
Health? or Hype?
Make the right choice with recommendations you can trust, backed by expert testing.
Explore health recommendationsBy clicking a retailer link you consent to third-party cookies that track your onward journey. This enables W? to receive an affiliate commission if you make a purchase, which supports our mission to be the UK's consumer champion.

Bubbling on toast, grated over a jacket potato or included in the mix of a great cheeseboard, strong cheddar brings a tasty tang to a multitude of meals and snacks.
To find out what cheddar should be your go-to option, we gathered 75 cheese lovers at our test lab to try out 11 extra mature cheddars.
They were given three well-known brands to taste – Castello, Cathedral City and Pilgrims Choice – alongside eight supermarket own labels from Aldi, Sainsbury’s, Tesco and more.
Our blind-taste tests revealed three deliciously satisfying Best Buys. These included one of the big brands, plus an excellent low-cost supermarket cheddar. Read on to discover which were the favourites.
How we found the best extra mature cheddar
Large tasting panel
Our panel of 75 people ate their way through 10kg of cheddar (32 blocks) to find the tastiest choice.
Blind-tasting
Our tasters weren’t told which cheddar they were trying, and didn’t discuss their opinions with others.
What's good about extra mature cheddar?
Our tasters considered the merits of the different extra mature cheddars, rating them on appearance, flavour, saltiness, creaminess and more.
Rigorous
All our results are checked and analysed by our in-house statistical team for accuracy.
The cheeses we tested are listed in alphabetical order below.
Only logged-in Which? members and free account owners can view the best extra mature cheddar from our tests. You can sign up for free to get instant access to our test results and Best Buy recommendations.

Available from: Aldi, in-store only (£2.99) (350g)
Saturated fat per 100g: 23.4g
Salt per 100g: 1.82g
Log in or sign up to see our expert verdict.

Available from: Asda (£3.52) (300g)
Saturated fat per 100g: 22g
Salt per 100g: 1.8g
Log in or sign up to see our expert verdict.

Available from: Asda (£3.24), Ocado (£4.50), Sainsbury’s (£4.50) and Tesco (£4.50) (300g)
Saturated fat per 100g: 22g
Salt per 100g: 1.8g
Log in or sign up to see our expert verdict.

Available from: Asda (£3.50), Iceland (£4), Morrisons (£2.75), Ocado (£3.50), Sainsbury’s (£3.75), Tesco (£3.50) and Waitrose (£4.25) (350g).
Saturated fat per 100g: 21.7g
Salt per 100g: 1.8g
Log in or sign up to see our expert verdict.

Available from: Lidl (£2.99) (350g)
Saturated fat per 100g: 21.7g
Salt per 100g: 1.8g
Log in or sign up to see our expert verdict.

Available from: M&S (in-store only) and Ocado (£5.25) (300g)
Saturated fat per 100g: 21.7g
Salt per 100g: 1.8g
Log in or sign up to see our expert verdict.

Available from: Morrisons (£3) (300g)
Saturated fat per 100g: 24.3g
Salt per 100g: 1.78g
Log in or sign up to see our expert verdict.

Available from: Asda (£3.08), Co-op (£5.15), Morrisons (£4.19), Sainsbury’s (£4.25), Tesco (£4.25) and Waitrose (£2.96) (350g)
Saturated fat per 100g: 21.7g
Salt per 100g: 1.8g
Log in or sign up to see our expert verdict.

Available from: Sainsbury's (£3.95) (350g)
Saturated fat per 100g: 21.7g
Salt per 100g: 1.81g
Log in or sign up to see our expert verdict.

Available from: Tesco (£3.50) (200g)
Saturated fat per 100g: 21.7g
Salt per 100g: 1.8g
Log in or sign up to see our expert verdict.

