We use cookies to allow us and selected partners to improve your experience and our advertising. By continuing to browse you consent to our use of cookies. You can understand more and change your cookies preferences here.

Coronavirus Read our latest advice

Car hire comparison

Car hire broker comparison

Article 2 of 3

Put us to the test

Our Test Labs compare features and prices on a range of products. Try Which? to unlock our reviews. You'll instantly be able to compare our test scores, so you can make sure you don't get stuck with a Don't Buy.

Sign up nowor login

Using a car hire broker can increase the options open to you. But which one should you use choose? We have compared car hire brokers to show you the best and worst.

We compared six leading car hire brokers; Argus Car Hire, Auto Europe, Do You Spain, Holiday Autos, Rental Cars and Zest Car Rental to help you choose the broker most likely to meet your needs. Unlock the table to find out:

  • The car hire brokers that topped the list
  • The broker that passed our checks to become a Which? Recommended Provider
  • How consumers rate car hire brokers for clarity of information on insurance and pricing, ease of booking and customer service

These results are for members only. Please log in if you're a member, or join Which? now to get instant access to all our reviews and test results.

Car hire brokers
  The booking The experience  
  Clarity of extra charges Ease of opting out of extra charges Clarity of fuel policy Clarity of final hire cost Clarity of information about car hire supplier Overall satisfaction with car hire supplier Customer Score
Argus Car Hire Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content
Auto Europe Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content
Do You Spain Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content
Holiday Autos Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content
Rental Cars Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content
Zest Car Rental Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content Subscriber only content
Clarity of extra charges eg insurance costs, additional drivers, child seats, sat nav etc.
Clarity of fuel policy on picking and dropping off the car.
Customer service during after the booking process.
Overall satisfaction with car hire supplier that supplied the keys to your hire car.

How we rate car hire brokers

In January 2019, we asked Which? members to complete an online survey about their experience using a car hire broker in the last 12 months. Results are based on 1,923 member experiences.

SHARE THIS PAGE

previous

Best and worst car hire companies

next

Recommended car hire companies