The pension loyalty penalty: Savers staying put at retirement could face tens of thousands in extra fees, Which? finds
In September 2026, Which? surveyed 1,760 drawdown customers aged 55 and over to learn about their experiences. Separately, the consumer champion analysed the annual fees payable with 18 different drawdown providers, across five pot scenarios ranging from £50,000 up to £750,000*.
Pension drawdown is a way of taking money from your pension pot while keeping the rest invested so it can continue to grow. Instead of buying a fixed income for life (an annuity), you choose how much and how often to withdraw. It offers flexibility, but because your money stays invested, your pot can still fall in value if markets drop.
Keeping pension savings invested through drawdown can be a delicate balancing act. Pots need to be carefully managed in order to draw an ongoing income, while avoiding depleting them entirely. As long as funds remain invested, fees continue to be paid on the balance, slowly chipping away at returns, or worsening losses. This means choosing a provider wisely is important.
However, Which?’s research has shown many drawdown customers may not be getting the best value for money, instead falling into a loyalty trap which could mean they're paying higher fees than necessary. Which?’s survey found that when setting up their pension drawdown plan, half of those surveyed (50 per cent) remained with their existing pension provider, rather than shopping around.
Across all pot sizes Which? looked at, Pru/M&G levied the highest fees. However, there was no single cheapest option, underscoring the importance of weighing the options against your own personal circumstances.
The largest pot size Which? analysed was £750,000. The differences between the providers with the lowest and highest fees in this price range was particularly stark. Aegon had the most competitive fee structure for this size of pot, coming out at £1,740 a year. In contrast, the most expensive option in Which?’s analysis, Pru/M&G, levies annual fees of £6,638 - close to four times as much. Over ten years, accounting for investment growth of five per cent, a drawdown customer would pay an eye-watering £61,877 more in fees with the most expensive provider versus the cheapest.
For a pot worth £250,000, Which? found Interactive Investor had the lowest fees, with a customer likely to pay £780 a year in drawdown. In contrast, the most expensive provider charged close to three times as much, with an annual bill of £2,275. Over ten years, that would mean paying £18,658 more than with the cheapest option.
For a retiree with a modest pot of £50,000, annual charges come in at just under £200 per year with two of the 16 providers Which? analysed, Vanguard and Interactive Investor, while in total, 12 of the providers Which? examined charge £300 a year or less. At the other end of the scale, someone with the same savings could pay more than twice as much (£530), with the most expensive provider in the list, Pru/M&G. This adds up to paying £4,183 more over a 10-year period, assuming investment growth of five per cent annually.
Platform fees aren’t the only cost to consider when weighing options for pension drawdown. Many providers require you to seek financial advice at some point in the process, and some platforms are only available to advised customers. FCA data shows that around four in ten (44 per cent) of those accessing pension pots via drawdown in 2025-26 received financial advice.
While financial advice can be incredibly valuable, it also comes at a cost. Figures from VouchedFor show that paying an independent financial advisor to oversee drawdown investments on a £250,000 fund would cost around £5,000 upfront and carry ongoing fees of approximately £10,000 over the next five years (0.8 per cent, per annum). Combined with platform and fund fees, this could quickly make a significant dent in a modest pot.
Paul Davies, Which? Pensions Expert, said:
“Retirees today are under immense pressure to make every pound in their pension count, but blind brand loyalty could quietly cost them tens of thousands of pounds over their retirement.
“Platform fees and hidden charges compound over time, quietly chipping away at your future spending power. It pays to shop around and be deliberate about what you actually need from a platform. Just a few hours spent comparing providers today could preserve a substantial chunk of your nest egg for the years ahead.”
-ENDS-
Notes to editors:
In September 2026, Which? ran an online survey of 1,760 Which? Connect members and the general public in the UK who were aged 55 and over and in pension drawdown. The data has not been weighted and may not be representative of pension drawdown customers.
*In its analysis, Which? included both platform fees and fund fees for the ready-made investment pathway known as ‘investment pathway 3’ or ‘IP3’, which is targeted at those looking to take an income from their pension within the next five years. Figures assume money is invested in funds and no withdrawals are made.
Correct as of Sep 2026. Figures (% and £) reflect platform fees plus fund fees for investment pathway 3 (IP3). Calculations include market average fund fee for IP3 of 0.2 per cent where appropriate.
About Which?
Which? is the UK’s consumer champion, empowering people to make confident choices and demand better. Through our research, investigations and product testing, we provide trusted insight and expert recommendations on the issues that matter most to consumers.
Fiercely independent, we put people over profit - shining a light on unfair practices, influencing policy and holding businesses to account to make life simpler, fairer and safer for everyone.
The information in this press release is for editorial use by journalists and media outlets only. Any business seeking to reproduce information in this release should contact the Which? Endorsement Scheme team at endorsementscheme@which.co.uk.
