How to navigate pension drawdown when you retire

James brings experience from the BBC and commercial radio to our award-winning video and audio team, where he produces our always-on podcasts and presents Which? Money, our weekly personal finance podcast.

Pension drawdown is an increasingly popular way to take an income in retirement, with more people than ever opting for this approach.
Once you reach the age of 55 – rising to 57 in April 2028 – you can choose to buy an annuity which guarantees a set income for life, or enter into drawdown which allows you to take a flexible income.
In this episode presented by James Rowe, Which? Money’s pensions expert Paul Davies is joined by Interactive Investor’s head of personal finance and pensions Craig Rickman to discuss the pros and cons of drawdown.
They help you understand when drawdown might be worth considering, such as if you're happy to keep your money invested, and when an annuity might be more suitable for you, for example, if you want a guaranteed income each year.
Plus, Paul reveals which drawdown providers came out on top in our latest analysis, including those that have been named Which? Recommended Providers.
James Rowe: Last week on the podcast, we spoke about taking a tax-free lump sum from your pension when you retire. Now this week, it's all about pension drawdown.
Welcome to Which? Money.
Hello, it's James in the Which? studio alongside Which? Money's pension expert, Paul Davies. Paul, hello.
Paul Davies: Hello there.
James Rowe: Nice to have you back. And for the first time, the Head of Personal Finance and Pensions at Interactive Investor, Craig Rickman. Craig, hello.
Craig Rickman: Hello.
James Rowe: Nice to have you with us. Now Paul, as I just mentioned, last week we spoke about lump sums on the podcast – I know you weren't with us – but drawdown kept cropping up. We've got a lot to talk about with drawdown. There's a lot to discuss, but do you want to just cover off the basics of it?
Paul Davies: I can do. Pension drawdown used to be quite rare. Ten years ago, before the so-called pension freedoms in 2015, you had to have a certain amount of income from other sources, so only fairly affluent people used to access pension drawdown. That all changed a decade ago, and sales of drawdown plans have really rocketed over the last, particularly over the last few years. I think there were 400,000 plans sold in the last year, which is almost double only three years earlier. So it's become much more common, much more popular.
The way it works is you keep your money invested in funds and shares, so it's not a great change from when you have your money in your pensions anyway, but you can start withdrawing money from your drawdown plan – and that's the big plus point – in that you can draw money as much as you want at any time. So that's a big advantage compared to some other options. Of course, there's the flip side that if you draw too much money too quickly, you might run out of money. But as I say, it's a much more popular product than it used to be.
James Rowe: And just to cover off the age, 55 at the moment is the earliest you can go into drawdown?
Paul Davies: That's right. So as with other DC pension options, you can withdraw money at 55. That's changing to 57 in two years' time, I believe.
Craig Rickman: Yeah, 2028, yeah.
Paul Davies: So that age is going to rise as the state pension age rises, so it's going to remain 10 years apart from the state pension. So as the state pension rises to 67, the age at which you can access your DC pensions and go into drawdown is rising to 57.
James Rowe: And Craig, as Paul was saying there, pension drawdown became a lot more available to people around 10 years ago when the pension freedoms came into place. I guess this flexibility is a big draw for people, isn't it?
Craig Rickman: Yeah, it's a huge draw. I think what we've seen in recent years is that people's path into retirement has shifted. In previous years, it used to be common for this hard stop, so people would work up to a certain age and then they'd need some replacement income from their pensions. But we've seen this, yeah, a shift in recent years where you're seeing more nuanced approaches to retirement.
So people enjoy the flexibility that they can harness from their pensions that were introduced by the pension freedoms. So they can have the facility to take out – as your previous podcast, your podcast last week tapped into – tax-free lump sums if they want to. They can set up a regular taxable income, but keep that money invested instead of committing to a guaranteed income, or they can take other one-off lump sums down the line. So it's that flexibility that was afforded by George Osborne's great retirement revolution that people have really harnessed since.
