Which? uses cookies to improve our sites and by continuing you agree to our cookies policy

Which? reveals latest toaster testing results

Discover the best toaster, and avoid the Don't Buy


Set yourself up for the day with a decent breakfast and great toast from the best toaster. We’ve tested 10 of the latest models – and discovered one to avoid.

A great toaster will deliver evenly toasted, golden brown toast again and again. But not all toasters are the same, and our tough testing keeps revealing toasters that don’t perform well enough to be crowned Best Buys.

The worst toasters struggle to fit a wide range of bread sizes, and make toast that’s patchy, stripy and uneven. And sometimes even burnt.

Which? members can find full test results and reviews for over 200 colourful 2 slice and 4 slice toasters in our toasters reviews.

If you’re not already a Which? member, you can sign up for a £1 trial subscription and get instant access to all our reviews on a wide range of kitchen appliances – including kettles, coffee machines and food processors. 

Cheap toasters

Our latest testing covers models from as little as £10, but if you think you’re getting a bargain – think again. One cheap toaster performed so badly, scoring less than 40%, we’ve made it a Don’t Buy.

This toaster is guilty of multiple toasting sins. It toasts unevenly, delivering rounds of toast that are stripy and almost like patchwork in appearance. Our experts struggled to get anything remotely evenly toasted.

A quick toaster will take less than two and a half minutes, but this one takes around three and a half minutes to toast – which is on the longer side of average. 

Discover the cheapest and best toasters, and find out which one gets the lowest score, by using our handy interactive tool to compare features and prices.

The best toaster?

The full list of toasters we’ve recently reviewed and rated is:

Russell Hobbs Jewels 19350
Breville VTT375
Cuisinart CPT2000BKU
Bosch Village TAT3014 Red
Asda 2-Slice Toaster 1570770
Argos Cookworks 909/9380
Breville Elements VTT311
Dualit Architect 46525
Tesco 4TSS11
Currys Logik LC04TC12

Matching kettles and toasters

Changing your kettle and toaster is a quick and easy, and sometimes cheap, way to update your kitchen. We list the different colour options available for each toaster, and our handy guide to choose a choosing a matching kettle and toaster set will make it easier to find the best toaster set.

More on this…

  • Make your own delicious bread and learn more about the best breadmakers
  • Complete your breakfast set with a stylish coffee maker. Choose from 20 Best Buy coffee machines
  • Does your toaster brown you, rather than your toast, off? Tell everyone in a customer review
Back to top