By clicking a retailer link you consent to third-party cookies that track your onward journey. This enables W? to receive an affiliate commission if you make a purchase, which supports our mission to be the UK's consumer champion.

free member article

Best Christmas puddings: tastiest supermarket puds revealed

Find out which supermarket pudding makes the best festive finale

Background in biology and food science, with 20+ years’ experience writing about food, from sustainability and growing to health and everyday consumer issues.

Three Christmas puddings: Asda, Tesco, Waitrose

After feasting on a festive meal with all the trimmings, which premium Christmas pudding will best satisfy your taste buds?

To find out, we got together a panel of 70 Christmas pudding fans to sample 10 luxury supermarket puddings from Aldi, Sainsbury’s, Tesco and more.

Each taster was dished up 50g of each pud and asked to rate the puddings for appearance and aroma, as well as flavour and texture. 

Three prize puddings impressed across the board and are Best Buys for Christmas 2026. Read on to find out which delicious puddings got top marks and the bland puds that lacked spice.

How our tests find you the best

Large tasting panel

Our panel of 70 tasters sampled 10 supermarket brands and munched their way through more than 43kg of Christmas pudding.

Blind tasting

Tasters were given a heated portion of each pud. They had no idea which brand they were tasting, and there was strictly no discussion to avoid influencing scores.

In-depth ratings

As well as rating the overall flavour, texture, appearance and aroma, our panel of tasters also scored the puds on spiciness, sweetness and moistness.

Statistical analysis

All our results are checked and analysed by our in-house statistical team for accuracy.

Best Christmas puddings

Christmas puddings from Asda, Tesco and Waitrose topped the rankings, with all three puddings equally enjoyed by our tasters.

Not far behind, and also good choices, were Morrisons and Sainsbury’s puddings.

Best Buy: Asda Exceptional 12 Month Matured Luxury Christmas Pudding

Asda Exceptional Christmas pudding with Best Buy logo

Price: £9 for 800g (£1.13 per 100g) 

Score: 75%

Asda's luxury Christmas pudding is packed with plump vine fruits, glacé cherries, almonds, walnuts and pecans. It's also infused with sherry, brandy and cider, with a dash of cognac and cream.

All this indulgence impressed our tasters, who also highly rated the pudding's appearance, sweet taste and moist texture.

Although its festive alcohol and spice flavour was relatively mild, it suited most of our pudding fans.

This Asda pudding is also the cheapest of our three Best Buys, so it's a budget-friendly option for Christmas.

Available from Asda.

Best Buy: Tesco Finest 12 Month Matured Christmas Pudding

Tesco finest Christmas pudding with Best Buy logo

Price: £9 for 800g (£1.13 per 100g) 

Score: 75%

Tesco’s Christmas pudding was also popular with our tasters, who thought it looked great and had plenty of raisins, currants, glacé cherries, pecans and almonds.

Its moistness and sweet flavour were both hits – although it didn't quite match the two other top puds for succulent texture.

This pudding is laced with brandy, cider, Amontillado sherry and cognac, which went down a treat with most of our tasters. However, some said they would’ve preferred a stronger alcohol and spice flavour.

Available from Tesco.

Best Buy: Waitrose No.1 12 Month Matured Christmas Pudding 

Waitrose No 1 12 month matured Christmas pudding with Best Buy logo

Price: £14 for 800g (£1.75 per 100g) 

Score: 75%

While it’s quite a bit more expensive than our two other Best Buys, Waitrose’s good-looking Christmas pudding would be a worthy choice for a festive finale.

Our tasters relished its moist texture and indulgent sweetness. And there was no skimping on the succulent fruit, with plenty of raisins, currants and cherries, plus pecans and walnuts. 

Around two thirds of our pudding lovers said the spicy kick was perfect, and most felt the alcoholic punchiness was about right. Only a few wanted a stronger flavour.

Available from Waitrose.

Morrisons The Best 18 Month Matured Luxury Christmas Pudding

Morrisons the Best Christmas pudding

Price: £9 for 800g (£1.13 per 100g) 

Score: 71%

Brandy-soaked cherries, alongside generous amounts of pecans, walnuts and almonds, helped make this pudding popular with our tasters.

The majority relished the pudding's moist texture, and more than half our panel felt the sweetness and spiciness were just right.

It also packed a punch alcohol-wise. Half of our tasters loved this, though nearly a third found it a bit too much.

Available from Morrisons.

Sainsbury’s Taste The Difference 18 Month Matured Christmas Pudding

Sainsbury's taste the difference 18 month matured Christmas pudding

Price: £9.50 for 800g (£1.19 per 100g) 

Score: 71%

Packed with fruit and nuts – cherries, vine fruit, almonds, pecans and walnuts – Sainsbury’s Christmas pudding is also a decent choice.