James Rowe: And do you think there's also more understanding of how your options differ come retirement as well? When the pension freedoms came in, I guess a lot of people would have been kind of unaware of how they work and that sort of thing. But now they're becoming more popular, I guess people just know more about them, so they may swerve towards that option as well.
Craig Rickman: Yeah, absolutely. So just building on the point that Paul made earlier, most people were capped on what they could draw out. You could potentially take money flexibly from your pension, but you needed, as Paul said, you needed a certain amount of guaranteed and secured pension income – so from annuities, from the state pension and from drawdown. As long as you satisfied that, then you could take money flexibly out of your pension. But as you can probably gather, it was quite complicated.
And what essentially the freedoms did is that they got rid of all of that and said to anyone, however much income you've got from elsewhere, you can take whatever you want out of your pension. And I think also now it's been in existence for – the new regime has been, well not so new anymore – has been in existence for 11 years now, people have got a better understanding of the options available.
James Rowe: Craig mentioned annuities there, so that is another option people can take, isn't it, Paul, for when they want to access their money? And that gives them a kind of a guaranteed, set amount every year for a certain amount of years. But drawdown works a bit differently. You can, I guess, you effectively change how much you get and how often you get it. Do you want to just touch on that a bit more?
Paul Davies: Yeah, that's part of the appeal. As you're right, annuities is guaranteed income, but it's usually a set amount each year or each month, unless you link it to inflation so you get slightly more each year to cap inflation. Drawdown's different. You end up with a total pot that's still invested. So imagine you've worked all your life and you build up your pension funds and you come to the point of retirement. You can then go into drawdown. You can probably go in with your current provider or swap around for a different provider – I'm sure we'll come onto that in a bit.
And so the money's still invested. It's up to you – you might decide what to do on your own, you might have the help of a financial adviser. And the task is deciding which funds the money stays invested in, how risky those options are, and then drawing the money out at a sustainable level. So say you've got £200,000 in your drawdown plan, if you're drawing out 25% of that each year, you're soon going to deplete the pot, so that's not sensible. So it's you have to weigh up your financial needs, how much is in the fund, what it's invested in, the sort of likely growth. So it's quite tricky actually – again, I'm sure we'll talk about it in a bit – but you have to decide, or decide with some outside help, how much you can sensibly draw out of the fund each year.
James Rowe: And when you say you have to make those decisions, those aren't one-and-done decisions either, are they? You don't just make them once and leave it for the rest of your retirement. You kind of have to take a bit more of a hands-on approach.
Paul Davies: Yeah, so you're correct, and again that has two sides of it. You've got the flexibility in that you might draw out more in a year where you've got a certain demand – say you've got to buy a new car or house repairs or whatever it is, or help your kids to get on the property ladder, whatever it is. So you've got the flexibility in that some years you can draw out more than other years. But as you say, that's all down to you to manage and make sure that you're on top of your financial affairs.
I've been talking to lots of people recently about drawdown against an annuity, and lots of people who've opted for annuity will say to me, "Look, it's sort of one and done. I've got that certainty. I don't have to worry about my investments. I don't have to worry about the stock markets. I know what I'm going to get each month." So again, drawdown is different. You have some personal responsibility, or again with an adviser, to make sure what you're doing is sensible. So there's the pros and cons of each really.
James Rowe: Should we go through some of those pros and cons now? Should we start with the pros, Craig? What if somebody was considering drawdown, what would be the draws, what would be the pros for drawdown?
Craig Rickman: Well the main one is that, yeah, you still have the flexibility to take money out of your pension as and when you wish. The money remains invested. So hopefully – or history tells us – that stock markets tend to go up over time, so if your pension pot is increasing, then it offers the facility for your income to increase with it. If your pension performs particularly well, you've got the facility to maybe take some extra lump sums and spend some money on doing some extra things in retirement that you enjoy.
Another benefit of drawdown is that you can leave the pot to someone else, so you can leave it to a spouse or a civil partner, for example, or you can leave it – or it can actually cascade down generations. In that scenario, there could be some tax to pay depending on when you die – I'm sure we'll cover that in a bit.
