5 mistakes to avoid if you're buying a phone this Black Friday

Shopping for Black Friday phone deals? Avoid expensive contract traps, short security support, and overpriced flagships with our expert's tips
Jamie DarlowSenior writer & researcher

A tech tester for nearly 20 years, Jamie is the Which? expert on smartphones, tablets, and wearables, delivering trusted buying advice.

Black Friday sale on a smartphone, with a credit card poised in the other hand
Set as preferred source

Black Friday is one of the best times to buy a new smartphone, but it can also be one of the most confusing, with thousands of deals to pick from. 

Using our independent lab test data and pricing research, we’ve rounded up the biggest phone-buying traps to avoid, so you can bag a genuine bargain this November.

Our guide to the best smartphones reveals the models that topped our lab tests.

1. Buying a 'new' phone

Newly-released phones aren’t always better than the ones they replace. It might sound surprising, but our lab tests prove it. And you’ll almost certainly get better value from a discounted handset that’s a generation or two old than from a brand-new flagship 

This is great news if you’re looking for a bargain this Black Friday, because brands regularly discount older models following their latest releases. If you have the patience to wait even 12 months from launch until the latest models are released, our pricing research suggests you could save hundreds on your next smartphone.

Jamie Darlow

Big brands like Apple, Samsung and Google use their flagship models to wow us with features such as folding screens and enhanced AI, but innovation is always going to be expensive. If you can look past things like periscope telephoto lenses and anti-reflective screen coatings, there are some real bargains to be found on older phones, which have been given a new lease of life with increased security support stretching up to seven years in some cases.

You’re not necessarily missing much, either. While smartphones made major leaps forward just a few years ago, introducing edge-to-edge OLED displays, biometric improvements like Apple’s Face ID and multi-lens camera systems, those hardware developments are largely ubiquitous, while the latest improvements are iterative. That means you probably won't see seismic improvements in performance from your last phone, even if you buy the most expensive phone out there.

So while the sharp rise in Ram costs this summer has made the increasing cost of new phones all the more obvious, it’s made cheaper phones from 2025 and 2024 harder to ignore. Ram rose by more than 60% year-on-year in 2026, as memory chip suppliers struggled to keep pace with the massive wave of hardware demanded by AI companies and new data centers. That’s brought phones like the Apple iPhone Duo to £2,000 and beyond, and the Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra to from £1,279 at launch, but left the iPhone 15 and Galaxy S25 hovering around £500.

Our advice: Shop for a phone released in the previous year – you're likely to see decent discounts across the board compared to the newest model.


Head to our mobile phone deals page to see hand-picked bargains from our experts. 


2. Paying extra for premium

Flagship smartphones get the best of everything: variable refresh rates, large batteries, fast processors, and multiple camera lenses with up to 10x zoom. But the truth is, few will truly need or make use of the features that give top-tier handsets their premium price. 

The latest iPhone 18 Pro, for example, has:

  • A Variable Aperture on its 48MP Fusion main camera to physically control the light hitting the sensor inside
  • AI that lets it judge depth of field even before you’ve taken the photo 
  • Three lenses to improve how far it can zoom in (8 x optical quality for the iPhone 18) and how close it can get to the action in macro mode
  • It also shoots in 4K Dolby Vision resolution video (up to 120fps)
  • And boasts a TOF (time of flight) lens to measure depth more accurately

That’s impressive, but the additional £800 spend over many of our Best Buys for this cutting edge tech is going to put most of us off.

If what you're more interested in is solid performance where it matters, there are dozens of smartphones that we’ve rated four stars for video and photo quality that cost less than £350, including some Best Buys and Great Value devices. They don’t have the huge 1-inch sensors that detect the most light that flagship phones do, but clever advances in software such as Google’s computational photography can come close to making up for that and produce great images. Some devices also feature multiple lenses that shoot at 48MP, take 4K video at 60 frames per second, and produce good photos even in tricky light conditions.

There's no need to pay more for good battery life

Buying the most expensive phone also doesn’t guarantee you the best battery life, according to our lab test data. Perhaps surprisingly, phones costing between £200 and £350 actually have the best battery consumption, consistently scoring four or five stars, while on average the most expensive devices over £1,000 will go fractionally less between the charges. And really poor battery life is thankfully a thing of the past, with no smartphones reviewed in the last three years scoring less than 3 stars, with some of the best phones lasting over 40 hours or more between charges.

So while flagship phones might have big batteries, they also have high demand on their reserves, thanks to power-hungry processors like Apple’s A20 Pro and brighter, higher-refresh displays. Given that choosing a phone with a long battery life is often or always a consideration for 45% of the Which? members we surveyed*, it’s surely time to look beyond the top-end smartphones.  

There are nine Great Value phones we’d recommend for less than £350, and three high-scoring Best Buys that cost less than £400. All have at least two years’ worth of security support remaining, too, with some topping out at six years’ support. That’s another important consideration you can read more about below.