It looked and smelled good, and most of our tasters loved its moist texture. Two thirds also enjoyed the pudding's festive spiciness, and nearly as many its sweetness.

However, the strength of alcohol flavour didn’t win universal approval. Nearly a third said it wasn’t boozy enough.

Available from Sainsbury’s.

How other Christmas puddings compare

Five Christmas puddings: Lidl, M&S, Aldi, Co-op, Iceland

Puddings from Lidl and M&S were next in line. Iceland's pud was the least liked, missing the mark flavour-wise.

  • Lidl Deluxe 18 Month Matured Christmas Pudding – 70% Excellent fruit and nut content, and most tasters enjoyed the pudding's texture and sweetness. But many thought it lacked alcohol and spice flavour. £4.49 for 400g (£1.12 per 100g). Available from Lidl (in-store only).
  • M&S Collection 12 Month Matured Christmas Pudding – 70% This pudding looked lovely and had a good aroma and moist texture. Its sweet spiciness was appreciated by many, but it didn’t win universal praise. £14 for 907g (£1.54 per 100g). Available from M&S (in-store only) and Ocado.
  • Aldi Specially Selected 24 Month Matured Christmas Pudding – 69% This dark-coloured pud with strong boozy notes was the joint cheapest on test. It was reasonably well liked, but tasters were divided over fruit and nut content. £6.99 for 800g (87p per 100g). Available from Aldi (in-store only).
  • Co-op Irresistible 12 Month Matured Christmas Pudding – 68% A mildly spiced pud that did well on looks and aroma. It had a reasonable texture, but struggled to deliver on flavour. £4.25 for 400g (£1.06 per 100g). Available from Co-op.
  • Iceland Luxury 18 Month Matured Christmas Pudding – 64% Joint cheapest on test, this dark-looking pud achieved just 50% approval for sweetness, spiciness and texture. Its flavour also struggled to win fans, and only a third said the booze flavour was right. £4 for 400g (£1 per 100g). Available from Iceland.

Best supermarket food and drink – from baked beans to peanut butter, see the full list of supermarket products that have topped our taste tests in 2026


Full results from our Christmas pudding taste test

Christmas puddingsScorePrice per puddingPudding sizePrice per 100gSugar per 100gSaturated fat per 100g
Best Buy:
Asda Exceptional 12 Month Matured Luxury Christmas Pudding
75%£9800g£1.1338g5.2g
Best Buy: Tesco Finest 12 Month Matured Christmas Pudding75%£9800g£1.1338g3.8g
Best Buy: Waitrose No.1 12 Month Matured Christmas Pudding 75%£14800g£1.7537.6g5.7g
Morrisons The Best 18 Month Matured Luxury Christmas Pudding

71%£9800g£1.1338.4g5.9g
Sainsbury’s Taste The Difference 18 Month Matured Christmas Pudding

71%£9.50800g£1.1941.7g6.8g
Lidl Deluxe 18 Month Matured Christmas Pudding70%£4.49400g£1.1239g5.3g
M&S Collection 12 Month Matured Christmas Pudding70%£14907g£1.5437.8g4.3g
Aldi Specially Selected 24 Month Matured Christmas Pudding 69%£6.99800g87p37.9g3.9g
Co-op Irresistible 12 Month Matured Christmas Pudding68%£4.25400g£1.0639g4g
Iceland Luxury 18 Month Matured Christmas Pudding64%£4400g£140.9g3.1g

Looking for other festive fare? Find out which supermarkets came top in our taste test of the best mince pies


Be a smarter consumer

free newsletter

Choose well, buy better and save money with the Weekly Scoop.

Unsubscribe whenever you want. Your data will be processed in accordance with our Privacy notice.

What's Christmas pudding made of?

Nutrition per 100g, sorted by highest sugar

 

Energy

Sugar (g)

Total fat (g)

Saturated fat (g)

Sainsbury's

360

41.7

11.3

6.8

Iceland

334

40.9

7.3

3.1

Co-op

320

39

7.9

4

Lidl

331

39

7.8

5.3

Morrisons

334

38.4

10.2

5.9

Asda

339

38

9

5.2

Tesco

320

38

7.5

3.8

Aldi

322

37.9

7

3.9

M&S

310

37.8

6.1

4.3

Waitrose

339

37.6

11

5.7

Recommended portion size: 100g

Which? nutritionist Charlotte Phillips.

Charlotte Phillips is a Which? nutritionist and senior researcher

Dried fruit makes up nearly 40% of a pudding, making it the leading ingredient across every supermarket Christmas pudding we reviewed. It can provide some nutritional benefits, including dietary fibre, vitamins, minerals and beneficial plant compounds called polyphenols. However, its 'health halo' is worth keeping in perspective. Although dried fruit contains naturally occurring sugars, the drying process removes water, concentrating these sugars into a smaller volume. Christmas puddings also contain added sugar and other ingredients that make them a relatively rich dessert.

