We use cookies to allow us and selected partners to improve your experience and our advertising. By continuing to browse you consent to our use of cookies. You can understand more and change your cookies preferences here.

Coronavirus Read our latest advice
Reviews based on facts
Our rigorous tests find the facts, and our impartial reviews tell you the truth about how products perform. First month £5, then £9.99 per month, cancel anytime.
Try Which?
1 October 2020

Why choosing where to give birth matters

Find out how planning to have your baby at home, in a birth centre or in a labour ward can affect your birth experience and what to consider if you’ve been told you’re at higher risk of complications.
BO-Why-choosing-matters
W
WhichEditorial team

Where can I choose to give birth?

The type of birth you have and the care you receive will be shaped by the choices you make about where to give birth.

You can plan to have your baby in one of the following birth environments:

Birth centres are either an 'alongside midwifery unit' at a hospital or a 'freestanding midwifery unit' located elsewhere.

Where you plan to give birth can affect many things, from the facilities available to how likely you are to know your midwife.

Here, we go through the top factors to take into consideration when choosing where to have your baby.

You can also use our Where to give birth tool to find the best option based on what’s important to you and your personal circumstances.

Pain relief available during labour

The pain relief available to you depends on the birth environment you choose and the use of it more likely in some birth settings than others. 

The Birthplace In England Research Programme study of almost 65,000 women at low risk of complications found that women planning to give birth in a labour ward were substantially more likely to have an epidural than those planning to give birth at home or in a birth centre.

The study found that even when a low-risk woman was transferred into a labour ward from home or a birth centre, she was still less likely to have an epidural than a low-risk woman who had planned to give birth in the labour ward all along.

Find out more about your pain relief options.

Having a water birth or using water for pain relief

Women who plan to give birth in a freestanding birth centre or at home are more likely to have a water birth than women who plan to deliver in a labour ward. Therefore, choosing to have your baby in an out-of-hospital setting gives you a better chance of using water in labour.

If you're really keen on a water birth, it's worth considering this when you're planning where to give birth.

Find out more about water births and using a birth pool.

Getting to know your midwife

Where you choose to give birth can affect the extent to which you get to know your midwives before the birth.

Research from the NCT found that women who gave birth in a freestanding birth centre or had a home birth were more likely to have already met the midwives caring for them than women who gave birth in a maternity unit.

In a

by the NCT and the Women’s Institute, the majority of women reported that knowing their midwife had a positive impact on their labour, with around two-thirds saying it made them feel more relaxed, confident and safe.

How far you have to travel in labour

If you choose to give birth in a hospital or a birth centre, it's likely you'll travel there while you’re having contractions.

Even if you're planning to have your baby at home or in a freestanding birth centre, you may have to travel to a hospital if it turns out you need extra help during labour, such as the intervention of a consultant.

Think about how far you’re prepared to travel, as this will affect your options.

Your chance of having medical interventions

If you have a home birth or give birth in a birth centre, you are less likely to end up having medical interventions such as being induced, having an assisted birth or having an unplanned caesarean. 

However, if it turns out you need intervention for the safety of you or your baby, you'll be transferred to a hospital.

Your postnatal care

How long you stay in the unit after the birth can vary from a couple of hours to a few days, depending on how you and your baby are, as well as on the policies of the hospital.

Our guide to postnatal care explains what you can expect after giving birth in a labour ward, birth centre or at home.

If you’re at higher risk of complications

Certain medical conditions or circumstances can increase your risk of experiencing complications during labour. Some more common examples include if you’re carrying multiples, your baby is breech or you’ve had a caesarean for a previous birth.

For a full list of risk factors see the NICE Intrapartum Care Guidelines. For more information about maternity care for specific conditions see the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG) Patient Information Leaflets.

If you have a higher risk pregnancy, you’ll be referred to a consultant who can talk you through what that means for you, your baby and the birth. It’s important to bear in mind that even if you’re considered higher risk, it doesn’t mean that you’re likely to experience problems, but rather that it's more likely than for someone who doesn’t have those risk factors.

Where will I be recommended to give birth?

If you’re at increased risk of complications, it’s likely that you’ll be recommended to give birth in a labour ward so that medical staff and equipment will be available at any time, should you or your baby need them. However, where and how you give birth is always your choice.

Planning a home birth or using a birth centre

If you’ve been recommended to give birth on the labour ward but don’t feel like it’s the right option for you, discuss your circumstances and options with your midwife, GP or obstetrician.

Planning to give birth at home or in a freestanding birth centre may reduce your likelihood of needing medical interventions, but of course you won’t have doctors and medical equipment close by.

In many cases, there’s little evidence available about the relative safety of birth in these settings for women at increased risk of complications. For example, there are no official statistics comparing how safe it is for women planning to give birth at home compared to in hospital after a previous caesarean section.

Personalising your care

If you’re having difficulty getting support to give birth where you want, the following options could be useful to you.

  • Agree a plan where you give birth in the labour ward, but are supported to have a natural birth in that environment. You would need to ensure that you’ll be looked after by an experienced midwife and/or supported by a birth partner or doula.
  • Arrange to give birth in an alongside birth centre, with easy transfer to the labour ward if problems arise. This may not be possible, as many birth centres have strict criteria on who can plan to give birth there.
  • Arrange your own home birth. If you’re unable to get support from the NHS for a home birth, you can consider using the services of a private midwife (such as an independent midwife). Read more about private maternity options.

Maternity care: how you should be treated

Whatever decision is reached, you should feel that your questions and concerns have been listened to, and that you’ve been fully informed about the condition that could affect you and/or your baby.

You should have a written birth plan which sets out what has been decided, and the situations in which you may agree to the use of interventions, or when you would prefer to avoid these.

If you’re not planning to give birth in a labour ward, the arrangements for transfer to one in the event of problems should be clear.

It could take a while to reach this point, so making contact with health professionals early in your pregnancy can be useful. It might be helpful to bring your partner, birth partner or a friend to appointments - these can be difficult conversations, so it helps to have some moral support.

What if I still don’t get the care I want?

If, following discussions, you feel you will not get the maternity care you want, you can arrange to speak to a local Supervisor of Midwives, a consultant midwife or the Head of Midwifery at your maternity hospital.

You can also reach out to organisations working for women’s rights in childbirth:

It can feel difficult to negotiate care which conflicts with what’s being offered to you. Make use of whatever support is available so you can make the best decision for yourself and your baby.