The CMA's consultation on access to NFC technology on iOS - Which? response
We support the CMA taking action to open up competition and innovation in NFC enabled products and services on iOS devices. Apple’s restrictions on NFC access are anti-competitive and hold back growth and innovation that can benefit consumers. The biggest use of NFC today is for contactless payments, and our research has shown that mobile digital wallets are used by a majority of UK consumers. Many consumers use their phones regularly to make payments, and lots of them rely exclusively on their digital wallets when out and about in place of physical payment methods. Opening up competition for digital wallet services should result in innovative services that benefit consumers. Our research estimates that the potential value of four innovative digital wallet features (automatic loyalty points, receipt storage, ID storage and flexible card functionality) is substantial, with estimates varying between c.£120m and £560m per year. Even at the lower estimate, this indicates that increased competition could lead to significant economic benefits in the UK.
We broadly support the non-pricing terms in the CMA’s proposed conduct requirement, including that access be provided with limited exceptions across both available technologies: Host-based Card Emulation (HCE) and a Secure Element (SE). Providing flexibility to third-parties across these NFC technologies is necessary to realise the full extent of the potential benefits of NFC service innovation.
However, we do not support the CMA’s proposed approach of allowing Apple to provide access to NFC for a fee that it is left to determine based on high level principles. Our preference is for NFC access to be provided free of charge, as is the preference of the vast majority of stakeholders and as is the case in Europe. NFC technology is a global technology that is not owned by Apple. The CMA’s use of principles provides Apple too much discretion to justify a fee based on the value it thinks it provides to developers. We do not think that Apple can fairly assess this value, adjusting for its substantial and entrenched market power, and are concerned that the proposed approach will result in Apple overcharging for NFC access and constraining the potential benefits.
pdf (268 KB)
There is a file available for download. (pdf — 268 KB). This file is available for download at .