But the other, another benefit of drawdown is it enables you to take, for example, a tax-free lump sum out of your pension, and then leave the remaining pot invested until you need to draw from it. So for example, let's say you've got to your sort of late 50s and you had some expensive debt that you were worried was going to snowball. So you turn to your pension, take a tax-free lump sum out, clear your debt, but then you can leave the remaining money invested. You don't have to take an income from it immediately. Leave that pot invested, hopefully that will continue to grow, and then you can draw an income in the future when you need it. So I guess as you can tell, the big draw with drawdown is the, yeah, the flexibility and the options that it affords.
James Rowe: And I guess people might listen to that and then think, "Well, actually for me, I would consider some of that not a pro, but a con," because they might think, "Well, I don't want to risk my money being in there. I want the certainty of an annuity instead."
Craig Rickman: And I guess that's where the two can combine quite well. So it's important to note it's not when you're looking at annuity versus drawdown, this isn't an either-or decision. It's not binary. It kind of exists on a spectrum if you like. So at one end for those who are – as you note – be uber-uber-cautious and think, "I just want certainty. I'm happy to trade my pot for this guaranteed income for life because I want to know how much I'm going to get every month, every year." So they're the sort of uber-low-risk people.
And then at the other end, you've got those that are sort of happy to take the risks, happy to take that sort of hands-on approach, keep on top of investments, review the investments every year, review the withdrawals every year. And then you might have lots of other people who are somewhere in the middle, who might want a bit of extra guaranteed income on top of their state pension, so might want to put some of their pension into an annuity, and those who are then with the rest are happy to leave that invested and have flexible withdrawals to get a sort of, the best of both worlds.
James Rowe: And that joined approach, Paul, is an interesting one, isn't it? Because I guess for a lot of people, they might just think it is one or the other – an annuity or drawdown – but you can go for a bit of both, can't you?
Paul Davies: Yeah, I think we call it mix and matching. And that's quite common. Again, talking to members, quite often people will have three, four, five pensions, and that's only going to increase as we all have more jobs. Every time we start a new company, a new pension might open unless you shift it. So people will have a range of pensions. People still have defined benefit pensions – I know it's not as common as it was – so you might have guaranteed income, particularly if you work in a public sector organisation like the NHS, or if you're a teacher or a fireman or something like that.
So that's guaranteed income, and then you've got a pot that might be in a DC pension, then that's moved into drawdown. So that's more flexible. So the two can sit next to each other. And quite often you might – people might have drawdown and an annuity side by side. Particularly if say you retired at 60, you're getting the state pension at 67, which is another chunk of guaranteed income. So you might get an annuity to bridge that gap alongside a drawdown pot for those, again, bigger expenses – not the day-to-day stuff, but if you're going on a big holiday, if you're spending on a big outlay. So it's not just either-or. People have got many different types of pension or many pensions, and that will usually convert into different options at retirement.
James Rowe: Yeah, what's the average? It's about 13 pension pots people might end up with by the time they come to retirement, so it can become quite complex. There's a lot to manage come retirement, isn't there?
Craig Rickman: There is, there is. That's the – when you're looking at your options between how you're going to draw your retirement income from your defined contribution pensions, it can be quite helpful to start the process a few years before retirement. How you choose to draw your pensions is among the biggest financial decisions that you ever make. Because one important thing to note with an annuity is that once you've bought a lifetime annuity, after the cooling-off period has passed, you can't reverse the decision.
That's fixed in for the rest of your life. And there are different sort of options when you buy an annuity, as Paul alluded to earlier, so you can have the payments to be level, you can have them increasing in line with – or sort of roughly in line with – inflation. If you choose that option, then it starts with a lower amount, but then you can choose it on a joint-life basis, guarantees – there's all these different options. So you need to be pretty certain not that you just want an annuity, but you need to be certain of the terms that you're choosing as well.
