

Try Which? magazine for just £1 and gain instant access to which.co.uk

About Which? magazine

Which? Car podcast

Listen to our latest FREE 10-minute digest of all the most important car news and reviews.

Listen to a podcast now

Which? car news

Sign up for the latest car news and reviews, and money-saving hot car deals, in your newsletter every Friday.

Sign up to Which? Car news