We use cookies to allow us and selected partners to improve your experience and our advertising. By continuing to browse you consent to our use of cookies. You can understand more and change your cookies preferences here.

Coronavirus Read our latest advice
Reviews based on facts
Our rigorous tests find the facts, and our impartial reviews tell you the truth about how products perform. First month £5, then £9.99 per month, cancel anytime.
Try Which?
1 October 2020

Best Dolce Gusto-compatible coffee pods for 2020

Should you buy branded pods for your Dolce Gusto coffee machine, or can compatible pods offer tastier, better-value coffee?
Dolce gusto compatible pods main
RM
Rebecca Marcus

Until relatively recently, owners of Dolce Gusto coffee machines had been restricted to using Dolce Gusto's official range of branded coffee pods, which can be pricey.

But now an increasing number of third-party Dolce Gusto-compatible coffee pods are becoming available, giving owners of Dolce Gusto coffee machines more choice over the coffee they drink.

Most are supermarket own-brand options, which are cheaper than Dolce Gusto pods, so switching could lead to big savings for regular coffee drinkers. One supermarket pod could save you more than £70 a year compared with the official Dolce Gusto version, based on having two coffees per day.

We asked a panel of expert coffee tasters to blind-taste and rate Nescafé Dolce Gusto pods alongside compatible pods from brands such as Aldi, Asda, Costa, Lidl and Starbucks.

Below, we reveal the best options for Americano and latte drinkers.

Not sure which coffee pod system is right for you? Check our pod machine buying guide for advice on how Nespresso, Dolce Gusto and more compare.

Best Americano pods for Dolce Gusto coffee machines

Our expert tasting panel blind-tasted Americano pods from Dolce Gusto, Costa and Starbucks alongside cheaper compatible options from budget supermarkets Aldi and Lidl.

Overall, they found that all the drinks came out too weak and suggested making a smaller coffee to give a stronger taste. But some options fared better than others.

Log in or sign up to Which? to reveal the results in the table below.

 

 
Price Recycling info Overall score
£2.49 for 16 pods (16p per pod) Not stated

This pale-coloured coffee had a distinctive crema and pleasant milk chocolate flavour that was enhanced when combined with milk. The mouthfeel was a little thin for our judges' liking though.

Find out which coffee pod we’re talking about - log in or join Which? today.

Price Recycling info Overall score
£4.50 for 16 pods (28p per pod) Recyclable

via drop-off points

This mellow-flavoured coffee had a nice thick crema when milk was added. However, the mouthfeel was considered too thin and watery.

Find out which coffee pod we’re talking about - log in or join Which? today.

Price Recycling info Overall score
£4.09 for 16 pods (26p per pod) Drop off at CollectPlus, only if ordered through Dolce Gusto website

Our judges thought this coffee was thin and lacked body. The flavour was fairly bland, with a mild sweetness, although it tasted better when milk was added.

Find out which coffee pod we’re talking about - log in or join Which? today.

Price Recycling info Overall score
£9.96 for 64 (16p per pod) Not recyclable

Mild flavoured with a slightly woody taste and almost no body, this coffee didn’t impress our expert panel much. One judge said it had very few coffee characteristics.

Find out which coffee pod we’re talking about - log in or join Which? today.

Price Recycling info Overall score
£2.89 for 16 pods (18p per pod) Not recyclable

While it had a reasonably good crema, the judges didn’t find much else to admire in this bland, thin offering. One expert said it had ‘almost no flavour whatsoever’, while another said it was ‘like drinking water’.

Find out which coffee pod we’re talking about - log in or join Which? today.

Price Recycling info Overall score
£4 for 12 pods (33p per pod) Recyclable via drop-off scheme

As the lowest scorer overall, this is a coffee that’s probably best avoided. The judges were disappointed with its poor flavour, watery mouthfeel and very thin, almost non-existent, crema.

Find out which coffee pod we’re talking about - log in or join Which? today.

Table notes: Results published April 2020. All pods are compatible with Dolce Gusto coffee machines.

Dolce Gusto vs compatible Latte pods

As well as Americanos, there are compatible versions of latte and cappuccino Dolce Gusto pods available for fans of milky coffees. These come with a second pod that contains milk powder, which is used to make the milk froth.

We asked our panel to assess these, too, to find out how the cheaper compatible pods compare. Our panel liked the Dolce Gusto, Starbucks Latte Macchiato and Costa Signature Blend Latte best, but thought the cheaper Lidl and Aldi latte pods had an unpleasant artificial sweetness that didn’t compare well to coffee made with fresh milk.

How we tested Dolce Gusto pods

 We asked a panel of coffee experts to blind-taste and rate a range of Dolce Gusto-compatible pods.

Our panel of independent coffee experts included:

  • Giles Hilton – panel head, coffee specialist with 40 years’ tasting experience
  • Colin Smith – artisan coffee roaster and former president of the Speciality Coffee Association of Europe
  • Charles Love – tea and coffee product expert and trainer
  • Mike Nunn – head of training at Monmouth Coffee Co, which has been roasting and selling coffee since 1978

We made each coffee using a Best Buy Dolce Gusto machine and asked our experts to taste it both with and without milk.

They rated the aroma, appearance, flavour, mouthfeel, sweetness and aftertaste of each coffee. These ratings were then combined into an overall percentage score.

Choosing the best pod coffee machine

Not sure what type of coffee machine is right for you? There are several types of pod coffee machine, most of which just work with one type of coffee pod, such as Nespresso or Dolce Gusto, which limits your options to the range available for that brand.

Nespresso has the most extensive range of compatible pods, but Dolce Gusto oprions are becoming more common. See our coffee pod machine buying guide for advice on choosing the best system for you.

If you don't want to choose, some coffee machines work with both types of pod. See our Lakeland 2-in-1 Coffee Pod Machine review for a model that takes both types of coffee pod.