So it can be helpful to, yeah, to start that process a few years before retirement, so by the time you get there, you've got a clear idea about the way, the best way to draw a retirement income for your personal circumstances.
Paul Davies: And it may be that you start off with all of your money in drawdown and then the markets might be volatile, or you might just worry that you haven't got that guaranteed income. So you can take a chunk of money out of that overall pot and buy an annuity at any stage. So drawdown is flexible in that way as well. You can draw out money to use another way, so it can be the core of your money, but there's other options available to you.
James Rowe: Yeah, I guess for a lot of people, it's changed that course, hasn't it? You could go for drawdown for a few years and then go for an annuity later down the line, Craig.
Craig Rickman: Yeah, and I think just going back to your other point earlier about having lots and lots of pensions – starting the process before retirement, one of the things to consider is consolidating these pensions into a single plan where appropriate, of course. There can be certain valuable guarantees or benefits that you might lose, so you need to check those first, but bringing several pensions together can make the decisions once you get to retirement a great deal easier.
James Rowe: Although, I'm sure we're all aware that process can be quite painful, can't it, of consolidating pensions? Although hopefully it might become a bit easier in the near future.
Paul Davies: Yeah, you can enlist the help of a financial adviser to do it – they will charge a fee. But yeah, it's not a – let's be honest, it can be a bit of a chore, especially if you've got lots of pensions. And as you sort of noted earlier, if you've been moving jobs frequently throughout your career and you haven't done a bit of tidying up along the way, then it's, yeah, it's quite possible you could get towards your retirement years with several pensions scattered around, and then you've got to try and make some sense of them before perhaps then making sense about how you want to draw the income.
James Rowe: Yeah, definitely one to consider. You mentioned financial advice there. I wonder if we should touch on that there, because Paul, do you need financial advice to enter drawdown?
Paul Davies: That's a good question. So looking at the stats, I think for the last year, 44% of people going into drawdown did receive advice. So some companies actually require you to do so, so that will account for some of those people. But that leaves 56% of people that don't. I guess it depends how confident you are in managing your investments. If you're a savvy investor and have been proactive with your pensions before you come to retirement, you might have actually chosen which funds your money was in in your pensions before you decide what to do with it.
So it depends how confident you are. It may be that you get advice at the outset to put your money into funds that are appropriate according to your risk profile, and then manage yourself. It may be that you pay for ongoing advice – obviously that's going to be more expensive. I saw some figures from VouchedFor, which is a website for finding financial advisers. For an initial pot of £250,000, the upfront fee on average was about 2%, so you're paying about £5,000 in fees just for that initial advice. Obviously you'd hope to recoup that with some sensible advice and investments and your money going up. But again, if you take ongoing advice for the next five years, I think the figure was 0.8%, so you'd pay another £10,000 over those five years. So it's a big chunk out of your pot, and obviously you'd have to recoup that via sensible investments.
Craig Rickman: Yeah, I think just, yeah, adding to those great points, I think some of it might boil down to how reliant you are on that defined contribution pension. So if you have the full state pension, which is going up to 13,000 in April, and then perhaps you've got some defined benefit pension as well – we know they're becoming less common, but those who are retiring now may still have some, at least some form of defined benefit pension. If they've already got a really solid amount of guaranteed income that's going to keep pace with inflation and they're less reliant on the rest of that money, then they may feel capable of managing it. But if they're going to be fully reliant and they're a bit confused by the options and not sure which way to take, then I think financial advice can be incredibly valuable.
James Rowe: And for those who don't take financial advice, there are options available – something called investment pathways. Do you want to just talk us through these, Craig?
Craig Rickman: Yeah, so they were introduced in 2021, I think, by the Financial Conduct Authority. And they're designed to help drawdown investors invest their money in the right way depending on the goal that they're looking to achieve with their money. So whether they're looking to take all the money out within the next five years – they're all based on a five-year period. So whether they want to take all the money out, whether they're looking to secure a guaranteed income, whether they're looking to draw a flexible income, or whether they're looking to do nothing with it. So it's, yeah, designed to try and sort of guide those who are avoiding financial advice for whatever reason – whether they feel like they can't afford it, for example.
