Unbranded White smoke alarm review
Don't Buy this smoke alarm – it failed to detect smoke in all eight of our fire tests
When set the task of detecting smoke from fires fuelled by wood, plastics, cotton and solvents, this unbranded and unreliable product failed to sound in all of our fire tests.
It’s one of the most unresponsive and potentially dangerous alarms we’ve seen and in our tests, we found it unable to reliably detect smoke and that’s why we’ve made it a Don’t Buy.
Further readingTake me to reviews of Best Buy smoke alarms
Find out how we test smoke alarms
Test score %
- Smoke alarm (battery powered)
- Optical smoke alarm
This dangerous smoke alarm failed all eight of our smoke detection tests when we tested it back in 2018 and that’s why we’re warning you about it and why we’ve made it a Don’t Buy. It’s not from a recognisable brand - we bought it from eBay but it’s also available on other online marketplaces. It’s made in China and you’ll see the model number JTY-GD-SA1201W and an image of a burning house on the box. On test, it’s among the most worrying products we’ve ever tested – it simply can’t detect smoke. So, your best course of action is to avoid this unsafe smoke alarm.
- Pros and cons
Make smarter choices
- 0%Lowest score
- 43%Average score
- 93%Highest score
How to buy the best smoke alarms
Buying or replacing smoke alarms? We reveal what you need to consider for fire safety, and which fire alarms or smoke detectors are most suitable for your home
How to place and maintain smoke alarms
Which? expert advice on where to put your smoke alarm, which type to buy, plus vital information on what you need to know about maintaining a smoke alarm.
How we test smoke alarms and heat alarms
Which? tests smoke alarms to find which alarms will alert your family to every type of house fire, and which smoke alarms you can't trust to keep you safe.