Unbranded CO & smoke alarm review
Don't Buy this smoke alarm – it failed to detect smoke in all eight of our fire tests
When set the task of detecting smoke from fires fuelled by wood, plastics, cotton and solvents, this unbranded and unreliable product failed to sound in all of our fire tests.
It’s one of the most unresponsive and potentially dangerous alarms we’ve seen and in our tests, we found it unable to reliably detect smoke and that’s why we’ve made it a Don’t Buy.
Further readingTake me to reviews of Best Buy smoke alarms
Find out how we test smoke alarms
Test scoreShow Context
- Smoke alarm
- Battery only
- Optical smoke alarm
We bought this alarm from Wish and in our tests it failed to sound in eight separate smoke detection tests. We’ve made it a Don’t Buy to warn you about the danger of having an alarm like this one in your home. In our tests it wasn’t simply a matter of this alarm sounding a little later than most - it simply didn’t detect smoke. Along with a handful of other incredibly dangerous smoke alarms we’ve tested recently, this model is one of the most worrying products we’ve seen on sale in the UK. It claims to also be able to detect carbon monoxide (CO), but predictably this dangerous alarm was just as bad at detecting CO in our tests as it was at detecting smoke.What's included:
- Pros and cons
First reviewed by Which?
- 0%Lowest score
- 38%Average score
- 93%Highest score
How to buy the best smoke alarms
Buying or replacing smoke alarms? We reveal what you need to consider for fire safety, and which fire alarms or smoke detectors are most suitable for your home
How to place and maintain smoke alarms
Which? expert advice on where to put your smoke alarm, which type to buy, plus vital information on what you need to know about maintaining a smoke alarm.
How we test smoke alarms and heat alarms
Which? tests smoke alarms to find which alarms will alert your family to every type of house fire, and which smoke alarms you can't trust to keep you safe.