So designed, yeah, to help them arrive at those decisions. And so if you go to different investment platforms, they will have put together solutions for each of those pathways based on what they think is the right thing for you to do.
James Rowe: And when you say – it's quite an important point actually, I think – when you say when people can't afford financial advice, there is for a lot of financial advisers, they won't speak to somebody if they don't have a certain amount of money, a certain amount of wealth, or a certain amount in their pension pot. So I guess these pathways, they almost bridge that gap a little bit, or it's a few slats of the bridge that bridge the gap, don't they?
Craig Rickman: Yeah, yeah. Because I think a couple of years before pension freedoms came in, there was this overhaul to the financial advice market called the Retail Distribution Review, which among other things, sort of banned financial adviser commissions, and it meant that all of them must charge a fee – or have had to charge a fee for advice since. And that caused, yeah, a bit of a drop-off in the availability of financial advice, and then two years later we get this retirement overhaul from George Osborne where people can do what they want with their pensions.
And so I think that sort of explains why they created – there was this gap that financial advice wasn't as readily available as you sort of said. Some financial advisers will only see people who have got a minimum sort of value of assets. And then for those who sort of don't fit that criteria, have been left to sort of plough their own furrow. So it's like, well, this is designed to help people do that.
I think just a note on the pathways is they're not sort of – these aren't bespoke, and so they're not personalised for you as an individual. You don't have to choose just one pathway because naturally you might have different ideas about how you want to access different pots and what you want to do with them. But I think as a start, they're a good starting point for people to get them just thinking more than anything about, right, what do I see myself doing with this money within the next sort of five years?
Paul Davies: I think it's also worth mentioning, as well as pathways, a lot of these companies will offer ready-made pensions or ready-made portfolios. And these are funds that the company will devise according to risk. So if you're not fully confident, lots of these companies will have a list of thousands of share funds, shares, ETFs, lots of different products. So if you want something that's almost designed by the company to help you according to your level of risk – so these options might be called adventurous or cautious or moderate. So again, it's a bit of a stepping stone. If you're not ready to go on your own completely and want a bit of help from the company, these can be a good option for you.
Craig Rickman: Yeah, I mean just, yeah, within those there'll often be a sort of a risk-profiling process where you'll answer around 10 questions, for example, 10 questions or statements, and then based on your answers you're given a risk score, and then they can sort of guide you towards an investment strategy that's probably going to be appropriate for the risk appetite that you're sort of happy and comfortable with.
James Rowe: So I guess the risk factor is one thing. But then what about actually working out how much money you should actually take through drawdown? I read something called the 4% rule. I wonder if you can touch on it and whether this is a good rule to live by.
Craig Rickman: Yeah, it's another good starting point. So yeah, the 4% rule, it was developed by a US financial planner called Bill Bengen in the '90s. And what it suggests is that if you withdraw 4% of your portfolio every year, uprated with inflation annually, then your pot should last at least 30 years. So Bengen tested all these different time periods of how markets have performed, and he came to that conclusion.
In fact, it was about a year ago he revisited the 4% rule and concluded that it's now 4.7%, so people can actually be a bit more aggressive with their retirement income strategy without draining their pot too soon. But I think that is – that's a pretty sort of commonly known within the retirement sort of landscape rule to use, but yeah, I think things like that are a really good guide to get people thinking about how can they withdraw a certain amount every year and make the pot last. But again, it's really only a guide because everyone's circumstances are unique and you want to do – you want to adopt a withdrawal strategy that's right for you.
James Rowe: Paul, would you agree with that, just a general rule to get you started?
Paul Davies: Yeah, it's a good guardrail. But again, I guess pension drawdown, one of the benefits which we've been talking about is flexibility. So it may be that you only need to take out 2% one year and it might be 6% the next year because you've got that big extension you want to build or whatever it is. So it's, yeah, it's a good guideline, but it's all – there's still the flexibility to take out more if you want to.
