By clicking a retailer link you consent to third-party cookies that track your onward journey. This enables W? to receive an affiliate commission if you make a purchase, which supports our mission to be the UK's consumer champion.

How we test microwaves

Which? goes to great lengths to find the best microwaves. Our Best Buy models excel at heating food evenly while being easy to use and clean

As the Which? cooking appliance expert, Jamie works with scientists and market analysts to give ovens, fryers, microwaves and more a good grilling. She helps shoppers get the most for their money with trustworthy, science-backed advice.  

Row of white microwaves on display in a store, with labels beneath each appliance and a blurred background.

We’ve been testing microwaves for over 10 years. Each one goes through 321 individual tests before being scored and reviewed. So we’re well equipped to recognise brilliant models from inferior ones that leave you with unevenly heated leftovers.

While reviews you read elsewhere may be based on a single user’s experience with a microwave, a panel of experts regularly reviews and updates our stringent lab test programmes. They ensure our tests simulate the habits of actual home cooks.

Our testing is always independent and our verdicts are never for sale. We don’t accept freebies or samples – instead, we buy appliances directly from retailers. This prevents manufacturers from influencing our reviews, and it means we test the same standard of microwave you would buy in the shops.

We aren't funded by advertisers either – our operating costs are covered by our members. This means we don’t have to answer to microwave brands to secure our next paycheck. If a microwave is a dud, we’re free to deem it a Which? Don’t Buy – and we do.

For all these reasons, you can have complete trust in our verdict.

Nobody goes to the lengths we do to find the best microwaves.

Our statement of editorial independence

We’re not influenced by third parties and we don't accept freebies from product manufacturers or retailers. As a not-for-profit organisation, we have no owners, shareholders or government departments to answer to, so we work entirely on behalf of you, the consumer – nobody else.

Read our full statement of editorial independence.

Heating: is the microwave good at heating and reheating food?

We use a mock ready-meal substance embedded with sensors to record temperature distribution during heating
We use a mock ready-meal substance embedded with sensors to record temperature distribution during heating

We test how well each microwave cooks or reheats food by using a special substance which has a similar consistency to lasagne when heated in a microwave. We heat the substance on full power and record how evenly the microwave heats it up, including whether all parts of it reach a safe temperature and whether the microwave is likely to dry out your food.

Many microwaves lose power with successive use, which means that you’d end up needing to heat your second round of food for longer than your first. With this in mind, we check how well microwaves maintain their heating power if used to reheat two meals in a row.

What separates a good result from a poor one?

A microwave that scores five stars in our heating tests will heat your food quickly and evenly without drying it out. The worst microwaves score one star. These models will take far too long to heat up food, won’t get it hot enough or leave it dry and unappetising.

Defrosting: how good is it at defrosting?

Which? microwave defrosting test
We use 14 temperature sensors to test whether the mince has defrosted evenly

We use slabs of lean, minced beef, which have been frozen for 12 hours, and set the microwave to defrost according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Then, we record the difference between the highest and lowest temperatures in the defrosted meat, and check for hot or cold spots. When the microwave has them, we also defrost our frozen mince using its pre-set auto-defrost programs. 

What separates a good result from a poor one?

Microwaves that score five stars on this test will defrost meat evenly, while low-scorers start cooking some parts while leaving others still frozen. We’ve seen some microwaves that produce more than a 20°C difference between parts while defrosting. The best leave a perfectly defrosted slab with an even temperature throughout. 

Ease of use: is it easy to use and quiet?

We investigate how easy it is to program the microwave and carry out simple tasks such as cleaning and opening and closing the door.

A kitchen can often be the busiest room in a home, so nobody wants a microwave loud enough to drown out conversation. That’s why we record microwave noise when heating on full power and when defrosting.

What separates a good result from a poor one?

The best microwaves are very easy and intuitive to use, while the worst models will leave you reaching for the manual time and time again.
Quiet microwaves make around 47 dB of noise, but the loudest make 62 dB, which will sound three times louder and be noisy enough to irritate some people.

Grilling and/or convection cooking: if the microwave has these functions, are they any good?

When microwaves have grill and convection functions, we test them to find out how well they work.

To check how effective a microwave’s grill is, we cover the grill rack with white, crustless bread and measure the spread and evenness of heating through the browning. We also bake trays of fairy cakes to test the convection function on combination microwaves.

What separates a good result from a poor one?

A great grill will evenly toast more than 90% of the bread placed under it. The worst will hardly brown any of it at all, leaving it looking virtually the same as when it went in.

Meanwhile, the best combination microwaves will produce Bake-Off-worthy, well-risen, evenly browned cakes. Poor models will burn them, or leave some uncooked.

Steaming: how good is it at steaming?

If a microwave has a dedicated steam setting, we’ll test it by steaming a complete meal consisting of salmon, potatoes and broccoli. Using temperature probes in different parts of the fish, veg and potatoes, we check if any of the food remains uncooked after steaming.

What separates a good result from a poor one?

We’ve tested microwaves that impressed in this test by producing an evenly steam-cooked meal, while some models over-cooked parts and left others near-raw.

Expert advice on all things homes and appliances

free newsletter

Sign up for our Home newsletter, it's free monthly.

Our free Home newsletter delivers home-related content, along with other information about Which? Group products and services. We won't keep sending you the newsletter if you don't want it – unsubscribe whenever you want. Your data will be processed in accordance with our privacy notice.

Which? members can filter all our microwave reviews by speed and evenness of heating, ease of use and more of our expert test results.