Our advice: If you're not desperate for the very latest in camera tech or AI features, aim for a mid-range phone at a top-end budget of about £500.

3. Forgetting about trade-in

If you’re like me, you’ll have a drawer full of old smartphones and their chargers stretching back generations, which should be recycled and their precious metals and rare-earth minerals reused. And the really good news is that you can take the sting out of buying a new phone by trading in your old handset, with some retailers and brands accepting 'any phone, in any condition'.

Of course your old Nokia from the previous millennium is unlikely to be worth much, with the biggest savings restricted to newer handsets - in your case, the model you’re replacing right now. 

Trade-in values can vary a lot, but we've included some current examples below. The process itself is fairly simple – enter details of your existing model while buying your new device, and receive a specific discount. After receiving the new phone, you’ll have around 14 days to send your old device to the brand or retailer in the padded envelope supplied. This should give you enough time to transfer your old details and data onto the new phone.

Brand/retailerPotential trade-in discountTypical model range accepted
Apple£40-£895iPhone 17 Pro Max to iPhone 8 Plus
Samsung£10-£629Galaxy S25 Ultra to Galaxy S9
Google£50-£445Google Pixel 10 Pro Fold to Google Pixel
John Lewis£5-£756Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max to Huawei Mate 20
Currys£1-£790Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max to Nokia 8.1

Our advice: Always check the brand's own store for trade-in deals and other special offers, such as tech bundles. They can often match or beat deals from traditional retailers.

4. Buying on contract

Smartphone with the screen showing a checkout basket, while the user's finger is poised to press

By spreading the cost with monthly fees and low or no deposit required, it’s tempting to buy a new device on contract, especially in the case of expensive flagship smartphones. However, we’ve found you'll often end up paying more overall than buying a Sim-free phone, especially when it comes to data.

The new iPhone Duo, for example, is prohibitively expensive for most of us at £1,999, but spread out monthly the handset can be yours for less than £100. However, when we crunched the numbers we found you'd end up paying about £170 extra over two years, just for the handset. You'll pay way more than that for the Sim, though, which can work out more than £1,000 more expensive than going with a third-party provider. Buying the new iPhone Duo with EE, O2 or Vodafone on a four-year contract would mean paying £37 a month for their basic unlimited data Sim, with price rises built-in. Meanwhile, we’ve found 100GB 5G data plans for as little as £10 a month.

Our advice: Pay the upfront cost of a handset if you possibly can, and spread the cost with interest-free purchase options if available (both Samsung and Apple offer them, along with various retailers). You could also consider interest-free credit cards.

5. Buying a phone with a short shelf-life

Long-term software and security support is an increasingly attractive feature on modern smartphones, as increasing amounts of personal data are stored on and collected by them. Without it, we’d be at greater risk from hacks and scams, and that’s before phone performance and app compatibility is even mentioned.

Google led the way by offering seven years of support from launch on all its phones since the Pixel 8. Samsung and Fairphone weren’t far behind, with seven years of support now on Samsung devices, and between five and eight years on selected Fairphones. Apple’s support is harder to nail down - it promises five years of support from launch, but this often stretches to six years or even longer on some devices. 

You can check how many years’ security support is left on our review pages, where we list the estimated end date in the specifications. You can also head to our mobile phone support calculator to find out how long a handset has left. Some brands such as Xiaomi offer just two years of support from launch, and while it ‘may support the security updates for three years or longer for some models’ that’s hardly reassuring if you’re buying last year's model in the sales. 

Our advice: If you're happy to keep a phone for its full lifetime, consider the cost of the phone against the amount of support remaining – effectively calculating the cost of ownership per year.

More Black Friday phone traps to watch out for

Want more tips to help navigate the phones market? 

  • Pay attention to storage. Phones with the smallest amount of internal storage (typically 128GB or 256GB) are always the least expensive, but because most modern handsets lack expandable storage, you need to choose wisely or risk paying for ongoing cloud subscriptions. Check how much storage you’re using on your current phone (after cleaning up the space) to give yourself a rough ballpark figure, but remember this will increase in time and that newer apps often require more storage space. Alternatively, aim for more entry-level handsets: Our reviews show more than half of phones costing less than £350 have space for a MicroSD card for cheap storage upgrades.
  • Beware of 'grey imports' - phones from the European or Asian markets that might not support UK carriers. These are more typical of deals found on online marketplaces – so check seller credentials carefully before you buy, including feedback from previous buyers.
  • Now that support periods on phones are far longer, the refurbished market has never been more appealing. Pick a good second-hand retailer and you'll get peace of mind after you buy, too. iPhones are particularly popular in this market, along with flagship Samsung models.
  • Finally, as yourself if you really need a new phone at all. Gone are the days when fancy new features make the latest models a must-buy – provided your phone is still supported, you could give it a new lease of life. We've got guides on how to speed up an smartphone, and free up storage space.