Asda reclaims title as cheapest supermarket for branded groceries, Which? reveals
Asda was crowned the UK's cheapest supermarket for branded groceries in October, as Which? reveals that shoppers without loyalty cards could pay up to 126 per cent more for identical items depending on where they shop.
In an analysis of 211 popular branded groceries - including Heinz beans, Nescafé coffee and Mr Kipling cakes - the consumer champion found that Asda was the cheapest supermarket for branded groceries with the list costing £742.35 on average - winning back the top spot after Tesco with a Clubcard took the lead last month for the first time this year.
While Which? regularly finds Aldi and Lidl are the cheapest supermarkets overall in its monthly supermarket price comparisons, they are not included in this branded grocery analysis because they do not stock a sufficiently wide range of branded products.
Sainsbury’s with a Nectar card (£758.14) also leapfrogged Tesco with a Clubcard (£765.53) in October, with a whopping 157 products on loyalty discount compared to 134 at Tesco. Morrisons with More (£771.11) followed, finishing in fourth place.
However, shoppers without loyalty cards faced significantly higher costs, with Sainsbury's (£846.44) and Tesco (£837.55) both proving more expensive than Waitrose (£814.40) and Ocado (£782.39) on average, highlighting the huge impact loyalty pricing can have on the cost of branded groceries.
Shopping at Sainsbury's without a Nectar card was the most expensive option overall, costing 14 per cent more than Asda.
This month, Tilda Boil in Bag Basmati Rice (4 x 62.5g) had the biggest difference between the highest and lowest price. It was at its lowest price, on average, at Asda (£0.95) and highest at Sainsbury’s (£2.15) - a huge 126 per cent difference.
Which? found several other branded products - including Pampers 1 Premium Protection New Baby Diapers (x50), Fairy-Platinum Plus All In One Dishwasher Tablets Lemon (36ea), L'Oreal Paris Elvive Bond Repair Shampoo (200ml) and Colgate Plax Cool Mint Mouthwash (500ml) priced at around twice as much at the most expensive supermarket compared with the cheapest.
There were 157 products from Sainsbury’s on loyalty promotion through the month of the consumer champion’s analysis, 134 at Tesco and six at Morrisons. None of the items in Which?'s analysis were subject to loyalty discounts at Waitrose. Asda and Ocado do not operate member-only pricing in the same way.
While loyalty cards can unlock substantial savings, some shoppers remain unwilling or unable to participate due to concerns around data privacy or eligibility requirements.
Shoppers looking to make the biggest savings may want to consider ditching branded goods altogether. Which? regularly finds supermarket own-brand alternatives are significantly cheaper and often just as good as well-known branded products.
Reena Sewraz, Which? Retail Editor, said:
“As we head into the colder months and the expensive festive run-up, every penny will count for households already under financial pressure.
“Our latest analysis shows Asda back on top for branded goods, as last month’s winner, Tesco with Clubcard, fell to third place. This volatility proves that prices change quickly and why shoppers must stay vigilant to get the best value.
“To keep the cost of their food shop down, consumers should watch out for price fluctuations and cross-check rival supermarkets to make sure a deal is actually saving them money.”
ENDS
Notes to editors
Research: The products with the biggest price differences
Which? compared the average price of branded groceries across supermarkets in October, including loyalty discounts where applicable, and identified the products with the largest percentage difference between the cheapest and most expensive supermarkets.
Average loyalty card prices where applicable:
Product | Lowest price (average) | Highest price (average) | Cheapest supermarket | Most expensive supermarket | % difference |
Tilda Boil in Bag Basmati Rice (4 x 62.5g) | £0.95 | £2.15 | Asda | Sainsbury's* | 126% |
Pampers 1 Premium Protection New Baby Diapers (x50) | £4.00 | £8.70 | Sainsbury's with Nectar | Sainsbury's*, Tesco | 118% |
Fairy-Platinum Plus All In One Dishwasher Tablets Lemon (36ea) | £7.58 | £15.26 | Asda | Ocado | 101% |
L'Oreal Paris Elvive Bond Repair Shampoo (200ml) | £6.50 | £13.00 | Tesco with Clubcard | Sainsbury’s*, Tesco** | 100% |
Colgate Plax Cool Mint Mouthwash 500ml | £2.25 | £4.50 | Asda | Sainsbury’s*, Tesco** | 100% |
Regina Blitz Kitchen Roll 1ea | £2 | £3.80 | Asda | Waitrose | 90% |
Soreen Lift Bars Blueberry 4x42g 168g | £1.25 | £2.35 | Morrisons | Waitrose | 88% |
Listerine Total Care Clean Mint Mouthwash 500ml | £3.34 | £6 | Ocado | Sainsbury’s*, Tesco** | 80% |
Oral-B Pro Expert Toothpaste 75ml | £2.24 | £3.95 | Asda | Sainsbury’s*, Tesco** | 76% |
Mr Kipling Angel Cake Slices (x8) | £2 | £3.50 | Morrisons | Tesco** | 75% |
Nescafé Azera Americano Instant Coffee 90g | £4.22 | £7.25 | Asda | Sainsbury’s*, Tesco** | 72% |
New York Bakery Company The Original Plain Bagels 5ea | £1.17 | £2 | Ocado | Sainsbury’s*, Tesco**, Waitrose | 70% |
Carex Original Antibacterial Hand Wash 250ml | £1 | £1.65 | Asda, Tesco with Clubcard | Sainsbury’s*, Tesco** | 65% |
