We use cookies to allow us and selected partners to improve your experience and our advertising. By continuing to browse you consent to our use of cookies. You can understand more and change your cookies preferences here.

Cathedral City and Pilgrims Choice beaten by cheap supermarket cheese in Which? taste test

Just one own-label extra mature cheddar was judged good enough to be named a Best Buy – while one of the big brands came last

Cathedral City and Pilgrims Choice beaten by cheap supermarket cheese in Which? taste test

Save money on your shopping this week by steering clear of big-brand cheeses and choosing our Best Buy supermarket cheddar instead.

Our panel of more than 60 cheese-lovers blind-tasted slices from Cathedral City and Pilgrims Choice, as well as 10 own labels, including Aldi, Asda, Tesco, Sainsbury’s and more.

Only one supermarket cheese, costing less than both the branded options, was named a Best Buy. It impressed our tasters with its smooth texture and mature flavour. Meanwhile, one of the premium cheddars ranked joint last.

But, if our supermarket winner isn’t stocked in your local shop, our testing also revealed a handful of well-rounded cheddars that would still make a welcome addition to your cheeseboard.

Find out which cheese came out on top in our extra mature cheddar taste test.


Tips for living well – get our free Food & Health newsletter: shop savvy, eat well, stay healthy


How much difference is there between extra mature cheddar cheese brands?

Woman reading cheese packet

The cheeses may all look similar once they’re on your plate, but our tests identified marked differences in taste and aroma.

Our panel’s favourites were full of flavour while striking just the right balance between creaminess and firmness. The worst were pale and bland and could leave you wondering if you’d accidentally picked up a mild cheddar instead.

There’s also a clear difference in price, with some costing twice as much as others per 100g.

If you were to buy a block of Cathedral City every week for a year, it would set you back around £145. Our Best Buy would cost just £104 a year, while one great value option comes in at just £93. That’s a potential saving of up to £50 for thrifty cheese fiends.


The A-Z of wine pairings – see which wine you should be serving with your cheddar cheese


The cheapest place to buy branded cheese

Slicing mature cheddar

If you’re loyal to one of the big brands but still like to bag a bargain, keep scrolling.

Every day, we record the prices of hundreds of branded grocery products in each of the UK’s most popular supermarkets, so we can track prices over time*.

Although we didn’t see any patterns in how often Cathedral City and Pilgrims Choice were on offer, we did see that, on average, some supermarkets are notably cheaper than others.

For example, the cheapest supermarket if you want to buy a 350g pack of Cathedral City extra mature cheddar was Lidl, with an average price of £2.50. The most expensive was Waitrose, where the same product was £3.21 on average.

For Pilgrims Choice Extra Mature Cheddar, Asda works out as the cheapest, with an average price of £2.36 for a 350g pack. Waitrose is the most expensive supermarket again, charging customers around £3.12 per pack. 


Warm up this weekend with a slice of cheese on toast and a hot cup of our best ground coffee


How we tested extra mature cheddar cheese

cheese on a bread board

The products were assessed by a large panel of consumers who regularly buy and consume extra mature cheddar cheese.

The make-up of the panel broadly represents the demographic profile of adults in the UK.

Each extra mature cheddar cheese was assessed by 64 people.

The panellists rated the taste, texture, aroma and appearance of each product and told us what they liked and disliked about each one.

The taste test was blind, so the panellists didn’t know which brand they were trying. The order they sampled the extra mature cheddar cheese was fully rotated to avoid any bias.

Each panellist had a private booth so they couldn’t discuss what they were tasting or be influenced by others.

The overall score is based on:

  • 50% taste
  • 20% aroma
  • 15% texture
  • 15% appearance.

These weightings are based on consumer rankings of the importance of different extra mature cheddar attributes.


From baked beans and chips to red wine and champagne, find out which products our tasters rate in our guide to the best food and drink.


*Figures based on pricing data for Asda, Morrisons, Ocado, Sainsbury’s, Tesco and Waitrose Nov 2020-Nov 2021. Lidl data from Feb 2021-Nov 2021.

Back to top
Back to top