What are the common types of ADR?

The two most common types of ADR are mediation and arbitration.

  • Mediation is where an independent third party helps you and the company you’re in a dispute with to reach a mutually acceptable outcome. The mediator will add formal structure to the communication you and the company have with the aim of helping you to reach a voluntary agreement. The mediator cannot impose a solution.
  • Arbitration is where an independent third party considers the facts and takes a decision that’s legally binding on you, the company, or both.

ADR schemes are independent third parties that act as a middleman between you and the company after your initial complaint couldn’t be resolved. Some ADR schemes are called ombudsman services.

Are all ADR decisions legally binding?

Mediation isn’t legally binding, but arbitration is.

  • Mediation allows you and the company you’re in a dispute with to 'control' the outcome, rather than having it imposed on you. The mediator has no decision making power, which means the dispute will be resolved on the terms you and the company decide and isn’t legally binding until you all sign a legal agreement documenting your resolution.
  • Arbitration is final and legally binding - it is enforceable in the same way as a court judgement. There will only be a limited number of cases in which either you or the company could appeal the final decision - for example, if you found the arbitrator had an undisclosed interest in the company you’re in a dispute with.

When can I use an ADR?

You can get the help of an ADR scheme only after you’ve tried to resolve things amicably with the company you’re in dispute with.

This means you should have reached a stalemate with the company even after going through its customer services and internal complaints procedure.

If you’ve already tried to resolve things and are getting nowhere, that’s where ADR schemes can step in to help.

While participation in ADR schemes isn’t mandatory for companies, almost all businesses that sell directly to consumers are required to point you to a certified ADR scheme when they can’t resolve a dispute in-house.

They must also tell you whether or not they are willing to use that scheme. You should check if there are any costs associated. If there are, these tend to be lower than in the courts.

Can an ADR help me resolve a cross-border dispute?

ADR schemes can be used by UK consumers to settle disputes within the UK, and can also be used for cross-border disputes.

At the moment, UK-based ADR organisations are required to act in cross-border disputes and there is an online dispute resolution (ODR) platform run by the European Commission for Member States, which UK citizens can use.

It helps UK consumers and other consumers across Europe to get greater access to redress in the case something goes wrong with goods or services bought in other Member States.

The ODR platform can also be used without having to start legal action in the courts.

Will I still be able to resolve cross-border disputes using ODR after Brexit?

If the Withdrawal Agreement is approved by the EU and UK, it's been agreed that consumer rights will remain unchanged until the terms of the future relationship between the UK and the EU are decided. This transitional period will last from the date the UK leaves the EU to 31 December 2020.

In a no-deal scenario, the ODR platform run by the European Commission for Member States will no longer be accessible to UK buyers and sellers. But the obligations around alternative dispute resolution for businesses will not change as a result of a no-deal.

If there’s no deal, UK-based alternative dispute resolution organisations will no longer be required to act in cross-border disputes. This means you may no longer be able to use alternative dispute resolution organisations to resolve cross-border disputes with EU countries.

UK consumers will still be able to contact the UK’s European Consumer Centre (ECCN) for help and advice for some time if no deal is reached, as the government has committed to funding the ECCN for one more year.

Read our guide on how Brexit could impact consumer rights for more information.

Are ADR schemes common?

In the UK, the financial services, energy, telecoms and aviation sectors already have large and well-established ADR schemes.

  • Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) - deals with financial services providers.
  • Ombudsman Services: Energy or RECC - deals with energy suppliers.
  • Ombudsman Services: Communications - deals with communications providers.
  • Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman - deals with NHS organisations and government departments and services.

Outside these regulated sectors, there are also voluntary ADR schemes which many businesses are members of.

Please tell us what you think of the Which? Consumer Rights website.

Your feedback is vital in helping us improve this site. All data will be treated confidentially. This survey will take approximately 5 minutes to complete.

Please take our survey so we can improve our website for you and others like you.