Babystyle Oyster Carapace i-Size + Duo-Fix base review£199.00
This child car seat has passed the regulatory tests required by ECE R129/i-Size to be sold as suitable for children from 40cm–83 cm, which is from birth to 15 months of age. However, our frontal and side-impact crash tests are designed to be tougher than the legal minimum requirements, and revealed weaknesses in frontal-impact safety. The car seat completely detached from the DuoFix i-Size Isofix base and was sent flying forwards.
For this reason the test score is automatically downgraded to 0% and it's been made a Don't Buy. A good result in any of our other tests can't compensate for this poor result.
Further readingUse our tools, tips and advice to protect you and your home How we test child car seats
Try Which? for £1 to reveal the products that perform
Make smarter choices
- 0%Lowest score
- 65%Average score
- 82%Highest score
How the seat is secured to the car
The Which? difference
As well as thousands of impartial product reviews from our Test Labs, a Which? membership also gets you:
- Unlimited access across which.co.uk
- Advice on the move with our apps
- Which? magazine delivered to your door
- The inside scoop on important issues, from scams to savings accounts
Which? can help you make good decisions
Best baby car seats
Key safety differences between baby car seats and child car seats. Why babies need more protection in car crashes and how to keep them as safe as possible. Plus car seat carrycots vs baby car seats.
How to buy the right child car seat
Get our expert advice on which car seat you need for a newborn, baby or child. We explain car seat weight groups and i-Size, and give top tips on how to buy the best child car seat when you head to the shops.
Car seat weight groups
Which? guide to car seat weight groups. From group 0+ 0-13kg (birth to around 12-15 months to Group 1/2/3 9-36kg (around 9 months to 12 years), find out why it matters, weight groups vs I-size and when to go up a car seat group