Rowntree's Fruit Pastilles Pouch 143g | £0.95 | £1.52 | Tesco with Clubcard | Waitrose | 60% |
Maltesers Pouch 158g - 175g | £2.44 | £4 | Tesco with Clubcard | Sainsbury’s* | 64% |
Mr Kipling Fruit Pie Selection 6ea | £2 | £3.25 | Asda | Sainsbury’s*, Tesco** | 63% |
Philadelphia Original Soft Cheese 165g | £1.40 | £2.25 | Asda | Sainsbury’s*, Tesco** | 61% |
Starbucks Frappuccino Mocha Chocolate Flavoured Milk Iced Coffee 250ml | £1.39 | £2.20 | Asda | Ocado, Sainsbury’s*, Tesco** | 59% |
Ryvita Thins Sea Salt And Cider Vinegar 125g | £1.45 | £2.30 | Ocado | Sainsbury’s*, Tesco** | 58% |
Cadbury Milk Chocolate Mini Rolls 10ea | £2.55 | £4 | Morrisons, Tesco with Clubcard | Tesco** | 57% |
Average loyalty card prices where applicable:
*Sainsbury’s with Nectar Tilda Boil In Bag Basmati Rice (4 x 62.5g) (£1.70), Pampers 1 Premium Protection New Baby Diapers (x50) (£4), Fairy-Platinum Plus All in One Dishwasher Tablets Lemon (x36) (£9.68), L'Oreal Paris Elvive Bond Repair Shampoo (200ml) (£10.48), Colgate Plax Cool Mint Mouthwash (500ml) (£3.19), Listerine Total Care Clean Mint Mouthwash 500ml (£4.14), Oral-B Pro Expert Toothpaste 75ml (£3.11), Nescafe Azera Americano Instant Coffee (90g) (£5.44), New York Bakery Company The Original Plain Bagels 5ea (£1.75), Carex Original Antibacterial Hand Wash 250ml (£1.47), Maltesers Pouch 158g - 175g (£2.50), Mr Kipling Fruit Pie Selection 6ea (£2.67), Starbucks Frappuccino Mocha Chocolate Flavoured Milk Iced Coffee 250ml (£1.59), Ryvita Thins Sea Salt And Cider Vinegar 125g (£1.84).
**Tesco with Clubcard L'Oreal Paris Elvive Bond Repair Shampoo (200ml) (£6.50), Oral-B Pro Expert Toothpaste 75ml (£2.50), Nescafé Azera Americano Instant Coffee 90g (£6.64), New York Bakery Company The Original Plain Bagels 5ea (£1.75), Carex Original Antibacterial Hand Wash 250ml (£1), Philadelphia Original Soft Cheese 165g (£1.60), Starbucks Frappuccino Mocha Chocolate Flavoured Milk Iced Coffee 250ml (£2.14), Ryvita Thins Sea Salt And Cider Vinegar 125g (£2.17), Cadbury Milk Chocolate Mini Rolls 10ea (£2.55).
Price analysis methodology
Which? analysed the price of 211 groceries from the most popular brands – including Chicago Town, Dove, Kellogg’s, Mr Kipling, Nescafé and Tilda – every day over the course of a month to work out the average cost per item. These are added up to get each supermarket's average total price.
The list represents the most popular brands across a wide range of grocery categories based on industry data and is designed to produce a robust sample rather than to be representative of a typical shop.
Which? includes loyalty discounts separately in the table where they are available. The value of points, personalised discounts or other rewards are not included as these vary.
Supermarket | Total Price | Number of products on loyalty discount | Percentage difference with Asda |
Asda | £742.35 | 0 | 0.00% |
Sainsbury's (with Nectar) | £758.14 | 157 | 2.13% |
Tesco (with Clubcard) | £765.53 | 134 | 3.12% |
Morrisons (with More) | £771.11 | 6 | 3.87% |
Morrisons | £775.45 | 0 | 4.46% |
Ocado | £782.39 | 0 | 5.39% |
Waitrose | £814.40 | 0 | 9.71% |
Tesco | £837.55 | 0 | 12.82% |
Sainsbury's | £846.44 | 0 | 14.02% |
While Aldi and Lidl are regularly found to be the cheapest supermarkets overall in Which?'s monthly supermarket price analysis, they were not included in this branded grocery comparison because they do not stock a sufficiently wide range of branded products.
Right of Replies
Each supermarket included in our price analysis was given the right to reply to specific examples.
Rachel Eyre, Chief Customer and Digital Officer at Asda, said: “The latest survey shows Asda continues to offer great value on the brands customers know and love, without relying on member-only pricing, and with our low prices available to all. As Christmas approaches, we're focused on keeping prices low and helping our customers get the best value from their festive shop.”
A Sainsbury's spokesperson said: "Our customers know they can get great value when shopping with us, with the large majority of our sales involving a Nectar card. We remain focused on offering outstanding value on the products people buy most often, with more than 10,000 Nectar Price offers available every week, on top of personalised Your Nectar Prices."
Morrisons, Ocado, Tesco and Waitrose did not provide comment.
Useful links
- Which? supermarket food inflation tracker shows what's happening to grocery prices
- Cheapest supermarket of the month price analysis
About Which?
Which? is the UK’s consumer champion, empowering people to make confident choices and demand better. Through our research, investigations and product testing, we provide trusted insight and expert recommendations on the issues that matter most to consumers.
Fiercely independent, we put people over profit - shining a light on unfair practices, influencing policy and holding businesses to account to make life simpler, fairer and safer for everyone.
The information in this press release is for editorial use by journalists and media outlets only. Any business seeking to reproduce information in this release should contact the Which? Endorsement Scheme team at endorsementscheme@which.co.uk.
