Best disposable nappy brands
By Anna Studman
From Pampers to Aldi nappies, and Boots to Asda nappies, see how parents rate the best disposable-nappy brands.
We all know that bringing up a baby can be expensive, and buying nappies is just one of the costs involved that can add up quickly. In the first few months, your baby will most likely use between six and 12 nappies a day. That's up to 372 nappies a month.
However, you don't have to spend a lot to get a great nappy. Using one of the best-rated brands could cost you an eye-watering £96 over three months, based on using eight size-2 newborn nappies a day. But using the cheapest highly rated brand of newborn nappies would cost you just £26 in that time, which is almost a quarter of the price.
But the best brands may not equal the perfect nappy. So we've pitted Pampers against other brands to find out which are the best disposable nappies
Pampers vs Asda, Tesco and Aldi nappies
We surveyed 3,445 UK parents, asking them to rate pricier disposable nappy brands, such as Pampers, and cheaper supermarket brands, such as Aldi, Asda and Tesco.
The best nappy brand got a customer score of 82%, but the bottom brand only scored 48% – a massive difference. Customer scores are calculated based on how satisfied parents are with a brand and how likely they are to recommend it.
To find out what separates the best and worst nappy brands, we asked parents to rate important factors, including ease of use, value for money, comfort, fit and absorbency.
Only logged-in Which? members can view our recommendations in the table below. If you’re not yet a member, you can get instant access to this table by joining Which? today.
|Disposable nappy brands|
|Brand||Absorbency||Comfort||Ease of use||Fit||Value for money||Customer score|
(see Aldi nappy reviews)
(see Asda nappy reviews)
(see Ocado nappy reviews)
(See Boots nappy reviews)
Co-operative Loved by Us
|Happy Nappy Co.|
(See Lidl nappy reviews)
(See Morrisons nappy reviews)
(See Pampers nappy reviews)
(See Sainsburys nappy reviews)
(See Superdrug nappy reviews)
(See Tesco nappy reviews)
Using the table
Star ratings and customer scores are based on an online survey of 3,445 UK parents in February 2018, who were asked to rate the nappy brands they use currently and have used in the past year. Customer score is calculated using a combination of overall satisfaction and how likely members are to recommend the brand to a friend.
Sample sizes: Aldi Mamia (818), Asda (716), Baby Ocado (71), Boots (377), Carrefour (50), Co-operative Loved by Us (99), Happy Nappy Co. (88), Huggies (623), Lidl Toujours (313), Pampers (1,238), Morrisons (341), Nature Babycare (56), Sainsbury's (487), Superdrug (95), Tesco (629), Waitrose Essential (60).
Top nappy brands: how parents rate them
We also asked parents for their comments on the nappies they use, and it was clear just how impressed they were with the two top-scorers:
- 'These nappies are head and shoulders above all other brands we have tried, both in terms of quality and price.'
- 'I always worried that cheaper nappies would not be very good. However, these nappies have been excellent.'
- 'These nappies are just amazing. The only difference from more expensive brands is the price.'
- 'I have tried many nappy brands, but I always go back to this one.'
- 'These nappies have provided good quality and comfort.'
Pampers nappies – finding the cheapest deal
Pampers is the best-known nappy brand in the UK, but it can also work out more expensive than supermarket or chemist own-brands. To help save you cash, we've tracked the price of a 44-pack of Pampers Baby Dry Size 4 maxi (8-16kg) nappies over the course of a year to see where was selling them cheapest (even with multibuy offers in place).
Find out which is the best store to get cheap Pampers nappies, where you could save more than £32 per month if you shop around.
Tips to cut the cost of disposable nappies
Whichever brand you go for, we have tips for helping you to cut costs when you're out shopping:
- Check our disposable nappy reviews to see if the cheaper brands that come top with parents are better than expensive alternatives.
- Buy the largest packs to reduce costs, but be wary of bulk-buying too much in one size (especially newborn sizes) as your baby may outgrow them sooner than you expect.
- Take advantage of special offers. If you don’t have a strong loyalty to one particular brand, special offers can really help you to save. The competition between nappy manufacturers is such that offers are often available.