By clicking a retailer link you consent to third-party cookies that track your onward journey. This enables W? to receive an affiliate commission if you make a purchase, which supports our mission to be the UK's consumer champion.

Buying car insurance on this day could save you £163

The price of premiums typically rise as your renewal date approaches
Ravi GhelaniContent writer & producer

From decoding personal finance and insurance to curating gift guides, Ravi’s writing helps readers save money - and pick the perfect present.

Hands typing on a laptop displaying a car insurance graphic, including icons, charts, and a coffee cup on the table.

Need car insurance?

Use our customer scores to help you choose a great deal at MoneySuperMarket.

Compare deals
Set as preferred source

Waiting until the last minute to buy car insurance could mean you pay around 50% more for cover.

Car insurance bought 26 days before the policyholder's renewal date cost £335 on average, but drivers who waited until the same day their policy started paid an average £498, according to data from comparison site Go.Compare. That means you could fork out an extra £163 if you leave it until the last moment to run quotes.

No magic date guarantees the cheapest premium, but data from price comparison websites consistently shows you can save by buying your car insurance a few weeks before the policy starts. 

Here, Which? reveals how the price of premiums changes as your renewal date approaches, plus how to drive down the cost without compromising on cover.

Be more money savvy

free newsletter

Get a firmer grip on your finances with the expert tips in our Money newsletter – it's free weekly.

This newsletter delivers free money-related content, along with other information about Which? Group products and services. Unsubscribe whenever you want. Your data will be processed in accordance with our privacy notice.

When is the cheapest day to buy car insurance?

You can buy car insurance up to 30 days before your renewal date, and new data from Go.Compare suggests three to four weeks before your renewal date is the sweet spot for shopping around, with the lowest average price paid 26 days ahead.

Our table shows the cheapest and most expensive days to buy car insurance, ordered by the median price paid for an annual policy.

Days to policy start dateAverage (median) price paid*
26£335
27£339
25£342
24£343
23£346
21£347
22£348
19£354
17£355
18£357
20£358
28£358
15£359
14£361
12£363
29£363
11£367
10£368
13£368
9£373
30£378
7£381
8£381
5£389
6£389
4£404
3£409
2£431
1£458
0£498

Table note: Based on the median price paid for comprehensive car insurance policies sold through Go.Compare between 1 October 2025 and 31 March 2026. The analysis covers policies paid for annually and purchased up to 30 days before renewal. The table is ordered from the lowest to the highest median price.

Prices were generally lower around three to four weeks before the renewal date and crept up as it approached. The sharpest price rises were the week of renewal, with the median price jumping from £404 four days ahead to £498 on renewal day – an increase of nearly £100.

There’s no guarantee that buying cover 26 days before your renewal date will produce the cheapest quote for every driver. Your premium will depend on factors including your age, car, location, mileage and driving history.

However, data from comparison sites has repeatedly shown that you can save by buying your car insurance three or four weeks before you need the policy to start.

What’s happening to car insurance premiums?

Car insurance prices remained relatively stable between July and September 2026, with the average cost of an annual policy falling by £4 to £562 compared with the previous three months, according to the Association of British Insurers.

That's 2% more than the average premium in the same period in 2025, but considerably cheaper than a couple of years ago – the average cost was £607 in the third quarter of 2024.

However, insurers paid out a record £3.2bn in motor claims during the quarter, which could put pressure on premiums.

Get a car insurance quote with MoneySuperMarket

How to cut the cost of car insurance

Buying at the right time can help, but the calendar isn’t the only way to save money. Try these five steps to keep your premium down:

  • Shop around Compare like-for-like quotes through sites such as Compare the Market, Confused.com, Go.Compare and MoneySuperMarket. Bear in mind that different comparison sites may show different insurers and prices, while some policies and providers don’t appear on comparison sites at all.
  • Don’t renew without haggling Before accepting your renewal quote, ask your insurer whether it can improve the price. Our survey of 2,000 motorists found that two thirds of those who contacted their car insurer to discuss price walked away with a cheaper premium offer last year.
  • Pay annually if you can Paying in monthly instalments usually costs extra because you're borrowing the year's premium and repaying it gradually across the year, with interest added.
  • Check your details Make sure your estimated mileage, occupation, address and vehicle use are accurate. Never change the facts to secure a cheaper quote, as this could invalidate your cover.
  • Choose your excess carefully Increasing your voluntary excess may reduce the premium, but check the total amount you would need to pay if you claimed. A cheaper policy could prove a false economy if the excess is unaffordable.

Find out more: how to find cheap car insurance