When you click on a retailer link on our site, we may earn affiliate commission to help fund our not-for-profit mission. Find out more.
We know from years of Which? research that many winter bargains aren’t as attractive as they first seem. So is it worth forgoing the shopping frenzy and seeking out smaller, independent shops and more sustainable shopping instead?
Since it caught on in the UK around a decade ago, our enthusiasm for Black Friday has grown exponentially. According to Statista, shoppers spent £7.95 billion over the 2020 Black Friday weekend.
Offers now appear weeks in advance, and many continue well into December.
But not only can the deals sometimes be duds, the November shopping rush can also add to your environmental impact.
If the rush for bargains is leaving you cold, here are our tips to ensure you don’t end up regretting a purchase, plus some alternative ways to shop.
Live more sustainably – get our free Sustainability newsletter to make changes for you and the planet
Research ahead of a Black Friday purchase
There are always deals to be found if you know where to look. But there are also pitfalls, so it pays to do your research and know what you want before you start spending.
The Which? experts have been hard at work identifying which discounts are the real deal, and which are duds.
Head to our Black Friday insider’s guide to find out more about how to spot if a deal is real and for our expert shopping tips.
Or head to our tailor-made guide to the best Black Friday 2021 deals.
We’ve also calculated how much you’ll pay in ongoing energy costs for key appliances. Head to our guide to how to use our new running costs tool to make sure you aren’t buying a cheap product that ends up costing you in the long run.
Only buy what you need
With so many retailers offering attractive discounts, there’s a risk that we snap up bargains without considering whether we’ll really make use of them.
Buying things we don’t need contributes to a throwaway culture and a rise in landfill waste. A shiny gadget that’s never used, or a half-price outfit that’s never worn, is not a bargain – it’s a waste of the energy and resources that went into making it.
But if you do need to replace an essential item, or you want to get started on your Christmas present list, there’s no harm checking the Black Friday offers to find a good deal on something you know you’d buy anyway.
Spend your money where it makes a difference
So, if you know what you need and are sure it’s the right choice for you, then where will your money make the most difference?
This year’s Black Friday weekend spending is expected to rise to £9.42 billion (Statista).
Spending just some of that cash in local, independent shops could make a real difference to small business owners. Buying locally made, sustainable goods can also reduce the need for shipping, and avoid packaging waste.
Here are five ways to turn your Black Friday green:
1. Shop Indie Week, 22-26 November 2021
Indie Week – billed as the independent alternative to Black Friday – is run by Just A Card, a grassroots campaign that encourages people to buy from artists, makers, independent shops, and small businesses.
Last year’s Indie Week saw over 55,000 independents take part. Search social media using the hashtag #justacard to find participating shops.
During Indie Week, Just A Card’s Visibility Fair online market will showcase the work of around 400 small businesses, all available to buy online.
2. Support Small Business Saturday, 4 December 2021
Small Business Saturday is another campaign that encourages consumers to shop local and support small businesses in their communities.
Its Small Business Finder lists retailers taking part and is searchable so you can find shops near you.
Small Business Saturday is supported by American Express, which runs regular promotions that reward Amex cardholders when they spend in participating small shops.
Amex Shop Small 2021 runs from 4-15 December. If you’re a cardholder, look out for the offer and add it to your card.
3. Visit your local high street in person or online
Independent high-street retailers need our support more than ever. Having survived closure during lockdowns, many still face lower footfall as people continue to work from home and shop online.
Smaller retailers often sell local, handmade, and sustainable products that you won’t find in chain stores or big online shopping sites.
Even if you can’t shop in person, there are online options too. Many independent shops have their own website or social media page, or a presence on online marketplaces.
Try Click It Local, a virtual high street selling everything from food, fashion, and gifts, to electronics and DIY. It allows you to buy from multiple independent businesses in one place, make one payment and have one consolidated delivery.
Or Trouva, which lists independent bricks-and-mortar boutiques and excludes online-only sellers. It’s Europe-wide, but you can limit your search to the UK, or find shops near you.
4. Try specialist online marketplaces
For unique handmade items, online marketplaces featuring independent sellers are the place to go.
Perhaps the most popular of these is US-based Etsy, but not everything you’ll see is handmade or made locally. Production may be outsourced to factories, so check listings carefully, and use the filter options to find local sellers and handmade or vintage items.
With a reputation for high-end products, Not on the High Street currently lists only UK-based sellers and is selective about who can join. Shoppers can search for items that are made in Britain and/or are eco-friendly.
While such platforms are a good way for small businesses and craftspeople to reach a wider audience, they all charge various monthly fees, listing fees, or commission, which reduces the amount the seller receives.
If you can buy direct from the seller’s own website or shop, more of your money goes directly into their pocket.
5. Buy nothing on Buy Nothing Day, 26 November 2021
The UK Buy Nothing Day campaign began in 2000, with a simple message: Shop less, live more.
You can participate in Buy Nothing Day by literally doing nothing at all. It’s a 24-hour detox from consumerism, and it’s free.
So if you’re determined to avoid over-consumerism and save money this Black Friday, Buy Nothing Day could be the answer.