NFU Mutual car insurance review

While the car insurance policy offered by the NFU Mutual Insurance Society is available to the general public, it doesn't cover all risks and postcodes (particularly in major cities). The insurer prioritises the personal touch: it doesn't sell policies online, but you can buy over the phone or visit one of its 300 local branches.

What you need to know about NFU Mutual's car insurance:

• No set-up, adjustment or cancellation fees
• Unlimited cover on windscreens, windows and sunroofs
• Unlimited cover for audio equipment, sat nav and child car seats

Which? members can log in to see the results of our analysis. If you’re not already a member, you can sign up to a one month trial for Which? Money for just £1 to access this review and enjoy the benefits of a Which? membership.

Car Insurance

NFU Mutual review

Overall Which? score

Our total score score combines both the Which? Customer Score, ratings from real customers of the provider, and our expert analysis of the provider's policies. The total score is made up of 50% of the Customer Score and 50% of the car insurance policy score.

Which? customer score

Which?'s rating for customer satisfaction, based on feedback from real customers. The score is made up of a customer's overall satisfaction with the brand, and how likely they are to recommend that brand.

Policy score

Which?'s rating of the quality of this company's car insurance policy. We analysed 58 features of its cover to calculate the policy score.

Sign up for a £1 trial for Which? Money to reveal NFU Mutual’s score

NFU Mutual’s car insurance policy: is it good or bad?

We analyse and rate the 58 most important elements of standard car insurance policies to come up with the overall policy score. We assess how important each individual element is to drivers when choosing and using a car insurance policy, and weight it accordingly when calculating our total policy score.

Initially, we score all of the product elements out of five, reflecting how competitive each provider is in this area compared with other insurers. Weightings are then applied to the higher and lower element scores to enhance/reduce their impact on the overall product score.

Table last updated in January 2019. Next updated in January 2020.

Most important policy elementsSecondary policy elementsOther policy elements

Policy element	Rating	Details
Interest charged on payment by instalments (APR)	5 out of 5	0.00%
No fault no claims discount (NCD) benefit?	5 out of 5	Yes
Uninsured driver NCD benefit?	5 out of 5	Yes
Renewal fee		No fee
NCD protection claims (number per year)		2 claims in 5 years
Theft of keys limit		No limit
Fire excess (standard compulsory)		£0
Theft excess (standard compulsory)		£100
Accidental damage excess (standard compulsory)		£0

Policy element	Details	Rating
Personal belongings limit
Medical expenses limit
Liability limit for property damage (including legal expenses)
Legal Expenses - Limit
Legal Expenses - Deadline to make a claim
Legal Expenses - Covered if Driver Uninsured?
Keys in car exclusion
Adjustment fee
Duplicate documents fee
Cancellation fee within cooling off period
Cancellation fee after cooling off period
Windscreen limit
Windows limit
Sunroof limit
Loss of keys limit
Uninsured driver excess liability
Courtesy car
Courtesy car - guaranteed availability?
Courtesy car limit
Windscreen replacement excess (standard compulsory)
Driver under 21 excess (standard compulsory)
Driver 21-24 excess (standard compulsory)
Repairs Guarantee Period
Vandalism Promise

Policy element	Details	Rating
Legal expenses cover
Notice if insurer cancels
Audio limit - manufacturer
Sat Nav limit - manufacturer
Child car seat cover
New car replacement - damage
New car replacement - period
Total loss courtesy car
Total loss courtesy car period
Windscreen repair excess (standard compulsory)
24 hour emergency helpline
24 hour windscreen helpline
24 hour legal advice helpline
Misfuelling cover
Driving other cars extension
Driving other cars - emergency cover only?
Driving other cars - only covers main policyholder?
Driving other cars - cover in Europe?
Windscreen damage - claim affect NCD?
Windows damage - claim affect NCD?
Sunroof damage - claim affect NCD?
Driving abroad - courtesy car cover?
Driving abroad - Days per trip comprehensive cover available
Driving abroad - Days per year comprehensive cover available
Contact Number

Get top money-saving tips from Which?

Sign up to the Which? Money Weekly newsletter to get our latest news, tips and deals straight to your inbox.