So as Craig says, it was revisited last year. It was felt that the 4% was a bit cautious, so Bengen's revised that to 4.7%. We asked people in our survey how much they took out, and the average was 5.4%. So a bit more, so maybe they've been listening to Bengen.
James Rowe: We've not talked about fees yet, because you will pay some fees, won't you, if you go into a drawdown pot? What kind of fees would you likely be paying?
Paul Davies: So you pay a variety of fees, you won't be surprised to hear. So I looked at the fees charged by 18 different providers, so I spent weeks and weeks – took years off my life. But the slightly complex thing I found is that I think there were 12 different charging structures amongst those 18 companies, so it's a mixture of fixed fees, sometimes it's percentage fees, sometimes it's both – percentage fees charged in different ways. So yeah, it was quite an undertaking trying to work it out.
The main charge is called a platform fee, whereby you will usually pay a fixed fee, but more often than not it's a percentage fee, so you'll be charged either a percentage of the whole fund – which might, the percentage might go down as you have more in your fund – or something called a tiered charging structure whereby you pay different percentages for different portions of the fund. So you might pay 0.3% on the first 200,000, 0.2% on the next 100,000.
But the platform fee is your main charge. Also you'll pay fund fees or fees for whichever investment you choose, and then also fees for transacting as you buy and sell investments. So yeah, comparing is quite difficult, but having a notion of the main platform fee is useful.
James Rowe: And comparing is what you have been doing lately – it's been taking years off your life, as you say.
Paul Davies: I have.
James Rowe: Because you've been looking into these providers, but also speaking to some Which? members and members of the public as well, to help us find out which were the best drawdown providers on the market. What did we find?
Paul Davies: Yeah, so it's the third year that we've come up with a list of best pension drawdown providers. So as you say, we ask customers of those companies to see how they feel about their company, so we come up with a customer score alongside a charges score, and put those together for an overall score, and that dictates who our recommended providers are. So we've come up with seven companies out of the total list of 18 this year.
James Rowe: And you are more than welcome to reveal them now, Paul.
Paul Davies: So the list of companies is headed up by Interactive Investor.
James Rowe: Great news, Craig.
Craig Rickman: Great to know.
Paul Davies: So no brown envelopes there at all. And then we've got Vanguard, Scottish Widows, Royal London, Aberdeen, AJ Bell and Fidelity.
James Rowe: And Money members can read all of those reviews in their Money magazine. They'll be available on the website soon as well.
Paul Davies: Today, in fact.
James Rowe: Well, there you go, it's available right now. Craig, Paul was just mentioning how Interactive Investor – and there in terms of fees as well – since you are here, just a quick word on the fee structure at Interactive Investor. How does it work there?
Craig Rickman: Yeah, so as Paul noted, we charge a flat fee as a sort of a platform, as a platform fee. So it means it remains fixed, no matter how much money you've got in there. So unlike percentages, it doesn't increase as your wealth increases. So that can be quite attractive for those who have got larger retirement pots because it doesn't matter as their fund continues to grow, then their fee's going to remain the same.
But I think just as a word on fees, they are – it is really important to keep an eye on them, especially when you're managing a retirement portfolio. It's a bit similar to tax really, in that every pound that you pay in fees or every pound that you pay in tax is a pound less for you to spend in retirement. And over time, that can really rack up. If you've been paying lots of tax over time, that can really rack up, and the same applies with fees. So yeah, that's one of the things that it's really important for people to keep an eye on, and probably the test is if the extra fees that you're paying don't translate into a better outcome, then you might be paying too much.
Paul Davies: So I can add some numbers to that. So we ran a few scenarios. So for a pension pot of £250,000 over a 10-year period with investment growth of 5%, so the pot's growing, the difference between the worst company and the best company in the analysis meant a difference of £19,000.
James Rowe: Wow.
