By clicking a retailer link you consent to third-party cookies that track your onward journey. This enables W? to receive an affiliate commission if you make a purchase, which supports our mission to be the UK's consumer champion.

How we test freestanding cookers

Which? goes to great lengths to find the best freestanding cookers – our Best Buy models excel at baking biscuits and frying food to perfection, and they're easy to use and clean

As the Which? cooking appliance expert, Jamie works with scientists and market analysts to give ovens, fryers, microwaves and more a good grilling. She helps shoppers get the most for their money with trustworthy, science-backed advice.  

Stainless steel oven, white cabinets, black countertop, and a wooden stool in a bright kitchen with glass dishware visible.

We’ve been lab testing freestanding cookers for more than 60 years, so we’re well equipped to separate the brilliant models from the inferior ones that leave you with uneven bakes. 

We buy freestanding cookers directly from retailers just like regular shoppers do. We don’t accept freebies or samples from manufacturers, so our verdicts are never for sale. Brands can’t influence what we write in our reviews, so you can trust our verdicts.

We aren't funded by advertisers, either. Our testing is always independent, and our operating costs are covered by our members. We don’t have to answer to brands to secure our next paycheck. If a freestanding cooker is a dud, we’re free to say so.

Freestanding cooker reviews you read elsewhere may be based on a single user’s experience. We test them scientifically in a laboratory, not a kitchen. Our stringent lab test programmes let you compare freestanding cookers across different brands and price ranges to find the very best one for you.

Nobody goes to the lengths we do to find the best freestanding cookers.

Our statement of editorial independence

We’re not influenced by third parties, and we don't accept freebies from product manufacturers or retailers. As a not-for-profit organisation, we have no owners, shareholders or government departments to answer to, so we work entirely on behalf of you, the consumer – nobody else.

Read our full statement of editorial independence.

Oven: does it cook well, and how much can you fit into it?

Different recipes call for different oven temperatures, so our tests check how quickly each cooker's oven reaches two set temperatures. We set conventional electric ovens and gas ovens to 180°C (gas mark 4) and 200°C (gas mark 6), and fan-assisted electric ovens to 150°C and 180°C. As well as noting how quickly they reach these temperatures from cold, we record how closely each oven sticks to the set temperature. 

Next, we bake a tray of shortbread. The colour of this delicate bake clearly shows how effective the cooker is at spreading heat evenly throughout the oven cavity. We also bake a large sponge cake, which reveals how consistently the heat is supplied.

Manufacturer websites show the total internal dimensions of an oven, but this doesn't give a clear picture of what you will actually be able to fit into it. We record the actual usable space in each oven by measuring from side to side, and from the inside of the door to the back of the oven. For height, we measure from the top of the lowest shelf to 3cm below the top of the oven, so we can work out its real capacity. 

To find out whether you'll be able to cook a full Christmas dinner, we use a plastic turkey, chicken or roast beef joint on a roasting tray, then we add another tray to represent trimmings. 

What separates a good result from a poor one?

Top-scoring Best Buy freestanding cookers stick closely to the set temperature, so you can repeat your favourite recipes again and again without nasty surprises. They also spread heat evenly, ensuring your bakes come out a uniform golden brown, with no dark or light patches. Steer clear of one-star freestanding cookers – these are likely to leave you disappointed.

A picture of the Which? cooking expert, Jamie Mayne, on a pink background

Jamie Mayne, Which? freestanding cooker expert, says:

‘Our tests have found ovens with temperatures that veer wildly away from what you would expect, sometimes by more than 40°C. This is enough to ruin any dinner – and delicate baking will be a complete lottery.’

Ease of use: is the cooker easy to use and clean?

Our panel of lab experts judges how simple it is to use the settings on each oven, grill and hob. They also check how clear the markings are and whether you have a clear view into the oven while food is cooking.

To assess how easy cookers are to clean, we intentionally create common kitchen messes. 

For the hob, we heat cooking oil, allowing it to splatter onto the burners, and let a pan of rice boil over. We leave the grimy hobs to dry overnight, then try cleaning them with washing-up liquid and a sponge. Next, we carefully apply cooking grime to various parts of the oven and turn up the heat to bake it on. We then note how tricky it is to clean off the stains and residues and how difficult it is to access any nooks and crannies.

We also assess any self-cleaning features and note whether parts are labelled as dishwasher-safe. 

What separates a good result from a poor one?

Freestanding cookers that score five stars for ease of use and cleaning are intuitive to use and low maintenance for hassle-free everyday cooking.

If a freestanding cooker you’re considering scores poorly in our ease-of-use tests, make sure you’re prepared to give it regular elbow grease and TLC before investing.

Expert advice on all things homes and appliances

free newsletter

Sign up for our Home newsletter, it's free monthly.

Our free Home newsletter delivers home-related content, along with other information about Which? Group products and services. We won't keep sending you the newsletter if you don't want it – unsubscribe whenever you want. Your data will be processed in accordance with our privacy notice.

Hob: how well does it heat up, simmer and fry?

When you’re in a hurry to cook pasta, you don’t want to wait for your cooker’s hob to get going. That’s why we test how quickly each hob heats a pan of water from 15°C to 90°C. 

Our heat-distribution test reveals whether foods that can't be stirred, such as pancakes and omelettes, will cook evenly. We heat a frying pan to 200°C and use a thermal imaging camera to measure how well heat spreads across its base. This reveals any cold spots that could leave your food undercooked.

Our final tests record what happens after you switch off the hob – some retain heat and keep cooking your food long after the power stops, while others cool down quickly. 

What separates a good result from a poor one?

Freestanding cooker hobs that score five stars in these tests take less than five minutes to heat a pan of water from 15°C to 90°C. The slowest keep you waiting more than double that.