How we calculate the scores

Which? scientific advisor, Jacob Compton

Jacob Compton, Which? scientific advisor, says:

‘To guarantee our scoring matches up with everyday use, we consistently survey Which? members to understand what they value most in a microwave. This real-world feedback forms the basis of our rigorous laboratory testing and how we judge the final results.

'Since members said how well a microwave evenly heats food matters most, this carries more weighting than other testing elements when I calculate the scores.’

The overall test scores are broken down differently depending on the type of microwave:

Solo microwaves 

  • 40% microwave heating
  • 25% defrosting
  • 25% ease of use
  • 10% steaming

Grill microwaves

  • 35% microwave heating
  • 25% defrosting
  • 25% ease of use
  • 7.5% grill 
  • 7.5% steaming

Combi microwaves

  • 35% microwave heating
  • 25% defrosting
  • 25% ease of use
  • 5% convection
  • 5% grill 
  • 5% steaming

How we choose the products

To make sure our reviews are 100% independent, we never accept free product samples. Instead, we invest just under £28,000 every year into buying built-in ovens directly from major retailers and testing them in our lab. 

We test regularly throughout the year so that we can deliver our reviews and verdicts to members as quickly as possible.

Which? market analyst, Cherie Cheung

Cherie Cheung, Which? market analyst, says: 

‘It’s my responsibility to track core launches on the microwave market to make sure we test all the popular models that people are actually going to buy. I do this by regularly speaking to manufacturers, as well as attending key product showcases and exhibitions to see what’s new with this staple kitchen appliance.

'This keeps us on top of the hottest microwave developments, so we can be ready to adapt, test, and review.’

Is it a Best Buy microwave? What our verdicts mean

Best Buy, Great Value, Eco Buy and Dont Buy badges

Our recommendations should help you to narrow down your shortlist, but it's always best to read our reviews in full to check for any deal breakers before parting with your hard-earned cash.

Best Buy-recommended microwaves

75% or more

Microwaves that score 75% or more in our tests are Best Buys and have our firm overall recommendation.

Best Buy microwaves tick all the most important boxes – they are good at heating, defrosting and steaming; most are also user-friendly, easy to clean and quiet, even at full power. 

Great Value-recommended microwaves

65% or more

Microwave prices vary a lot, with some premium models priced at more than £500. But if you're after a well-priced microwave, then our Great Value recommendation will come in handy.

Great Value microwaves are at least 20% cheaper than the average price of the microwaves we've tested and score 65% or more, so you'll get a decent product at a decent price.

Some Great Value models may also score well enough to be Best Buys, Eco Buys or both.

Eco Buy-recommended microwaves

65% or more

If you want to make a more sustainable choice when buying your next microwave, an Eco Buy model is a good option.

Eco Buy microwaves come from brands that have a decent reliability record and should save you money over their lifetime, when compared to other models.

To become an Eco Buy, a microwave must:

  • Have a total test score of at least 65%
  • Score five stars for energy consumption
  • Score at least four stars for cooking quality and ease of cleaning
  • Come from a brand with a good longevity rating in our annual consumer surveys

Less than 10% of our reviewed microwaves are sustainable enough to be made Eco Buys. 

Don't Buy microwaves

45% or below

Microwaves that score 45% or lower are Don't Buys. 

Don't Buy microwaves fall down in important areas and aren't worth spending your money on. 


Discover which models impressed in our lab – filter our microwave reviews by Best Buy, Eco Buy and Great Value to help find the right model for you.


Which? microwave testing changes

In 2023, after a survey showed our members place more value on a microwave's evenness of heating, we changed our evaluation criteria, increasing the score required for a microwave to be a Best Buy from 74% to 75%. This meant that some products lost their Best Buy recommendations. The affected models, while no longer Best Buys, are still great overall and worth buying.

In 2018, we updated our tests to make them even more challenging, including adding a new test on steaming food, based on member feedback about how they use their microwaves. This means that scores from microwaves tested from February 2018 or later aren't directly comparable with the scores of microwaves tested before this date.

Our microwave experts

Running our test projects is a group effort, with several members from across the team contributing to each one. 

We thoroughly re-evaluate our testing processes every year to ensure they're useful to you, and we ask the Which? community to tell us what matters the most when choosing a new microwave.

Here's the team that makes it happen:

From left to right: Researcher & writer, Jamie Mayne; Market analyst, Cherie Cheung; Scientific advisor, Jacob Compton; Home editor, Jackie Gallego
From left to right: Researcher & writer, Jamie Mayne; Market analyst, Cherie Cheung; Scientific advisor, Jacob Compton; Home editor, Jackie Gallego

Researcher & writer, Jamie Mayne: Jamie turns technical lab reports into in-depth, accessible product reviews and buying advice to separate great microwaves from the duds. She cuts through marketing bumph and unclear jargon to make sure you spend your money on a quality oven that serves your needs.

Market analyst, Cherie Cheung: Cherie keeps her finger on the pulse of the microwave world to choose which products we test, ensuring we review what’s relevant to consumers. From household names to up-and-comers, she looks beyond the hype to test what you really want to buy.

Scientific advisor, Jacob Compton: Jacob works directly with our labs to shape our rigorous test programme to make sure it answers our members key questions, and meticulously converts hundreds of facts and figures into easily digestible scores and star ratings to help inform our members’ buying decisions.

Home editor, Jackie Gallego: Jackie makes sure what you’re reading is what you want to know about microwaves. She helps ensure consumers are informed in their buying choices by finding important stories within our lab reports, from safety considerations to solving common problems.