We use cookies to allow us and selected partners to improve your experience and our advertising. By continuing to browse you consent to our use of cookies. You can understand more and change your cookies preferences here.


When you click on a retailer link on our site, we may earn affiliate commission to help fund our not-for-profit mission.Find out more.

31 Jul 2020

Car finance commission to be banned - how much will you save?

Regulator ban estimated to save customers £165m a year

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) announced on Tuesday that it would be banning a form of commission currently earned by some car dealers and credit brokers when selling finance.

Salespeople are often rewarded in commission for high levels of sales, but the ways the commission is calculated vary and can be complex.

An investigation last year by the FCA revealed that when it comes to arranging some types of credit - such as car finance - certain forms of commission have been incentivising sellers to unfairly hike the prices on deals, potentially leaving customers collectively overpaying by hundreds of millions of pounds every year.

Be more money savvy

Get a firmer grip on your finances with the expert tips in our Money newsletter – it's free weekly.

This newsletter delivers free money-related content, along with other information about Which? Group products and services. Unsubscribe whenever you want. Your data will be processed in accordance with our Privacy policy

What was wrong with car finance commission?

More than nine in 10 new cars were sold using car finance schemes in the past year.

Under typical finance deals, you borrow a sum of money towards the cost of the car, which is then repaid monthly - with interest - over a set term.

The money is usually lent by a finance company, such as a bank, but the deals themselves are arranged by car dealers or brokers, who are paid commission for setting up the loan.

Under some existing models of commission, which the FCA reports to be 'widespread', the amount paid to brokers rises in line with the interest rate on the finance deal.

Furthermore, under some arrangements, brokers can also control the interest rates set on individual deals. This effectively means they stand to earn more commission by making credit deals more expensive than they need to be for customers.

When will the ban kick-in?

The FCA is now banning such types of commission - a measure due to come into effect on 28 January 2021.

Firms will also have to give customers more information about the commission they are paying when entering into finance deals.

An FCA spokesperson commented: 'By banning this type of commission, where brokers are rewarded for charging consumers higher rates, we will increase competition and protection for consumers.'

How much will the ban save you?

The watchdog's analysis found that where deals are arranged through commission models like this, interest rates are routinely higher.

The FCA reckons the ban could save customers £165m a year.

With one of the commission models investigated, a typical customer on a four-year finance deal for a £10,000 car would be likely to pay around £1,100 more in interest than if the broker were paid a fixed fee.

What car finance option should you go for?

Millions of people buy new and used cars with finance each year. Here are the two main types and what to watch out for.

Hire Purchase (HP)

You pay a deposit, and then repay the remaining cost of the car, plus interest, in monthly instalments. At the end of the deal, for a usually small purchase fee, you'll own the car outright.

Be aware: The car can be repossessed if you miss a payment, and it could prove more expensive than an independent bank loan. Servicing may be included, but check all terms and conditions.

Personal Contract Purchase (PCP)

The dealer estimates how much the car will be worth at the end of the deal period (often three or four years). This estimate, which the dealer guarantees to honour, is called the Minimum Guaranteed Future Value (MGFV).

You pay a deposit and then monthly instalments over the deal period. These are based on the value of the car, minus the deposit paid and the MGFV.

At the end, you have options to either pay a lump sum ('balloon payment') to own the car outright, return the vehicle to the dealer or part exchange it for another car. With the last option, any value the car retains that's higher than the MGFV can be put towards a deposit on the new car.

Be aware: This usually suits people who like to change their car every few years. The amount you pay each month is typically lower than other forms of finance, as it's not based on the car's full value. However, if you intend to keep the car at the end, the sizeable balloon payment can make it an expensive way to pay overall.

Other ways to finance a new car

If you're trying to spread the cost of payment, other borrowing options available are leasing the vehicle (with the proviso that you won't have the opportunity to own it), or using unsecured finance options such as a personal loan or credit card.

Check the latest credit card and personal loan deals to find out if this could work for you.

A potential risk with using unsecured borrowing to buy the car is that it isn't 'secured' to the vehicle, as HP and PCP are. This means that if you can't keep up repayments, you'll not be able to hand your car back and be free of the remaining debt.