A survey of1,653 owners of wearables found that more than 48% of those who'd had a problem with a Garmin activity tracker reported a broken strap. It's a similar story for Fitbit, with more than 41% reporting the problem.
The brands swap places when it comes to fitness watches: 37% for Fitbit and nearly 29% for Garmin. The picture here is a little more positive but still disappointing overall.
This isn't to say that you won't experience strap problems with other brands, of course, but Garmin and Fitbit stood out particularly.
The survey, which also reported on issues with Samsung and Apple wearables, was part of Which?'s annual reliability report, designed to advise consumers on issues that others are having with popular brands and to help them pick a model that lasts.
It's fair to expect your fitness watch or activity tracker to be built to last, robust, powerful and ready for action. It's going to help you train up, after all, so you're planning to wear it for extended periods and during strenuous exercise.
Fortunately if you do have problems with straps, you shouldn't be left out in the cold.
We asked Fitbit and Garmin what you should do if your strap breaks, and how they're planning to address this in the long term.
Both brands told us that:
Fitbit told us that on its website it has stopped selling older models that don't have detachable bands (you may see them being sold elsewhere, though).
Garmin said that its new-style bands are more durable than its old ones. It said its new models have 'quick-release' bands, which you can take off and swap with a new one quite easily should you need to.
Garmin also said that all new Garmin fitness watches and activity trackers come with replacement straps and instructions showing you how to change the strap. Fitbit said that special edition models come with replacement straps in the box.
Both companies emphasised that they were committed to customer care and to developing robust products - which is as you would hope.
Our dedicated explains what constitutes a faulty product under the law, what your rights are if you have one, and it contains some handy template letters in case you need to complain.Depending on the length of time you've owned a product, find out .
Fitbit and Garmin both offer useful advice on how to care for your straps. Here are some key points to bear in mind:
If you buy a leather or metal band, it won't bewater resistant. That means soaking it might tarnish it, or cause other damage.
And, if you buy awoven or knit band, note that the Fitbit website also says that these bands 'are intended to be worn during normal daily activity'. It continues: 'They are not intended to be worn during high-intensity workouts or sleep, which could affect the overall appearance and quality of the accessory is maintained.'
Other common faults that came to light in our survey included:
While our fitness watch and activity tracker reviews can't tell you what problems will develop over time, we can tell you which ones have some of these problems from the outset. For example, we see which wearables have trouble syncing properly with a smartphone, and which have screens that are easily scratched. We also comment on the ones that are well made and sturdy.