We use cookies to allow us and selected partners to improve your experience and our advertising. By continuing to browse you consent to our use of cookies. You can understand more and change your cookies preferences here.

Coronavirus Read our latest advice
5 November 2019

Best place to buy turkey and trimmings

Find out the best place to buy your turkey and trimmings, as chosen by Which? members.
By Alice Williams

Cooking Christmas dinner can be daunting, but you can avoid turkey terror by choosing the best place to buy your bird.

We surveyed 4,226 members in January 2019 to find out where they rated top for Christmas dinner essentials.

Turkey

Specialist suppliers, butchers and farm shops are tops for turkey, our members told us. As in previous years, our members loved the succulent taste and excellent quality of their turkey centrepiece.

In fourth place was a store we've not seen rated so highly before, followed by one of the low-cost supermarkets that members said brought an excellent value, tasty turkey to their tables.

Only logged in Which? members can view the results of our survey below. If you’re not a member, join Which? to get instant access.

Best place to buy turkey
Retailer Taste Quality Value for money Customer score
Retailer 1 93%
Retailer 2 92%
Retailer 3 91%
Retailer 4 86%
Retailer 5 85%
Retailer 6 81%
Retailer 7 80%
Retailer 8 77%
Retailer 9 77%
Retailer 10 74%
Retailer 11 73%
Retailer 12 73%
Retailer 13 71%

Table notes: Based on a survey of 2,761 Which? members taken in January 2019.

 Sausages

Whether you’re swaddling them in bacon for pigs in blankets or frying them up for a Boxing Day breakfast, our members loved the bangers they got from their butcher or farm shop while picking up the turkey.

Our top scoring supermarket for sausages scored highly for value for money with Which? members. However, they felt that either the quality, taste or the price of their sausage suffered with other supermarkets.

Best place to buy sausages
Retailer Taste Quality Value for money Customer score
Retailer 1 93%
Retailer 2 89%
Retailer 3 81%
Retailer 4 78%
Retailer 5 77%
Retailer 6  - 76%
Retailer 7 74%
Retailer 8 73%
Retailer 9 71%
Retailer 10 70%
Retailer 11 69%

Table notes: Based on a survey of 2,760 Which? members taken in January 2019.

Stuffing

It was the same story for stuffing - butchers and farm shops were rated for high-quality stuffing that tasted delicious.

Of the top two supermarkets rated for stuffing, one had a quality rating that stood shoulder-to-shoulder with the butchers and farm shops, whilst the other offered outstanding value for money, our members said.

Best place to buy stuffing
Retailer Taste Quality Value for money Customer score
Retailer 1 93%
Retailer 2 88%
Retailer 3 80%
Retailer 4 79%
Retailer 5 78%
Retailer 6 74%
Retailer 7 72%
Retailer 8 71%
Retailer 9 71%
Retailer 10 68%

Table notes: Based on a survey of 1,917 Which? members taken in January 2019.

 Fresh vegetables

Those lucky enough to have a local market on their doorstep were the most satisfied with their Christmas veg, followed closely by greengrocer, veg box scheme and farm shop customers.

If you’re filling your festive basket at a supermarket, there are two options for veg at the top of the table. Although their taste and quality wasn’t rated quite as highly as the best sellers offered, members said they excelled at offering excellent value for money.

Best place to buy fresh vegetables
Retailer Taste Quality Value for money Customer score
Retailer 1 92%
Retailer 2 90%
Retailer 3 89%
Retailer 4 88%
Retailer 5 86%
Retailer 6 82%
Retailer 7 82%
Retailer 8 80%
Retailer 9 80%
Retailer 10 79%
Retailer 11 77%
Retailer 12 77%
Retailer 13 72%
Retailer 14 70%

Table notes: Based on a survey of 1,939 Which? members taken in January 2019.