Available from: Waitrose (£3.18) (350g)
Saturated fat per 100g: 21.7g
Salt per 100g: 1.8g
Log in or sign up to see our expert verdict.
All the cheddars were blind-tasted and rated in September 2026 at our specialist test lab by a panel of 75 people.
We recruited a panel of people who regularly buy and eat cheddar, and who broadly represent the demographic profile of adults in the UK (age range, gender split and more).
The taste test was conducted blind, so our testers didn’t know which brand they were trying. They tasted the cheddars in a fully rotated order to avoid any bias. Each tester had a private tasting booth, so they couldn’t discuss what they were tasting or be influenced by others.
The tasters rated the flavour, aroma, appearance and texture of each brand of cheddar and told us what they liked and disliked.
The overall score was based on:
These weightings are based on what people ranked as the most important attributes when tasting cheddar. All our results are checked and analysed by our in-house statistical team.
Find out more about our editorial independence policy and see behind the scenes of our taste tests to understand more about how we work
Which? nutritionist and senior researcher Charlotte Phillips said:

'Extra mature cheddar is a useful source of calcium and protein, but its salt and saturated fat content can add up fast, especially since the standard 30g recommended serving (think the size of a small matchbox) is far smaller than what many of us actually eat. Once grated or sliced, it's easy to lose track of this portion size and consume double, or even triple, that amount without realising, pushing salt intake to more than 1g in a single sitting (remember, we ought to be consuming no more than 6g salt per day).
'Opting for extra mature cheddar is a useful way to make a little go a long way. The longer ageing process intensifies the savoury flavour, meaning a smaller amount can deliver the satisfying cheesy taste you’re craving on top of your pasta or in a toastie. Eating less cheese can, in turn, help to keep your overall intake of salt and saturated fat in check, while potentially also saving you money, as the block lasts longer.
'Another bonus is that extra mature cheddar is naturally lower in lactose due to the ageing process, making it potentially easier for people who are lactose sensitive to tolerate. However, lactose intolerance varies from person to person, so it shouldn't be presented as suitable for everyone with digestive symptoms.'
Nutrition per 100g, sorted by highest saturated fat:
| Energy | Overall fat | Saturated fat | Protein | Salt | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Morrisons | 422 | 35.2 | 24.3 | 24.3 | 1.78 |
Aldi | 417 | 34.6 | 23.4 | 23.2 | 1.82 |
Castello | 416 | 35 | 22 | 25 | 1.8 |
Asda | 416 | 35 | 22 | 25 | 1.8 |
Pilgrims Choice | 416 | 34.9 | 21.7 | 25.4 | 1.8 |
Cathedral City | 416 | 34.9 | 21.7 | 25.4 | 1.8 |
Sainsbury's | 416 | 34.9 | 21.7 | 25.4 | 1.81 |
Tesco | 416 | 34.9 | 21.7 | 25.4 | 1.8 |
M&S | 416 | 34.9 | 21.7 | 25.4 | 1.8 |
Waitrose | 416 | 34.9 | 21.7 | 25.4 | 1.8 |
Lidl | 416 | 34.9 | 21.7 | 25.4 | 1.8 |

Make the right choice with recommendations you can trust, backed by expert testing.
Explore health recommendations
Cheddar is high in fat, but there are various types of ‘light’ cheddar available that are lower in both overall fat and saturated fat.
The fat reduction does vary and can sometimes be more, but it's generally around 30%.
Cathedral City and Pilgrims Choice both have a lower-fat extra mature cheddar, as do many of the supermarkets, including own-label cheese from Asda, Tesco and Waitrose.
You can also find reduced-fat grated and sliced cheddar in some supermarkets.

All the extra mature cheddars we tested are suitable for vegetarians.
While traditional cheese making used animal rennet (from cow stomach enzymes) to coagulate the milk, most cheese is now made using non-animal rennet.
However, certain cheeses tend not to be vegetarian, including Parmesan and other parmesan-style hard cheeses. Check the label to be sure.
Fully plant-based ‘cheese’ is now widely available. Various supermarkets stock own-label grated and sliced cheddar, while Cathedral City has a plant-based mature block, slices and grated cheese.

As cheddar matures, it loses moisture and develops a sharper, tangier taste.
Mild cheddars are generally less than six months old, while at the other end of the scale, vintage cheddars are often at least 24 months old.
Mature cheddars tend to be 12-18 months old, while extra mature cheddars are aged for 18-24 months.
Which bread is best for you? Our analysis of 60 popular sliced loaves reveals which brown bread is the healthiest choice
Prices and availability correct as of November 2026.