Do 'trusted farmers' and 'higher welfare' labels really mean what you think they do?

Separate the genuine welfare labels from the vague marketing spin
Erica McKoy Senior Presenter / Producer

Erica is a senior presenter and producer who has spent more than 15 years crafting stories for major international broadcasters. At Which? she works across our award-winning audio and video content.

Olivia HowesSenior researcher & writer

Olivia is an investigative journalist covering sustainability and retail issues. She's been at Which? for 15 years.

Set as preferred source

You might think that paying a premium for supermarket meat and dairy, and looking out for packaging that includes phrases such as ‘trusted farmers’ and ‘happy and healthy’ means that high animal welfare standards are a given, but our research suggests otherwise.

In this episode of Which? Shorts, we bring you the results of our investigation into supermarket food labelling, revealing how major retailers Aldi, Asda, Co-op, Iceland, Lidl M&S, Morrisons, Ocado, Sainsbury’s, Tesco and Waitrose actually measure up when it comes to chicken and pork welfare.

Our results show that unregulated marketing terms often blur the line between genuine welfare certifications and standard farming practices, leaving shoppers confused about what they are really paying for at the till.

This episode is read by Erica McKoy and is based on an article written by our sustainability expert Olivia Howes, originally published in the November 2026 issue of Which? magazine. 

Live well and stay healthy

free newsletter

Sign up for our Healthy Living newsletter, it's free.

Our Healthy Living newsletter delivers free health and wellbeing-related content, along with other information about Which? Group products and services. We won't keep sending you the newsletter if you don't want it – unsubscribe whenever you want. Your data will be processed in accordance with our privacy notice.

More podcasts from Which?

The Which? podcast showcases the best content from across our website and magazine. 

Which? Money episodes, released on Fridays, give advice to help you get on top of your bills and tackle the issues hitting your pocket, from spiralling energy costs to your weekly food shop.

The Which? Shorts podcasts offer you a free insight into some of our favourite articles from our suite of magazines.

Plus, keep an eye out for bonus episodes that tackle important issues – from motoring to tech, and from health and wellbeing to travel.

How to listen to the Which? podcast

We're always releasing new episodes, and the podcast is available wherever you usually listen to podcasts.

Subscribe using one of the links below or click this link on your mobile to find us in your favourite podcast app.

As part of your subscription, Which? members also get access to exclusive podcasts.

If you're not already a member, podcast listeners can get 50% off the first year of an annual membership.