Paul Davies: So that's £19,000 out of your initial pot of £250,000. So that's to show what a big difference it can make. So ignoring fees at your peril.
James Rowe: It's good to actually hear a number in pounds and pence there, because I think sometimes – and quite understandably – we can get a bit lost in percentages, can't we? Especially when if the difference is 2% and 2.1%. You might not think it's big, but I'm not saying that's the example, but £19,000 is a huge chunk of money to lose out on, Paul.
Paul Davies: Yeah, and I've been lost in percentages for a couple of months, as I say. But yeah, it's good to have those figures just to remind people that they shouldn't sit on their hands if they can do a bit of research, if they can compare providers – which hopefully we can help them do – then it's certainly worthwhile doing, or again, if you're not confident, you might have to pay a financial adviser to do similar.
James Rowe: And another important point to mention here is just because your pension pot is currently with provider A, you don't have to go into drawdown with provider A. That's the whole point of this. You can choose who to go with, can't you, Paul?
Paul Davies: Yeah, exactly. So it wasn't always the case, but most providers now offer a drawdown option. So if you feel like you're paying too much in charges or you're not happy with your current company, of course you can swap, and as Craig says, I think as the years go by, more and more people will consolidate their pensions before they retire because it's easier, because there's less admin, because they've got a provider they particularly like. So you might do that before retirement into a SIPP, and then it's easy to go into drawdown. So I think people will, as they become more accustomed to having lots of pensions, will realise that they need to be a bit more proactive and maybe combine them in advance.
Craig Rickman: Yeah, I was just going to add that, yeah, it's important to find a pension provider that allows you to draw money from your pension in the way that's right for you. So for this we focused on drawdown, but there are other ways as well. There's something called – nasty bit of jargon – uncrystallised funds pension lump sum, which is – I think you might have been through this before.
James Rowe: Last week, yeah. It's a bit of a mouthful, isn't it?
Craig Rickman: It is, it is indeed. There's a lot, lots of nasty jargon in the pension industry and that's one of the biggest culprits, I think. But so that's another way of drawing money from your pension where the withdrawal is part tax-free and part taxable. But the important thing is to have a provider that allows you to access your pension in the way that's best for you. So whether that's drawdown, whether that's using that sort of part tax-free, part taxable one, and yeah, to shop around and try and find the right one for you.
James Rowe: I don't want to bring the mood down right at the very end, but I'm going to anyway. If you do have money in drawdown and you do die, what happens to that money?
Craig Rickman: So that's been one of the sort of long attractions with drawdown is that that money can pass to a loved one. So it can go to, yeah, spouse or civil partner. It can also cascade down the generations as well, so they can inherit the pot, which is why some people have chosen to use drawdown over annuities, because with annuities, once you've bought one, you sort of say goodbye to that sort of portion of money and you get the income, the regular income instead.
There could be some tax to pay, so if you're over the age of 75 when you die, whoever inherits the pension, any withdrawals are subject to income tax, so they're added to any other income and taxed at whatever income tax band they fall into. At the moment, there's no inheritance tax to pay, but from April 2027, for most pensions that is going to change.
James Rowe: So that's another big change on the horizon, isn't it? Should we wrap up with some final thoughts on pension drawdown? We've covered quite a lot given there is so many different branches to drawdown, but just final thoughts from the pair of you – anything we either haven't discussed or just something you really want to reiterate, Craig?
Craig Rickman: I think probably just one final thing is to maybe talk about the tax on withdrawals from income drawdown. So if you've taken, for example, you've taken a tax-free lump sum from your pension, which is for most people will be 25% – there's a cap on it, but 25% for most – the rest of the money, so the other 75% that you move into drawdown, the withdrawals are taxed again at your marginal rate of tax. So it's important to bear that in mind. So if you've – I think like an example I used earlier, if you're still working and you don't need the income, it's often best to leave that money untouched until you need it.