Dried fruit can also be sticky and cling to teeth, so it's best to enjoy it as part of a meal rather than as a between-meal snack to help reduce the risk of tooth decay. 

Ultimately, while Christmas pudding provides some nutritional benefits from its fruit content, it's still a rich, traditional dessert best enjoyed in moderation as part of a balanced diet. 

How to cook your Christmas pudding

Microwaving is handy if you’re pushed for time, but steaming a Christmas pudding gives better results.

Microwaving takes just a few minutes but can cause the fat to separate too quickly, leaving the pudding dry and the fruit super-hot.

Steaming takes up to two hours (check instructions on the pack), but the end result is worth the wait. Once it’s bubbling on the hob, keep an eye on the water level to ensure it doesn't all evaporate – you don't want to burn your pan.

Vegetarian, vegan and free-from Christmas puddings

Six Christmas puddings: Tesco free from, M&S made without, Asda free from, Waitrose alcohol free, Sainsbury's alcohol free, Morrisons alcohol free

Traditional Christmas pudding always used to contain animal fat (suet), which made them unsuitable for vegetarians. However, all the premium puddings in our taste test are vegetarian. They also all contain alcohol, and typically contain gluten and dairy.

If you’re after a gluten-free, vegan or alcohol-free pudding, there are plenty to choose from. Here's a selection:

Alcohol-free

Gluten-free, dairy-free and vegan


Our taste test on alcohol-free beer guides you to which crowd-pleasing booze-free bottles to stock up on 


How mature is your Christmas pudding?

You’ll see supermarket Christmas puddings matured for 12 months, 18 months and even 24 months, with claims that a richer flavour develops as they age.

When we blind-tasted 12-month and 18-month matured puddings, some 12-month ones rated higher than the more mature options. 

The tastiest puddings, however, were simply the ones that were full of flavour and achieved the best blend of fruit, nuts, alcohol and spice.

How to light a Christmas pudding

Christmas pudding with a flame

Nothing beats a flaming Christmas pudding as a spectacular finale to a festive feast.

It can be a bit of a fiddle, though, so follow these tips:

  • To guarantee a good flame, use alcohol with a high spirit content (around 40%), such as rum, brandy or armagnac.
  • Gently heat around 2-4 tbsp of alcohol in a saucepan.
  • Remove from the heat, tilt the pan and carefully light the alcohol.
  • Immediately pour onto your pudding for an impressive flame.
  • Carefully carry it to the table.

Drinks to serve with Christmas pudding

Christmas cocktails in glasses

Tawny port makes an excellent accompaniment for Christmas pudding. According to our wine experts, it's actually a good all-rounder, pairing well with other festive food, including mince pies and cheddar.

If you’re not a port fan, other recommendations include a sweet sherry or other sweet fortified wine, such as Muscat de Beaumes-de-Venise.

Or try a boozy coffee, such as an espresso martini or traditional Irish coffee.

Spicy cocktails, especially those made with ginger, also blend well with the spices in a Christmas pudding.

Our experts suggest mulled cider works better than mulled wine with a festive pudding. Heat the cider with spices, then slosh in some brandy.


Which boozy bottles should grace your table on the big day? Our experts reveal the best red wine and best champagne from our taste tests


Does Christmas pudding contain palm oil?

Christmas pudding with cream served on plate

Most of the Christmas puddings on test contained palm oil.

Only Iceland’s pud didn't contain it, using shea and coconut oils instead.

For more on palm oil, how to spot it in products, and how to minimise its impact on vulnerable habitats, head to our guide on how to buy sustainable palm oil. 

How we tested Christmas pudding

All the Christmas puddings were blind-tasted and rated by a panel of 70 people in September 2026 at our specialist test lab.

We recruited a panel of people who enjoy eating Christmas pudding and who broadly represent the demographic profile of adults in the UK (age range, gender split and more). 

The taste test was blind, so our testers didn’t know which brand they were trying. They tasted the puddings in a fully rotated order to avoid any bias. Each tester had a private tasting booth so they couldn’t discuss what they were tasting or be influenced by others.

Each taster was served 50g of each pudding, heated according to the packaging instructions. Between them, they got through more than 43kg!

The tasters rated the flavour, aroma, appearance and texture of each Christmas pudding and told us what they liked and disliked. 

The overall score was based on:

  • 50% flavour
  • 20% appearance
  • 15% texture
  • 15% aroma

These weightings are based on what people ranked as the most important attributes when tasting Christmas pudding. Our in-house statistical team checks and analyses all our results.


Find out more about our editorial independence policy and see behind the scenes of our taste tests to understand more about how we work


Price and availability correct as of November 2026.