The best excel at the other end of the scale, too, letting you simmer delicate ingredients without leaving burnt-on residue in your saucepan.

Five-star cooker hobs also spread heat evenly across the base of a frying pan, so you won’t struggle to cook your omelettes evenly. 

Grill: how evenly does it brown food?

To test the grills on our freestanding cookers, we cover each grill pan with white crustless bread to see how well, how far and how evenly the heat spreads. 

What separates a good result from a poor one?

Grills that score five stars brown almost all the bread underneath them, but our tests have found many that struggle to heat more than 50% of the area.

One-star grills struggle to heat anything beyond the area directly below the element, so you'll have to shuffle your food around to get it evenly browned. 

Energy efficiency: does it waste energy?

Because heating times vary by food, we maintain consistency by heating 2kg of bricks in the main oven for 1 hour 40 minutes. This simulates roughly how long you might roast a large whole chicken.

We set freestanding cookers with conventional electric ovens to 200°C, electric fan ovens to 170°C and gas ovens to gas mark 6.

We measure each oven's energy use and convert it into a score based on each model's running costs.

What separates a good result from a poor one?

A freestanding cooker that scores five stars in this test is highly energy efficient and won’t spike your bills. The same can’t be said for models that score poorly.


Which? members can filter all our freestanding cooker reviews by oven and grill performance, ease of use, cleaning and more of our expert test results


How we calculate the scores

An image of Which? scientific advisor, Ruby Gordon, on a yellow background

Ruby Gordon, Which? scientific adviser, says:

‘We regularly check in with Which? members to find out what is most important to them when buying a freestanding cooker. I then use the information they provide to create a tailored test programme and evaluate the lab results. Since members said they value how energy efficient a freestanding cooker is, we doubled the energy weighting when it comes to calculating the final score and awarding badges to reflect consumer priorities.’

How the overall freestanding cooker test score is calculated:

  • 40% oven performance
  • 25% ease of use and cleaning
  • 20% hob performance
  • 10% grill performance
  • 5% energy efficiency

How we choose the products

To make sure our reviews are 100% independent, we never accept free product samples. Instead, we spend just under £30,000 every year buying freestanding cookers directly from major retailers and testing them in our lab. 

While we aim to test a representative sample of freestanding cookers each year, we will include more if there are products we simply can’t ignore. We test regularly throughout the year so we can get our reviews and verdicts to members as quickly as possible.

An image of Which? market analyst, Sarah Hiscock, on a green background.

Sarah Hiscock, Which? senior market analyst, says:

'To offer the best coverage of the freestanding cooker market, I choose products from popular brands like Beko, Hotpoint and Rangemaster, identifying the key models at major retailers like Amazon, AO and Currys.

'We don’t just test the flagship models that companies want to promote – I track product launches, market trends and consumer habits by speaking directly with manufacturers and attending events. This means we stay on top of developments and review the freestanding cookers consumers actually want to buy.’

Is it a Best Buy freestanding cooker? What our verdicts mean

The Best Buy, Great Value and Don't buy logos

Our recommendations should help you to narrow down your shortlist, but it's always best to read our reviews in full to check for any dealbreakers before parting with your hard-earned cash.

Best Buy-recommended freestanding cookers

67% or more

The freestanding cookers that impress most in our tests are Best Buys. These cookers score 67% or more and get our firm overall recommendation.

Best Buy cookers typically tick the most important boxes: they heat up quickly and accurately, grill effectively and have decent built-in hobs. 

Great Value-recommended freestanding cookers

60% or more

Freestanding cooker prices vary significantly, with some premium models costing more than £1,400.

Great Value cookers are at least 20% cheaper than the average cooker we test, and score at least 60% – so you can be sure you'll be getting a decent product at a reasonable price.

Look out for Great Value models that also score highly enough to be Best Buys.

Don't Buy freestanding cookers

45% or below

Any cooker that scores 45% or lower is a Don't Buy that's best avoided.

These models tend to fall down in the most important areas. They're awkward to use, with ovens that can't reliably bake a cake and hobs you'd struggle to even heat baked beans on. 

Our freestanding cooker experts

Running our test projects is a group effort, with several team members contributing to each one. 

We thoroughly re-evaluate our testing processes every year to ensure they're useful to you, and we ask the Which? community to tell us what matters the most when choosing a new freestanding cooker.

Here's the team that makes it happen:

From left to right: researcher & writer, Jamie Mayne; senior market analyst Sarah Hiscock, senior scientific advisor Ruby Gordon and home editor Jackie Gallego
From left to right: researcher & writer, Jamie Mayne; senior market analyst Sarah Hiscock, senior scientific advisor Ruby Gordon and home editor Jackie Gallego
  • Researcher & writer, Jamie Mayne: Jamie turns technical lab reports into in-depth, accessible product reviews and buying advice to separate the great freestanding cookers from the duds. She cuts through marketing fluff and unclear jargon to make sure you spend your money on a quality oven that serves your needs. 
  • Senior market analyst, Sarah Hiscock: Sarah tracks the freestanding cooker market to ensure we test the products you care about most. She cuts through the hype to choose a representative range you can rely on, from household names to up-and-comers. 
  • Senior scientific adviser, Ruby Gordon: Ruby helps to shape our rigorous test programme to make sure it answers our members' key questions. She meticulously converts hundreds of facts and figures into easily digestible scores and star ratings to help inform our members’ buying decisions. 
  • Home editor, Jackie Gallego: Jackie makes sure what you’re reading is what you want to know about freestanding cookers. She helps ensure consumers are informed in their buying choices by finding important stories within our lab reports, from safety considerations to solving common problems.