But I think just a sort of again a final thought on drawdown is that, yeah, and I think there's a really important word that you mentioned earlier, I think, which is hands-on. It needs to be a hands-on approach. This isn't a one-and-done thing. It's a pot that you will need to manage throughout your retirement. You can change your mind at some point, so you could move some or all into an annuity down the line if you then reached a point where security and certainty was going to be more valuable. But yeah, it's a more hands-on approach. You can, as we've spoken about, enlist the help of a financial adviser to help you, but still you need to be comfortable managing a pot of money in retirement.
James Rowe: Paul?
Paul Davies: Yeah, I'd like to reiterate the pros and cons, I guess. So pros: it's flexible, you can take out how much you need to, your pot can also continue to grow with investment growth. Cons: the opposite can happen. If there's a downturn in the markets, your pot could fall in value, which can be disconcerting in retirement when you're hoping to make the money last. As we've said, it will need your management, so it will need your time and effort. And if – worst-case scenario – you spend too much or markets crash, you could run out of money. But hopefully having listened to the podcast today, you won't do.
James Rowe: And I think as you've both mentioned, this is a very personal decision and you really have to get to grips with that, and as Craig, you said before, take time – a few months or maybe a few years beforehand – to really think about what you want to do and how you come to that decision.
Craig Rickman: Yeah, yeah, I think that's important. I think five years tends to be a good amount of time to plan because that can also inform the best way to invest as you approach retirement as well. So if you're looking to use income drawdown and keep your money invested, as opposed to buying an annuity, there's usually less need to begin to take risk off the table as you approach retirement. Because if you're looking to lock in a guaranteed income and markets drop shortly beforehand, then you're going to have a smaller pot to secure that guaranteed income with. But with income drawdown, because you're going to keep the money invested, there's less need to take risk off the table. So that five-year planning period sort of in advance of retirement is really important, and then make sure that you're reviewing it every year up until that point.
James Rowe: Plenty to consider and plenty more to read about as well on the Which? website. We'll pop some useful links in the show notes. But for now, Craig, thanks so much for your time.
Craig Rickman: Thanks for having me.
James Rowe: And Paul, thank you.
Paul Davies: Thanks.
James Rowe: That brings to an end another podcast from Which?. There's loads more for you to read about everything we discussed today – just head to the episode description for more useful everyday advice. There, you'll also find an exclusive offer for podcast listeners like you to become a Which? member for 50% off the usual price, giving you access to our product reviews, our app, one-to-one personalised buying advice, and every issue of Which? magazine across the year. Plus, your membership helps us to make life simpler, fairer, and safer for everyone.
If you'd like to know when we release a new episode, then make sure you press subscribe wherever you're listening – that way you can be one of the first to listen. And for any questions, comments, or anything in between, follow us on social media @WhichUK or email us: podcasts@which.co.uk. Goodbye.
Take control of your retirement planning
free newsletter
Get to grips with pensions, boost your retirement income and enjoy the lifestyle you want with our expert tips.
Our Retirement Planning newsletter delivers free retirement-related content, along with offers from third parties and details of Which? Group products and services.
More podcasts from Which?
The Which? podcast showcases the best content from across our website and magazine.
In our Which? Money episodes, released on Fridays, we give advice to help you get on top of your bills and tackle the issues hitting your pocket, whether that's spiralling energy costs or your weekly food shop.
The Which? Shorts podcasts offer you a free insight into some of our favourite articles from our suite of magazines.
Plus, keep an eye out for bonus episodes that tackle important issues, from motoring and tech to health and wellbeing and travel.
How to listen to the Which? podcast
We release new episodes regularly, and the podcast is available wherever you usually get your podcasts.
Subscribe using one of the links below, or click this link on your mobile to find us in your favourite podcast app.
As part of your subscription, Which? members also get access to exclusive podcasts.
- Listen to member-exclusive podcasts on our website
- Listen on the go by downloading our app on Google Play
- Listen on the go by downloading our app from the App Store
If you're not already a member, podcast listeners can get 50% off the first year of an annual membership.
What’s your retirement status?
Select the option that best describes your current situation.

